Heavyweight wine list. Glossy decor. A menu with a dozen massive, meaty options. Smack bang in the heart of London’s moneyzone and a stone’s throw from the Bank of England. Every box checked. I therefore thought I had a pretty good picture of the kind of restaurant M Threadneedle Street was before I’d even walked through the door for my review. Frankly, places like this don’t tend to float my boat. While I love a great piece of red meat, I don’t enjoy the macho swagger that seems to come on the side with hundred pound steaks. I also don’t like tables of loud all-male diners taking part in protein-fuelled one upmanship. And I really don’t like private members’ clubs, which M partly is (more on that later).
But, from the moment we sat down for a late mid-week lunch, to when we left, many many hours later, M managed to buck the trend followed by so many of the City’s steak restaurants. This is the place to go if you really like eating properly kept and cooked cow, without having to sign up to being a city boy twat.
It would be easy to dine out exclusively on moomeat here. Starters included the rather lumpen sounding wagyu dumplings, through to beef tartare (also wagyu) as well as a fistful of main steak options.
The place to go if you really like eating properly kept and cooked cow, without having to sign up to being a city boy twat…
We however opted to kick things off with some raw tuna. This left room for us also to try the beef tartare. The tuna was clearly high grade, pale purple, fresh and diced into cubes a little too dinky for my liking. The fish sat on some wasabi crème fraiche, liberally sprinkled with caviar. The caviar was excellent. Every egg popping in the mouth and a fun albeit flash way to season up some fish. My only gripe was with the spiced soy ‘firecracker’ dressing. The only good aspect was the fact they serve it on the side. Chilli and caviar don’t make good bedfellows. So, if you order the tuna, I suggest you leave the ‘firecracker’ sauce in its pot.
The tartare was finished table side by our chilled and charming waiter, who shaved a pile of flash frozen foie gras over the meat, after he had smoked the whole dish with some apple wood under a glass bell jar. Personally I don’t think the foie added much to the actual taste of the dish, but it was fun to watch and did no harm (except to the goose, natch). The smoke really worked, providing a nice bitterness against the sweet, razor-thin slices of apple dressing the dish. I partly love food smoked tableside because I spent most of my 20s puffing on Gauloises blues in an ill-conceived attempt to channel some Gallic charm. I still miss the hot little death sticks, but I promise the smoke was more than a gimmick or some sad form of cigarette replacement therapy.
Next up, faced with too many options for mains, I asked the kitchen for a selection of their steak highlights. I honestly couldn’t choose a cut, and I reckoned, when in Rome, eat too much meat. As Nero might have said between bouts of matricide and incest. This option will set you back around £150, which sounds a lot until I tell you the heaving board of perfectly cooked (by which I mean rare) cuts would easily have fed four. We had USDA fillet, Argentinian sirloin and rump (the best of the lot, all flavour and a much cheaper cut than the rest) and a British rib eye. All were at the top of their game. If this were a meat Olympiad though, Argentina would have won.
The tartare was finished table side by our chilled and charming waiter…
At this point I spotted the chef mooching about the dining room, gave him a wave and he came over. We then got into a ridiculously intense and entirely enjoyable conversation about the provenance of their beef. I was, as they say over at the Golden Arches, already lovin’ it. And that was before he took me to the dry-ageing chamber. It was at this point I started to truly appreciate these guys are serious meat geeks.
They’ve built a full-on Himalayan pink salt chamber in which to hang the sides of cow before breaking them down. The only other place I know with this kind of kit is Peter Hannan, a Northern Irish butcher who counts me and, slightly more impressively, Richard Corrigan amongst his clients. Nobody ages meat like this this unless they really care about the end product. For a start, it means you lose 20-25% off each joint as the moisture is drawn out of the meat. That’s a quarter off your bottom line before you’ve cut a single steak. What it does, apart from costing the restaurant an arm and a leg, is intensify the flavour of the meat.
Amongst all the butch carcasses, I spotted an odd looking buttery yellow triangle. It was about the size and proportions of one of those giant Toblerones you buy at the airport when you forget to get something for your kids. The chef explained this was a wagyu sirloin which was sealed and aged in beeswax. Even for a food-freak like me, this was a first, but apparently they do it in Japan, so fair play.
Even for a food-freak like me, this was a first…
Having chatted about the beebeef (not its brand name yet but I’m open to offers from the Wagyu collective), we decided we had to give it a go. What arrived was thinly sliced, just-seared beef, served with some aged viscous soy and chopsticks. Nowt else. I picked a piece up, dipped it in the soy and popped it in my mouth. It rendered me speechless for at least a minute (a personal best). It was beyond beefy. My tastebuds were immediately overwhelmed by the meltingly-soft, super-rich, creamy fat counterbalanced with the rare meat and cut through with soy the texture and power of which reminded me of proper balsamic vinegar (also a great meat condiment). Okay, full disclosure, a 150g portion will set you back £115 so this is a special occasion treat. Unless you’re Elon Musk, although he would probably prefer some chia seeds and robot loving.
Now as well as serving up some excellent grub, M has quite the wine list. My main problem with high-end lists is that they tend to tack hard to the restaurant standard 3x markup on bottles, even when you reach the three figure mark. This has never made any sense to me. It discourages all but Russian oligarchs from exploring the interesting stuff because you know you’re being scalped. For example, if a wine retails at £20 then you’ll pay around £60 in a restaurant so a £40 mark up for having them store and serve it. I can handle that. But if a wine costs £100 in a shop you’ll usually be paying £300-350 for the pleasure of drinking it in a restaurant. That’s hundreds of pounds for the effort of cellaring it then pulling the cork. Which is robbery.
A 150g portion will set you back £115 so this is a special occasion treat…
M have decided to part ways with the old style markup. They simply add £50 to the retail cost of their finest wines. It’s a refreshing approach, unheard of in this part of town and I genuinely hope it catches on like Covid (I think we’re ready for Covid jokes now, but let me know if I misjudged the mood. Perhaps with a little cough to attract my attention…).
As we headed to the door after a seriously fun lunch, I happened to hear the unmistakable click clack of a pool table. I love the game, having had a coin operated ex pub table in my bedroom throughout my teenage years, which then travelled up to uni with me (really helped those grades). Sniffing like a hound after a fox I followed the sounds upstairs and discovered a whole new side to M. You see, it’s not just a restaurant.
For a grand a year you can join their members’ club. This opens up a warren of comfy, cognac leather clad private dens, rooms and bars. And you get money off food and drink. With the Olympics now upon us, I have my eye firmly on the TV den upstairs. It’s decorated with wall-to-wall high end spirits and crying out for someone (me) to waste a day watching sport and drinking a little glass of something suitable.
I happened to hear the unmistakable click clack of a pool table…
Membership also gives you the chance to attend a load of fun-sounding events. For example lunch with Brian Lara (one of my life’s ambitions). Or to attend some polo event, if you’re an estate agent with a Prada man bag.
A place in the heart of the City where you can enjoy exceptional steaks without the bray of the red braces brigade, drink stellar wine without being ripped off and, should the fancy take you, become a member of a club without feeling like a bit of a dick. M(iraculous).
Find it: 2 & 3 Threadneedle Walk, 60 Threadneedle Street, The City, EC2R 8HP
Click it: www.mrestaurants.co.uk
‘Gram it: @mrestaurants
If you read a lot of these you’ll be familiar with this line at the bottom. It always says something like ‘if you enjoyed Ari’s restaurant review of M Threadneedle Street then click here for more‘. It’s an SEO ruse so we can shoehorn ‘M Threadneedle Street ‘into the same sentence as ‘restaurant review’. See, we just did it again. But if you enjoyed this, please do read more like it (here are all Ari’s). And do subscribe to The Sauce – it’s free!
