Ari, lucky thing, got to try out ALL THE FOODS at The Balmoral in this hotel review from the provinces…
Without a doubt, the half dozen years I spent living in Edinburgh, first as a student, then as everything from a (seriously bad) barman/barista to waiter in various restaurants, were some of the best days of my life. I arrived in 1996, arrogant yet somehow also awkward, and gradually, thanks mostly to my group of friends (still my best friends now), I became slightly less over the top and showy, slightly more low key and approachable/normal. Put it this way; I arrived at uni sporting a Prada crossbody manbag. If that doesn’t scream ‘look at me, I’m a twat’ I’m not sure what does.
Given I consider Edinburgh my second home, I was almost indecently keen to take up The Balmoral’s offer to come and stay for a couple nights to check the place out. In all the time I’d lived in Auld Reekie, I’d never set foot in this grandest of hotels, slap bang in the heart of the city, adjacent to Edinburgh’s main railway station.
I arrived by train so had a 30 second walk to the hotel check-in, manned by a team in impeccable tartan. My ‘executive room with a view’ (from around £600 a night bed and breakfast) had full-length picture windows. These directly overlooked the gothic spire of the Scott Monument, with the castle, perched on a hill above the city. It’s a wondrous view from the ground, but from the elevated fourth floor of my bedroom it verged on the awesome. The decor is classic luxe. Think natural wool carpets, heavy curtains and more marble in the bathroom than you’d think was possible.
It’s a wondrous view from the ground, but from the elevated fourth floor of my bedroom it verged on the awesome…
It also had the first intuitive and elegant air con system I’ve ever found in a hotel. And real light switches. The attention to detail was top-notch. The housekeeping staff replaced the raggedy Oxfam receipt I was using to mark the page in my holiday read, with a lovely striped bookmark. They also put a little Rocco Forte branded velcro tidy around my iPhone cable wire. (The Balmoral is part of the super fancy Forte group, which also includes the equally fabulous Brown’s in London).
I reckon you’ve probably got the message by now. This is a serious hotel, positioned in the top tier of five stars, with a reputation to match. It meant nothing though, if the food wasn’t up to scratch.
On my first night we were booked into the flagship restaurant, Number One. The restaurant’s sommelier, Matt had arranged a pre-supper wine tasting for me in the temperature controlled cellar. This meant I got to enjoy some fabulous wines (I’m looking at you Ken Forrester FMC, which apparently doesn’t stand for F*cking Magnificent Chenin but really ought to).
On my first night we were booked into the flagship restaurant, Number One…
The kitchen even sent up a few canapés, including some particularly rich and popping N25 caviar which went down as you’d expect with a yeasty and full-flavoured Champagne from Charles Heidsick. The night was young and I was already three glasses in and counting, thanks to Matt’s generosity and my insatiable appetite for all things grape. Before it all got a little hazy, we headed for the restaurant itself and sat down for their five course taster (£119).
This is where things started getting serious. And kicked off with a Cullen skink micro tart. This managed to flood my mouth with rich deep smoky haddock without being overbearing. There was more Champagne. I was starting to feel inexplicably jolly. There was more FMC, which went a treat with yet more caviar, this time used to dress some delicate Ullapool crab.
Nearly all the principal ingredients at Number One are sourced from Scotland. Unsurprising, since it’s one of the world’s greatest natural larders. So we had, after the crab, massive seared scallops hand dived from Orkney and a perfectly rare little slab (slablet?) of Loch Duart salmon dressed with a tomato water beurre blanc which managed to be both rich and refreshing. In fact the only non-native course was a beautifully pink squab (which just means baby) pigeon. This hailed from Brittany, but even that was dressed with wild garlic from Paisley, so maintained a Scottish touch.
Nearly all the principal ingredients at Number One are sourced from Scotland…
Pigeon is one of only three animals I reckon taste better as juveniles than fully grown. The others, since you’re asking, are goat and arguably (suckling) pig. Thanks to Matt I don’t think I can claim all my faculties were firing in perfect order by the end of this meal. But I was in no doubt that it was something special. It provided a tour of the best that Scotland has to offer, whilst avoiding a descent into over formality. And, most importantly, it was seriously fun. Such fun that we ended up joining tables with a neighbour for a final drink, before wobbling off to bed.
Breakfast the next morning, in the hotel’s brasserie, Prince, brought more joy. This time in the form of the best kippers I’ve ever eaten, hands (fins?) down. Hailing from Arbroath, home of the Smokie (the name of kippers from these parts), these haddock are slow-smoked over hardwood. This makes them much less oily than your standard kipper. Which means you can drench them in butter, which is never a bad thing to do. They were so good that I broke the golden rule of reviewing! I had exactly the same breakfast the following morning.
As well as the ubiquitous kipper, breakfast includes a host of the usual suspects on the à la carte menu. Together with a buffet heaving with high-end fruit, cheese and charcuterie. Not to mention slices of Japanese style (pale and delicate) cold frittata.
I skipped lunch, deciding the only way to justify another blowout dinner was a brisk climb up Arthur’s Seat, a steep faced hill overlooking the city, which I singularly failed to climb during my student years. Returning to The Balmoral I headed to Prince Brasserie for supper.
Prince is every bit as glam as Number One, albeit with a more casual menu and feel. It’s elegant, full of shiny brass fixtures and bentwood furniture. There’s a well drilled team of staff manning what feels like a constantly busy dining room and bar. I decided to build a meal focusing on key Scottish ingredients. Which meant, poor me, kicking off with some langoustines, served whole. These arrived in a utilitarian metal dish, with the usual set of ironware provided to help you crack through the carapaces. I spent half an hour happily wrist deep in Crustacea, wrinkling out the claw meat and slurping down the brains, feeling very much like the pig in the proverbial.
Next up was a rump steak tartare (£24), dressed beautifully at table but a little let down by the meat having been worked too much, which turned it into a slightly grey mush rather than leaving it as individual cubes of ruby red meat. The best part of this dish was the cupful of still warm potato gaufrettes, lacy, hand made waffle crisps which are fiendishly difficult to make. For starters, to get the waffle lattice, the potato has to be turned a quarter around between every cut. And that’s before you’ve even started trying to cook them.
For my main I went for saddle of venison, with foie gras, and winter truffles (£43) and a side order of aligot (£11). Aligot is an insanely rich cheese and garlic mash. It’s mountain food, rib sticking and delicious, usually made with one or more of three cheeses… Tomme fraiche, Gruyère and/or Comte. This one had both the latter options, making it properly rich, full flavoured and decadent. I managed to take down half the portion.
This left me feeling slightly overfaced and unable to tackle a full pudding. The solution was simple. A scoop of white chocolate ice cream with lemon, olive oil and caviar. Trust me, as mental as this sounds, it worked. The mellow white chocolate ice cream acted as a perfect, slightly bland (in a good way) counterpoint to the saltiness of the caviar, with the lemon adding a little sharpness and the olive oil binding it all together. Okay, it’s £55 per scoop but you get your own pretty little tin of King’s oscietra caviar. Plus, it’s silly and fun which is what puddings should be about.
Properly rich, full flavoured and decadent…
With this meal I was treated to an exceptional bottle of red thanks to Magic Matt. He sneaked me up a 2020 Valli Pinot Noir from New Zealand. The Kiwis are now making Pinot which tastes an awful lot like Burgundy, without it costing deep into three figures. Valli retails at around £50, so the £125 they had it on for at The Balmoral is decent value. Especially in a five star hotel.
This is a wine to make you think. It started in the glass tasting like strawberries and cherries – bright and fresh. And ended the meal, after a couple hours in a decanter, with a smoky autumnal character that was pretty profound. When I eat on my own I tend to order a serious bottle. This isn’t down to me being bad at sharing, but because special wine evolving through a meal is something I really enjoy taking my time over, but I fear it would annoy anyone normal I was eating with.
This is a wine to make you think…
For my final morning I got up early, heading down to the Forte Spa. Here I had a swim in the Romanesque pool, followed by a sauna and steam. I think I was hoping the week’s worth of booze I’d drunk in 48hrs would magically evaporate out through my pores. Another round of kippers and it was time to leave.
The Balmoral is a genuine classic. Comfortable in its own skin, smoother than a mink in silk, but without the snootiness that some high flying hotels suffer from, this place is very much the real deal.
Find it: 1 Princes Street, Edinburgh, EH2 2EQ
Click it: www.roccofortehotels.com
‘Gram it: @thebalmoral
For more travel reviews, akin to Ari’s one from The Balmoral Hotel, click here... For good measure, here’s what Ari thought of Sir Andy Murray’s place in Scotland, Comlix! (Which, I just discovered, is closed for refurbishment at the time of writing…)
