Pieces Of Ate: We Found A Floating Restaurant Aboard An Old Lightship…

I’ve never really bought into the concept that the English ‘Riviera’ exists. Too much of our coastline is scarred with half empty dilapidated towns which time seems to have forgotten. And not in a sepia tinted, nostalgic, positive sense. Well, my preconceptions got a proper kick in the cockles last week! I travelled down to Haslar Marina, near Portsmouth, to review The Lightship, an almost 100 year old vessel that’s been given a full Gatsby-esque makeover and now has a locally caught seafood-led menu right in time for the summer. 

Bearing in mind Portsmouth is a good couple hours each way from home, I opted to make a trip of it and stay overnight at The Creek. It’s an upmarket b&b with a picture perfect restaurant and bar overlooking Haslar Marina. Enjoying a pint of IPA while watching the boats bobbing about and playing the eternally enjoyable game of trying to guess how much a particular yacht costs (clue- it’s always five times more than you think) was the ideal way to kick off the evening.

I was then scooped up by the team at Boatfolk. They look after several UK marinas including Haslar. We gently sailed around the Solent in one of their ultra swish, fully catered, motor yachts drinking Pimm’s. We ate superior snacks (the locally sourced charcuterie in particular was outstanding) watching the sun set and seals playing between the mammoth old naval ships lying at rest in the harbour. It was a uniquely British experience of luxe coastal living and I now have the hunger for more. 

We gently sailed around the Solent in one of their ultra swish, fully catered, motor yachts drinking Pimm’s…

Being the UK, as soon as the sun went down it started to feel a little less like Cap d’Antibes and more like Cape Horn. So the boat headed back inshore and dropped us off at The Lightship. It’s a grand old vessel now in a permanent mooring in a prime position in the marina and facing out to sea.

First impressions: a serious amount of TLC goes into keeping things ship-shape. Paint gleams, wood is polished and the interior of the boat has been given a burnished bronze and emerald green colour scheme that makes you feel like you’re in a glam 1920s speakeasy. 

We kicked off with a really high quality Champagne-method local fizz from The Grange and a punchy, scotch-based strawberry cocktail on the upper deck, which is set up for casual all day drinking and dining. Think sharing seafood platters, and pink wine in the sun, with ambient Ibiza sounds and you’ll get the vibe. The ever-helpful crew brought rounds of oysters to go with our drinks and I felt like I was on holiday. Surely this was the south of France, rather than a couple hours’ drive from London?

Think sharing seafood platters, and pink wine in the sun, with ambient Ibiza sounds…

One level below the outside deck, the main dining room has a more formal feel. It’s a sea of green banquettes, more plush wood and some seriously superior live jazz and swing. This comes courtesy of the rather marvellous singer Amy Baker. Her glam look and rich sound couldn’t be a better match for the ship. She’ll be performing on board over the summer, during several live music events The Lightship will be putting on.

Because I’m food-curious (my new monicker for greedy), I opted for a multi-course tasting menu. It showcases many of the dishes which Lightship will have on the a la carte this summer. 

First up from the starters was a south coast scallop with crisped angel hair filo pastry. It sat in a pool of coral coloured lobster bisque. And, for me, the bisque was the star not only of this dish but the whole meal. It’s obvious many, many crustaceans found themselves sacrificed on the altar of this most decadent of sauces. I could have drunk a bowl of it, with a baguette and some cold butter and gone home totally satisfied. It was a million times better than the overpriced, thin, measly gruel you often get when trying to order the equivalent in Cannes (or, frankly, anywhere in France these days).

Many, many crustaceans found themselves sacrificed on the altar of this most decadent of sauces…

The scallop couldn’t quite keep up with its sauce; the filo pastry casing meant the mollusc carried on cooking long after it was taken off the heat, so it ended up a little oversteamed. But it didn’t really matter because, however good it was, the bisque would have stolen the show anyway. 

We followed this with a squid carbonara. Full marks for originality! It had British venison chorizo crumb replacing the usual guanciale (Italian pig jowl) and squid playing the part of pasta. And it worked, in terms of creating a dish reminiscent of carbonara, whilst being entirely different to the original. The only issue was the rather forceful cheddar in the sauce (old Winchester according to the menu), a wonderful cheese in its own right but with too much of a heavy dairy hit for the squid. 

For our first main we had halibut with clams in a saffron cream. The fish was perky, firm and fresh, the sauce a weedier cousin to the bisque I was (and still am) missing. Next, some carefully judged roast pork sitting in a cider cream with nectarines for a little twang. The pork was beautifully tender but could have done with a little roughing up in a hot pan to get a little caramelisation going, otherwise though it was a fab way to finish the savouries. 

The final flourish was a miniature chocolate delice with honeycomb and burnt orange…

The final flourish was a miniature chocolate delice with honeycomb and burnt orange. The chocolate is dark, dense, its sweetness offset by the burnt orange which tastes like grown up marmalade. The dish gets some grip from the crisp crunch of honeycomb. This was a pudding highlight of the year and a million miles away from what I would expect to find on a boat off the UK coast. 

Each of the five courses came with an interesting, original wine pairing. And most were from local vineyard Ashling Park. The entire ethos around the food and wine was, where possible, to source high quality, local alternatives to what punters would usually expect. This is an ambitious, laudable and wholly positive approach for which The Lightship deserves real recognition. It would be far easier (and less costly) for them to go down the tried and tested route of flying in ingredients and booze from all ends of the earth but this focus on what you can find nearer to home, even down to the red we drank (a strawberry scented, light touch Pinot Noir), was one of the highlights of the experience.

An ambitious, laudable and wholly positive approach …

I finally retired to my cosy, cabin like room at The Creek. It had enough little maritime decorative nods to point up its seaside location. But without feeling like it had been themed by Disney. I woke up bright and breezy and in time to enjoy a flawless breakfast. 

The Lightship at Haslar Marina is one of the best places I can imagine spending a warm British summer’s day. Who needs Porto Cervo when we’ve got Portsmouth?

Find it: Haslar Marina, Gosport, Hampshire, PO12 1NU
Click it: www.thelightshiphaslar.co.uk
‘Gram it: @thelightshiphaslar

Assuming you like Ari’s review of The Lightship Haslar, then you’ll find more of his reviews here. Or, indeed, all our reviews by clicking here!

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!