Andy Murray’s Scottish Hotel Is Completely Ace!

I spent six years living in Edinburgh, first as a student and then helping to run a couple restaurants in the vague and misplaced hope I could make it in the hospitality business. So I was pretty smug as I packed to head north to review Cromlix, a luxury hotel near the city of Dunblane, about an hour or so north of Glasgow, knowing just what a trip up there in May would require. Sturdy boots with a winter sole. Three jumpers, ranging from the merely thick to one of those duvet proportioned numbers fisherman in the Outer Hebrides wear. Knee high woollen socks, a windcheater and a brolly.

But then I arrived off the train to behold something akin to spotting a unicorn. Scottish sunshine. I had no sunglasses, sandals or sunscreen (luckily Cromlix lays on the last of these). I was more prepared for spring snow than the balmy mid-20s heat I now basked in. The start of this Scottish sojourn therefore felt a little miraculous. Which well suited what ended up being a rather magical stay. 

The first thing you’ll read about Cromlix is that it’s owned by Kim and Andy Murray. And let’s be fair, that’s a fun fact. Especially as the hotel has a purple tennis court on which Sir Andy has been known to bat a ball. Murray grew up in Dunblane and learnt to play at the local club, still going strong when I visited. So he and his family have deep roots in this part of the world. Any sense it’s some sort of celebrity vanity project vanished the moment I entered this venerable, Victorian, picture-perfect country house. The original features have been retained and clearly celebrated by those who run it. This even extends to the preservation of the 150 year old chapel, complete with floor to ceiling organ. The church is still consecrated and very much in use as a centrepiece for weddings held at Cromlix.

The hotel has a purple tennis court on which Sir Andy has been known to bat a ball…

Don’t get me wrong though. It’s clear throughout that the Murrays have had a very hands-on approach to the way this place looks and feels. It’s just that they’ve designed this place sympathetically to the history of the building rather than imposing their tastes, regardless. From the serious, high-end art which adorn most inches of the walls in both the public areas and bedrooms. To the bathrooms, works of art in themselves, beautifully wallpapered and, I was told, interior designed by Kim. This feels very much like a work of passion, with budgeting clearly taking second place to aesthetics at every turn.

Cromlix Review: WHAT A Bed!

The shower in my suite was the most powerful I’ve experienced outside the US. Built for professional sportsmen and American guests alike, many of the latter were staying when I visited. But these Yanks were about as far removed from their MAGA-hatted Capitol-storming brethren, as you could imagine. The guests from across The Pond I encountered at Cromlix were invariably international in outlook, cosmopolitan and predominantly from the urban (and urbane) east coast. They were here to pursue various activities, including cycling, fishing and touring the countryside. And all of which the hotel seemed to be able to arrange at the drop of a rod.

The shower in my suite was the most powerful I’ve experienced outside the US…

The activity I chose for my two-day trip was a tennis lesson. Having spent 30 plus years playing an aggressive but largely ineffective game, I decided it was time to iron out the wrinkles. And where better to improve my game than the house that Murray built? Ambling down to the Cromlix branded court, next to a bountiful looking kitchen garden guarded by half dozen very pretty, free range hens, I met up with one of the coaches, Kirstie, a recent graduate of nearby Stirling University. She had played competitively whilst a student and now provides lessons throughout the year at Cromlix.

I spent 90 minutes huffing round the court, Kirstie showing endless patience with my wayward forehand and even having the grace to allow me to win a game. She also managed to develop an entirely new (and actually functional) serve for me after five minutes’ gentle correction. I finished up a sweaty but very happy mess. Kirstie looked exactly the same as when we started. It turns out Cromlix hires staff for all aspects of the hotel from the University of Stirling and other local schools and colleges. Several of the front-of-house team were students. Each of whom, apparently, train up new recruits over the summer. This provides an unbroken conveyor belt of keen, personable, bright young things to keep service running smoothly. 

Cromlix hires staff for all aspects of the hotel from the University of Stirling and other local schools and colleges…

I got the feeling Cromlix operates in a way which nurtures the community around it, providing not only employment both for local students and semi-retirees alike but also offering facilities such as the tennis and pickleball courts for those who live and study in the area to use.

When, for example, Andy’s mum Judy discovered that the Stirling tennis team only had access to indoor courts, she made Cromlix’s outdoor court available for them to train on. If you want to get the right impression of this place, imagine the diametric opposite of a Trumpian megahotel, one of those gilded behemoths The Donald loves plonking into communities with which there is bond, designed to serve only wealthy foreign clients who drop in and out via private jet.

Cromlix, in contrast, feels entirely like a symbiotic ecosystem. The hotel and those who live near to it intertwine, working together for mutual benefit. On the Friday night I had my final dinner, half the guests in the (fully booked) restaurant were non-residents. Which reflects that Cromlix is about more than those who stay here. There are plenty of high-end, fancy, country house hotels in this neck of the woods. But there are very few which give off such a community spirit. I know this all sounds like I’ve gone a bit soft in the head, and trust me, I’m the last person to get carried away with Wordsworthian sentimentality. But Cromlix genuinely feels like a joint initiative between those who own it and those who live around it. And that’s worth both recognising and celebrating.

Cromlix genuinely feels like a joint initiative between those who own it and those who live around it…

The room I stayed in, one of the two turret suites at Cromlix (their top end option), was, quite frankly, magnificent. Adorned with original paintings, the bedroom had a huge canopy bed and floor-to-ceiling bay windows. These overlook the kitchen garden and tennis court. The separate sitting room, traditionally decorated, had a complimentary minibar, room for 6 people to chill out in (shame it was a solo trip) and a host of treats including homemade shortbread (made according to Andy’s Granny Erskine’s recipe) and excellent coffee.

Rates for these suites start at £750 a night so nobody’s going to claim this place is cheap. But you get a hell of a lot of bang for your buck. Including a superb breakfast which included a top notch tropical fruit salad. Plus a Bloody Mary station for the Bravehearts. And, of course, a full Scottish breakfast (with haggis, no less), and a host of other hot options. On my first morning I asked for some wilted spinach to go with my eggs royale. Which one of the chefs then went and picked for me fresh from the kitchen garden. That’s the kind of service you want to shout about. 

All meals are served in The Glasshouse, an extension of the original building filled with natural light and deliberately set up in a low key, casual way which encourages guests to chill and enjoy themselves, rather than sit in sombre silence. Dinner on my first night was from the a la carte menu. It’ll set you back around £70 for three courses.

That’s the kind of service you want to shout about…

I started with rabbit, sourced from nearby Linlithgow. The bunny came two ways… The saddle stuffed with leek, the leg deboned and terrined (this is now a verb) with truffle. Marking a dividing line down the middle of the plate was a long, thin crispy hash brown with the final component of the dish being a scattering of punchy pickled walnuts. This was a serious, accomplished, technical dish. It’s clearly up to Michelin standards but served without all the boring hoo hah you often suffer when fine dining. It was exactly what I wanted to eat, and how I wanted to eat it. Which is all anyone could ever ask for.

My main course, of local Puddledub pork, again demonstrated the deft touch of Executive Head Chef James Mearing. He’s only been at Cromlix for a few months, but seems to have bedded in immediately, given I experienced absolutely no teething troubles during any of the meals. The highlight of this dish was the combination of rich, pork fat caramel apple puree against the sharpness of shredded and well-seasoned confit turnip. It’s the only time I’ve ever thought turnip was a good idea on a plate rather than in a horse’s nosebag. The little, turned turnip served alongside was slightly bland and watery by comparison with the other elements on the plate. But I fixed that minor issue by not eating much of it.

Given that Cromlix is a top end five star hotel, I was also somewhat surprised to discover that I was able to order a bottle of perfectly decent Bordeaux (Chateau Petit Laurence), from the supreme 2016 vintage, for £44. That is a steal in any establishment, even more so in a place like this, for mature claret from an impeccable vintage.

The only time I’ve ever thought turnip was a good idea on a plate rather than in a horse’s nosebag…

My final night I decided to go all out and have the seven course taster menu. It comes in at £115 a head, for which you get a roll call of the kitchen’s greatest hits. The word count here won’t allow me to describe every course. But standout dishes included salt aged St Brides duck in a Chinese style five spice sauce with chicory and baked kohlrabi, the bitterness and earthiness of the vegetables playing well against the sweet, rich, duck. Also excellent was a pre-meal snack of salmon tartare in a crisp little pastry shell with a tingling smear of Thai nam jim chilli sauce.

The course that blew my mind though, was the asparagus and morel starter. As well as using ingredients perfectly in season, this dish showed execution of the very highest standards, from the truffle studded chicken mousse with which the fat morels were stuffed, to the yolk rich emulsion that coddled the elements together. The asparagus came from Scotland’s only commercial grower (growing asparagus in Scotland must be the preserve of only the most (fool)hardy souls. The morels, I suspect, were similarly locally foraged since they tasted like they’d been pulled from the ground moments before I devoured them. I’m not exaggerating when I say I’ve far had less sophisticated starters in places which charge three times as much for their taster. 

Usually I don’t go down the cheeseboard route, because there’s not much copy in how well they’ve kept the brie. But at The Glasshouse they served a single cheese, the creamy blue Montagnolo Affine, with, and I’m not kidding, a sliver of spiced warm treacle tart, which made it a pudding/cheese course mash up ripe for writing up. The pairing of salty blue cheese and sticky aromatic treacle was genius. It’s the most decadent and frankly irresponsible way to finish a meal.

The course that blew my mind though, was the asparagus and morel starter…

You can add a wine pairing for an additional £65 but since this included two kinds of Champagne and I’m not a massive fan of fizz, I spent almost the same sum on a bottle of Morgon from the excellent 2020 vintage. Morgon is the big boy wine of Beaujolais. It tastes a bit like a Burgundy but without the hundred pound price tag. For any of you who approach restaurant wine lists with fear, head for the Beaujolais section. Almost always underpriced in comparison to better known appellations, it’s a great red wine for this time of year. The restrained tannins and mellow taste profile of which makes it all too easy for a bottle to slip down.

I left Cromlix the following morning, driven down to Dunblane station in the house car by yet another convivial member of the team, my mind filled with memories of excellent hospitality but perhaps more importantly, with a feeling that this place positively affects not only the guests who stay here, but also those locals that call this little pocket of Scottish paradise home. Cromlix is very much at one with its surroundings, its community and its history. Bravo. Now go.

Find it: Cromlix, Kinbuck, Stirling, FK15 9JT.
Click it: www.cromlix.com
Splash it: From £304 (though obviously more for a fancy suite like Ari’s!)
‘Gram it: @cromlixhotel

Ari’s review of Cromlix makes us want to jump on the sleeper to Scotland right away! If you enjoyed his writing, you’ll find more of it here! And for all our travel stuff, click here…

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!