Each year I’m struck that the most important celebrations, Christmas, my birthday, whatever Battle Of The Boyne Day is (every year, Apple, every year) are allocated just a single day. But pies get a whole week. Like Desperate Dan runs whatever government department decides our national holidays. And while National Pie Week, this year from 2nd to 8th March, may not be marked off in highlighter in your diary, we decided to come up with as many reasons as possible to celebrate it. Hold onto your crusts, here are London’s best pie restaurants…
We’re going to be pretty liberal with our description of a pie. Is a shepherd’s pie a pie? It is when it’s at The Ivy. Does fish pie count? If you’re Richard Corrigan, then we’ll allow anything. What about apple pie? No, Jim from American Pie, probably not.
The Pie Room At Holborn Dining Room, Holborn
With a space dedicated to the art of pies, the Holborn Dining Room consistently tops out any pie-based listicles. Which is fair, given their commitment to the cause.
Consistently tops out any pie-based listicles…
Dubbed The Pie Room, the niche kitchen within the Holborn Dining Room doubles as a private dining room in the evenings. But its day job, churning out pie for the restaurant as well as takeaway pies (put in an order in if you’re picnicking, they’re some of the best in London) is pastrytastic.
The range isn’t huge, there are normally about half a dozen pies ‘on’, but the quality is consistently high.
Find it: 252 High Holborn, Holborn (I think they’re over trying to rebrand it Midtown), WC1V 7EN
Click it: www.holborndiningroom.com
‘Gram it: @holborndiningroom
Kerridge’s Bar & Grill, Westminster
Tom Kerridge seems to have a telepathic link to my belly. He’s a chef who just knows how to get digestive juices stewing, and you can bet that a decent pie is fully in his wheelhouse. After all, his original Michelin Star was awarded to his (albeit posh) pub, and pies are the very heart of any pub menu.
Tom Kerridge seems to have a telepathic link to my belly…
And the pies run through to his rather more grand digs at The Corinthia, Kerridge’s Bar & Grill.
And would you know it, on cue there’s his signature pig’s cheek pie. It comes with truffled clotted cream mash and devilled sauce. And that’s about all I can say on the matter because I’m now so hungry that I’ve got to make a dash for the fridge…
Find it: 10 Northumberland Avenue, Westminster, WC2N 5AE
Click it: www.kerridgesbarandgrill.co.uk
‘Gram it: @kerridgesbandg
Putney Pies, Putney
There’s more than awesome alliteration going on at Putney Pies. Along with the claim to be the ‘finest pies in the land’ (we’ll be the judge), the pie shop refuses to be… just another pie shop.
There’s more than awesome alliteration going on at Putney Pies…
Along with a traditional pie menu, the Thames-side restaurant is furnished as you might expect, with benches and wooden tables (so far, so pie shop) there’s a full on DJ hosting a full-on rave and one of the borough’s most exciting music venues. As unexpected as it is welcome.
And, let’s face it, when you’re ‘out out’ there’s nothing you crave more than a brilliant pie. The finest in all the land, no less…
Find it: 2 Putney High Street, Putney, SW15 1SL
Click it: www.putneypies.co.uk
‘Gram it: @putney_pies
St John, Smithfield
The godfathers of meat, St John are a no-brainer for anyone with a pie craving. Take, for instance, their venison pie (pictured).
The godfathers of meat…
It comes with a bone marrow chimney in the centre of its golden suet crust. Inside, long-braised and tender venison shoulder combine with juniper, herbs and red wine and the juices from the central veal bone.
It’s served with buttery mash and purple sprouting broccoli dressed with a mustard-dressing.
It looks incredible. Eat it at the restaurant for the full effect, or order it via their ‘Dispatch’ delivery system. Without doubt one of London’s best pie restaurants.
Find it: 26 St John Street, Smithfield, EC1M 4AY
Click it: www.stjohnrestaurant.com
‘Gram it: @st.john.restaurant
Rosi At The Beaumont, Mayfair
The Beaumont has always been one of London’s pie-lights. Both as Rosi and in its previous guise as The Colony Grill, pies are front-and-centre.
At the time of writing you can actually visit Rosi and enjoy pie for starters, main and pudding, which sounds positively heavenly.
They’ve got a limited-edition menu showcasing the best of British pies. These include a hand-raised gala pie, a hearty fish pie and a nostalgic banoffee pie.
There’s also a butter pie, which is a Lancashire delicacy that reflects Rosi’s Culinary Director and acclaimed chef Lisa Goodwin-Allen’s heritage.
This is the ultimate in comfort food, and some of the best pies you’ll find in any restaurant in London.
Find it: 8 Balderton Street, Mayfair, W1K 6TF
Click it: www.thebeaumont.com
‘Gram it: @thebeaumontldn
Charlie’s at Brown’s, Mayfair
Always leaping at a chance to rave about Charlie’s at the brilliant Brown’s Hotel, of course there’s a pie.
Of course there’s a pie…
The restaurant, under Adam Byatt (Michelin Starred for Trinity in Clapham), is exquisite and we have no doubt that the British Game Pie is too.
The pie comes with buttered savoy cabbage. You may want to add the triple cooked chips and a night’s stay to your bill.
Find it: 33 Albemarle Street, Mayfair, W1S 4BP
Click it: www.roccofortehotels.com
‘Gram it: @browns_hotel
Bob Bob Ricard, Soho
This has to be one of the prettiest pies in London! Bob Bob Ricard generally has an eye for the aesthetic, witness the stunning interiors and the much tagged ‘Press For Champagne’ buttons on each table. And the pies.
It’s one of London’s best pie restaurants thanks to the British and French menu’s crust-toped selection, including their Truffle and Champagne Humble Pie.
The indulgent dish is made with Bollinger Champagne (yes!), Jerusalem artichokes, mushroom, celariac, baby onions and truffle velouté under a puff pastry lid.
Find it: 1 Upper James Street, Soho, W1F 9DF
Click it: www.bobbobricard.com
‘Gram it: @bobbobricard
FOWL, St James’s
Feeling peckish? Forget Chicken Cottage and the like, FOWL is here for all your finger lickin’ needs.
FOWL is a ‘beak to feet’ chicken restaurant from the highly successful Fallow. And they really do use every part of the bird.
For example, their chicken head pie. Which is a pie… with a chicken’s head poking out the top. Shades of Sing A Song Of Sixpence aside, what’s exciting is what’s inside.
Available on Sundays, the dish contains chicken liver, chicken hearts, chicken feet and chicken wings. And the head.
Find it: 52 Haymarket, St James’s, SW1Y 4RP
Click it: www.fowlrestaurant.com
‘Gram it: @fowlrestaurant
The Windmill, Mayfair
The Windmill is a pie-heavy pub in the back streets of Mayfair, just off Conduit Street. And it’s great for reasonably priced (for Mayfair) pies. It’s also the place I once met Shaggy, yes actual Mr Bombastic Shaggy, who was there with the Jamaican athletic team during the 2012 olympics.
Actual Mr Bombastic Shaggy…
If it’s good enough for Usain Bolt and Shaggy then it’s good enough for us. It is, after all, one of London’s best pie connoisseurs, and a great pub and restaurant to boot.
Self-described on Google as ‘quirky’ (an online dating red flag if ever there was one) the relatively conventional pub boasts a long pie list.
Find it: 6-8 Mill Street, Mayfair, W1S 2AZ
Click it: www.windmillmayfair.co.uk
‘Gram it: @windmill_pub
The Ivy, Covent Garden
And to The Ivy. The real Ivy. The Kate Moss and Noel Gallagher, nineties hip place to be seen Ivy. And to eat shepherds’ pie.
The real Ivy…
The menu item remains a staple across the now sprawling group, but you really have to enjoy it at the O.G. Ivy on West Street.
And it won’t disappoint. The pie tastes as rich and delicious as it looks. Other than Lord Archer’s annual Krug and Shepherds’ Pie Christmas bash, it’s the only place to be seen scoffing the stuff.
Read our review of The Ivy (original Ivy) here…
Find it: 1-5 West Street, Covent Garden, WC2H 9NQ
Click it: www.ivycollection.com
‘Gram it: @the_ivy_collection
M. Manze, Peckham
M. Manze Pie & Mash has been in the pie business for as long as anyone can remember. Since 1902 the Peckham (and Sutton and London Bridge) pie, mash and eel shop has been serving the things up in true London style.
True London style…
The pies (which they also deliver hot and cold) are served with mashed potato and liquor (which contains a secret ingredient).
Run by the same family for four generations, with pies made daily onsite, it’s the ultimate traditional London dining experience.
Find it: 105 Peckham High Street, Peckham, SE15 5RS
Click it: www.manze.co.uk
‘Gram it: @manzespieandmash
Bentley’s, Mayfair
Anything Richard Corrigan does just seems to work. He’s a genius chef and knows exactly how to make great tasting food that everyone wants to eat.
Anything Richard Corrigan does just seems to work…
Which brings us to Bentley’s and the finest fish pie in London. The restaurant is a delight, and the fish is fresh out of the water. The fish pie is a creamy, buttery, potatoey wonder.
We reviewed Bentley’s and we loved it, by the way. If you get a chance then go!
Find it: 11-15 Swallow Street, Mayfair, W1B 4DG
Click it:www.bentleys.org
‘Gram it: @bentleysoysterbar
Walmer Castle, Notting Hill
Notting Hill’s Walmer Castle brings us back to pubs. Albeit posh ones. And this Ledbury Road classic is lays on some pie-tastic fare.
At the time of writing, there’s a a limited-edition beef shin and oyster pie. The novel pairing takes its inspiration from Victorian London, where these were natural pie-fellows. So much so they were referenced by Dickens himself.
If a deep-fried oyster doesn’t float your boat then the smart pub runs a rotating ‘pie of the day’ menu.
Find it: 58 Ledbury Road, Notting Hill, W11 2AJ
Click it: www.walmercastle-nottinghill.co.uk
‘Gram it: @walmercastlenottinghill
Fallow, St James’s
When your Chef-in-residence is none other than the former head pie maker at the Pie Room inside Holborn Dining Room, then you know that we’re about to hit peak pie. Chef Nokx Majozi knocks the socks off most pie makers on this list, noted as a genuine pie-oneer…
Knocks the socks off most pie makers on this list…
And she’s a perfect fit at Fallow, a wonder of the London dining scene and a place where meat is treated with the utmost respect. And her pie-spertise is on display across the menu. Expect innovation, fun and, most of all, some of the best pies you’ve ever tasted..
Find it: 52 Haymarket, St James’s, SW1Y 4RP
Click it: www.allowrestaurant.com
‘Gram it: @fallowrestaurant
Open Gate Brewery London, Covent Garden
Guinness and pies are natural platefellows, with the stout playing the lead role in many a one over the ages.
But the arrival of a Guinness brewery in Covent Garden is an opportunity to pie lovers to see how it’s meant to be done. The restaurant, overseen by Calum Franklin (self-dubbed ‘London’s Pie King’) has pies on the go at all times.
Try the rich Braised beef and Guinness pie with slow cooked beef cheek and caramelised onion in a deeply savoury Guinness gravy. It’s delicious. Or the chicken, tarragon and mushroom pie layered with wild mushrooms and mustard sauce. They’re baked fresh and come served with mash or colcannon (mash, but make it Irish) and, of course, a pint of Guinness.
Find it: 1 Mercer Walk, Covent Garden, WC2H 9FA
Click it: www.opengatelondon.guinness.com
‘Gram it: @guinnessbreweryldn
