High Steaks Player: Why Newly Opened Cordelia’s Is Seriously Good

There are plenty of places in Mayfair where you can drop £100 or more on a steak. It’s become almost de rigueur at these temples of beef, for a raw cuts board to be presented to you, the waiter taking you through every bit of cow on offer, before you’ve even had a drink. At some of these places, you even get to choose your knife. The cutlery you’re typically offered is generally so sharp and substantial it seems more suited to killing the cow than simply slicing up a sirloin. The bloody meat and array of eating swords are meant to make you feel macho and forget the three figures you just dropped on your main. This week’s review, Cordelia’s, is a spendy steak place in Mayfair, but it offers none of these gimmicks. Instead, they let the meat, and their open fire charcoal grill do all the talking.

So our steaks, a 300g ribeye and a 250g Wagyu bavette, the former just north, the latter just south of the £50 mark, were only presented once cooked, rested and ready to eat. And with not a drop forged knife in sight. They arrived on a heated marble board, heavy enough to give waiters Popeye forearms, but also a useful piece of kit to keep the meat warm while we tucked in.

The bavette, from Australia, was as good as it gets. The outside had a dark crust from its proper char over fire. Inside was ruby red, cooked medium rare, rested so that not a single drop of blood leaked out when we cut into it, and accurately seasoned. This last point is fundamental. You can’t fix under-seasoned meat after cooking it. Adding salt at the end gives a superficial saltiness, but it doesn’t work its way into the meat. By comparison, the rib eye wasn’t quite up there. Although a beautiful piece of dry-aged meat, it hadn’t seen enough of the fire to melt the fat that makes rib eye so tasty. It needed another minute on the coals and another shake of the cellar to be a 10/10. 

The bavette, from Australia, was as good as it gets…

By the time the beef arrived, I’d already worked my way through a very fine gin martini. It was twice the size of what you’d normally get in this part of town. With the cocktail, I downed a couple Carlingford rocks (£5 a pop). They were so firm, fresh and full of flavour that they could have masqueraded as Gillardeaus. The pal doesn’t do oysters, so instead of ordering another dozen of these beauties for starters proper, we shared a pair of giant tiger prawns in a spicy bisque (£32) and Cornish crab and caviar tacos (£28). I wasn’t a fan of the mayo/creamy dressing that the crab came in. The texture and sweetness of the crab meat became lost amidst the richness of the sauce. But they were undoubtedly tasty, moreish bites.

The prawns though, were simply superb. Two of them arrived on their (Cordelia branded) plate, each the size of a 10 year old’s forearm. It’s not as weird a comparator as it sounds, if you factor in that I have kids around this age. Although comparing something edible with your child’s limbs is, I fear, still going to seem a little odd to some of you. The heads were left on, the body had been both shelled and deveined, making it an easy eat (we’re back to prawns now, keep up). They were of the highest quality and grilled so that the flesh was firm and cooked through. And without any hint of the rubberiness than can set in if you leave them on the heat too long.

They were of the highest quality…

But the real star of the show was the bisque. Glossy, sunset-red, it pooled around the prawns, begging to be scooped up with the home made focaccia they’d brought when we sat down. The only time I enjoy bread these days is as a vehicle to soak up a superior sauce. And this bisque demanded a full mop up. I asked the front of house, Carlos, how they’d infused the bisque with so much prawn flavour. He told me they make it not only with the shells, but with smaller whole prawns. So they make their stock using ingredients which most restaurants would send out as a fancy starter.

We need to talk about Carlos. It would be so easy for Cordelia’s to feel like just another soulless, corporate meat joint, designed to part hedge funders from a sliver of their bonuses. But the place has soul, good humour and feels fun. And that has a lot to do with Carlos. This is a man who, it was clear, has been running the show in high end joints for many years. So, yes, he was utterly competent and a master of his art.

But beyond that, he made us laugh half a dozen times, including when he gently took the mickey out of me when I mixed up a couple wines we were drinking by the glass (we tried an Aussie Pinot which cost in the mid £70s a bottle and a Brouilly in the mid £60s, of which the Pinot had a little more to it and went better with the meat). Carlos also told us stories about members of his team, which celebrated their skill rather than pointing up his own. He was nothing less than an utter joy. His presence is a large part of the reason Cordelia’s has real character. 

We need to talk about Carlos…

I finished up with a final cocktail, a play on a Last Word (with mezcal replacing the gin) made by a barman who had hair like Charles I and an air of insouciance that belied the fervent effort and industry he brought to his boozecraft. This cocktail, when made well, is a little smoky (thanks to the mezcal), a little herbal (from the green chartreuse), with a touch of cherry sweetness balanced with fresh lime. And Cordelia’s version was a stellar example of its kind. It takes effort, skill and experience to make a drink like this. Just like it does to give your guests such a memorable lunch. This place has has the lot. 

Find it: 6 Clarges Street, Mayfair, W1J 8AE
Click it: www.cordeliasmayfair.com
‘Gram it: @cordeliasmayfair

If you enjoyed Ari’s review of Cordelia’s in Mayfair, then click here for more like it. Cordelia’s recently opened,, so click here for more new restaurant news.

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!