If you’re obsessed with restaurants, as I am, then this job is the adult equivalent of being a kid let loose in a sweet shop. Every week new opportunities present themselves, to try the latest opening, menu relaunch or concept from London’s next uberchef. And I rush hither and thither, munching my way through the latest novelty. Before truffling off for a new fix, like an ADHD piglet. But sometimes, you need to breathe. Pause. Relax. Ignore the siren calls of the newest food trend. And go home. By which I don’t mean actually go home, but returning to a classic. And specifically, to a restaurant that’s been around since Armistice Day. The Ivy. Don’t ask me which. There is and will always be only one Ivy, a flying wedge of a building, jutting out on West Street, like the prow of a ship, over Theatreland, and this week’s review.
Theatre and The Ivy go hand in hand. Luvvies have always made a beeline for its art deco space, stained glass windows that both sparkle like jewels and stop the riff raff seeing in, and strict table hierarchy. The corner banquettes for four, like the old table 16 (more of which later) were favourites of the famous. Although I also like sitting nearer to the beautiful horseshoe shaped bar.
When you go, try to make sure they don’t seat you too near the entrance to the dining room, if you can possibly help it. The further in you get, the more fun it is. You want to be cosseted by this place, trust me. So, needing the welcome embrace of the Grande Dame of our restaurant scene, I decided to return to The Ivy and for the first time, cast my reviewer’s eye over the place.
Theatre and The Ivy go hand in hand…
The late great(est of them all) Adrian Gill used the single page menu at The Ivy as a template by which to judge all other menus. He adored the place so much he wrote a book about it, ‘The Ivy: The Restaurant and its Recipes’. It reads more like a love letter than a cookbook. And he and Anthony Bourdain are the two reasons I write about food, so this place really means something to me.
I haven’t eaten at The Ivy for a good few years but, walking under the green awning and up to the service desk, it all came flooding back. We used to arrive, usually a gaggle of at least four good mates, generally already well oiled, and use what we thought was our irrepressible charm to try to winkle a primo table as we tumbled in. Little could we appreciate, in those days, that decisions about who sits where are made several hours before service, with military precision, by the team.
It all came flooding back…
We would always, always start with a martini. So, on this rather nostalgic lunch, that was my very first order. Cold and clear as crystal, with a single fat, gordal olive. Dry but not too dry, the clean lick of gin tickled up with a taste of vermouth. In a generous measure, in an iced glass. That’s how it should be, and was, done. We drank our martinis perched at the beautiful bar which sits right in the middle of the dining room. It had a full facelift ten years back, with acres of coral onyx, fantastic pink, deco, stools and glossy brass fixtures. It’s one of the most gorgeous bars on the planet, manned almost entirely by ultra smooth Italians in beautiful pale green silk smoking jackets.

We finished our drinks and headed over to our table, by the window and next to what used to be table 16. Our waitress, who’d been working at The Ivy for over 18 years recalled that old banquette for four, now split into two tops 9 and 9A but still the best place to sit. The menu hadn’t changed much. A very good thing. A journey through the house classics beckoned…
It had a full facelift ten years back…
So, we ordered the duck and watermelon salad, followed by Dover sole meunière and then shepherds’ pie to finish. Many, many words have been written about each of these dishes at The Ivy. But none by me until today so, forgive my indulgence, but I’m going to have my own crack.
Duck salad. It doesn’t sound exciting. Many of you might ignore this on the menu. Don’t. It’s such an accomplished dish. The duck was crispy, a bit like what you get in Cantonese restaurants. The fat of the skin was perfectly counterpointed with the juicy watermelon and scattering of cashews, giving each bite a richness, crunch then freshness. And I got to eat this hedonistic delight whilst pretending I was healthily salading.
It’s such an accomplished dish…
Dover sole are mottled, sandy coloured flatfish native to our waters. The flesh is white and mellow, almost sweet tasting, so can take on fairly robust sauces. But for me it always tastes best with butter. Luckily, Meunière roughly translates as ‘shit loads of butter (and some parsley)’. This dish is deceptively simple and so utterly reliant on the quality of the fish and the care with which it’s handled by the kitchen. Thick tranches of sole arrived, drenched in butter, cooked to firmness but not beyond. The fish had been unobtrusively filleted, with serious skill, at table by our waitress, who definitely gave off vibes she’d done the 10,000 hours required utterly to master her trade. It was a perfect piece of cooking. I can’t really say more than that.
Finally, we had the shepherd’s pie, the nearest The Ivy has to a signature dish. On the wet and cold afternoon of our lunch, the rich, wine-infused lamb with silky-smooth spud was the perfect comfort food. It always comes with a bottle of Worcester sauce for you to season it, making it feel more homely and taste more funky. We pepped it up further with a balanced, earthy, kiwi pinot noir, which came in around £70 a bottle. The three courses, which we shared between two, would set you back around £50 a head. So, this isn’t crazy pricing. Especially when you consider that you get to eat in one of the world’s legendary establishments.
The nearest The Ivy has to a signature dish…
The Ivy isn’t going to win any awards for innovation. It doesn’t have a ‘concept’. There are no sharing small plates. You don’t have the menu explained to you when you sit down. This restaurant has though, been doing its thing for over a century. And that’s feeding you stuff you really want to eat, in a buzzy space full of people you want to hang out with. And isn’t that the essence of the ideal night out?
Find it: 1-5 West Street, Covent Garden, WC2H 9NQ
Click it: www.ivycollection.com
‘Gram it: @theivy_original
If Ari’s review of The Ivy has you longing for shepherd’s pie then you’ll love these… Hundreds more reviews from The Sauce. Enjoy!

