A Scallop Short Of Perfection At Marlow’s The Oarsman

Let’s get this out the way at kick off. The single scallop on the shell, from the snack section of the menu, was seasoned with too heavy a hand. The XO sauce bullied rather than complemented the mollusc. And that’s it folks. That was the only misstep I can point to during a frankly remarkable three hour lunch review at The Oarsman in Marlow, enjoyed in the surprise summer reboot we experienced in the dog days of September. 

We arrived at Marlow itself half an hour early for our lunch booking. This allowed us a meander through this pretty, ever so pleased with itself, up-at-heel little town. Every other shop sold art, jewellery, or designer clobber. One gallery appeared to specialise in paintings by very famous people, as if Marlow’s denizens needed more than mere art to get their rocks off, requiring no less than designer doodles. Notwithstanding the weird, tarot card scrawls apparently daubed by Feminist Weekly’s ‘Man of the Year’ Johnny Depp, our ‘petit tour’ of Marlow (as its residents might well have called it, over a large G&T by the croquet lawn) was a perfect way to whet the appetite for lunch at The Oarsman. 

Ambling down the high street, we came upon this smart, food-focused pub. Its front door is apparently (and slightly confusingly) sealed shut. But following the signs pointing round the side, we found the entrance, through a canopied alley decorated with rowing paraphernalia and looking like something Hollywood might knock up to fit the brief ‘perfect English country inn’. Think ramshackle Tudoresque beams, soft leather furnishings and the golden glow of mellow lamps combined with autumn sunshine. 

Like something Hollywood might knock up to fit the brief ‘perfect English country inn’…

I appreciate that I’m starting to channel romantic poet rather than restaurant critic vibes so let’s pull it back to the food. We started with a couple of the snacks from the pre-menu menu. There was the pre-mentioned scallop, the other some bouncy, crisped up monkfish cheeks in a Katsu sauce that cried out for a glug of the excellent, salmon pink, dry, house rosé, from the Bekaa Valley in Lebanon, we ordered in honour of the almost Provençalian weather. 

For starters proper I had a mackerel ceviche with fennel and orange. I tend to order raw mackerel whenever I see it on a menu. There’s nowhere to hide with this slippery little fish, making for a decent test of a restaurant’s supply chain. The minute after they’re plucked from the sea, mackerel start to lose their incredible flavour. Even after a day on ice they start to taste too much of the oil in their skin, slightly redolent of canned sardines. Or, two days’ after being caught, cat food…

We started with a couple of the snacks from the pre-menu menu…

The Oarsman’s mackerel was outstanding. It was as fresh as anything I’ve tasted outside high-end sushi joints. But unlike their Japanese counterparts, this place charges a mere tenner for the pleasure. The fennel was young, the thinly sliced bulb and dill-like fronds neither too strident in flavour nor tough in texture. The orange gave the dish the gentle acidity it needed to play off the richness of the mackerel. This was a flawless plate of food, and worth the trip to Marlow on its own.

A brief chat with the helpful, clued-up staff revealed that they get fresh fish delivered to The Oarsman every day. That’s really the only way you can serve a dish like this. And it tells you everything you need to know about how serious they are about the food.

Having been a good boy and ordered fish to start, I felt justified in opting for a manlier main. Venison loin with faggot and pickled pears. Can’t get more macho than a faggot. Typically a round dumpling of minced offal, usually from a pig, but here, the faggot was, appropriately, Bambi’s rather than Babe’s minced heart, liver and spleen; sorry kids). It was heavily seasoned with pepper, which worked, but otherwise delicately flavoured and incredibly moreish.

They get fresh fish delivered to The Oarsman every day…

Unlike many faggots I’ve had before, this wasn’t over-gamey or ferrous (often the case if too much liver finds its way into the mix). If you didn’t tell your kids it was deer heart, I guarantee they would wolf these baubles of joy down like a superlative sausage. The loin was perfectly pink and soft, the richness counterpointed by the slices of poached and lightly pickled pear. This was sophisticated, technical, impressive cooking, way beyond what you’d expect from a pub (which The Oarsman looks and sounds like) or a bistro (which it identifies as).

Under any usual circumstances, this would have won main of the day at a canter. But the whole plaice with brown shrimp butter and samphire, ordered by Mrs A, was ludicrous. The inch thick fish arrived draped on (and over the sides of) a plate swimming in tiny brown shrimp butter. It was the most generous, fantastic dish and at £30 when it could easily serve two, also an absolute steal. Especially when you consider that Brat in London now charges £185 for its whole turbot!

It was the most generous, fantastic dish…

Plaice is an utterly unforgiving bugger to cook. It transmutes from raw to overcooked (and tasting like warm cotton wool) in under a minute. A chef has to be entirely on their game to get it right. And I couldn’t have cooked it as perfectly as they managed in The Oarsman, in my actual dreams. 

After the rosé, and in order to pay due deference to the venison, we opted for a half litre carafe of an excellent 2016 Bordeaux, Chateau Noaillac from a 300-strong wine list, most of which is well under a £100 a bottle. And The Oarsman has a policy which permits you to order a 500ml carafe of any bottle under £100 at a scrupulously fair two thirds of the bottle price. This is genius and meant we drank some seriously good claret for £32, without (quite) tipping over into the messiness and mayhem of a mid-week two bottle lunch. This approach to the wine list signposts the philosophy of The Oarsman. Innovative, generous to a fault and blessed with superlative cooking. 

Find it: 46 Spittal Street, Marlow, SL7 1DB
Click it: www.theoarsman.co.uk
‘Gram it: @theoarsmanmarlow

That’s the end of Ari’s review of the brilliant Oarsman in Marlow. But fear not! Here are all our reviews in one place!

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!