Open the door. Enter the restaurant. Sit at a table, set with knives, forks and plates. Look at the menu. Order what you want for starters, mains and desserts, which then arrive on plates set down in front of you. Eat. That’s your basic restaurant dining rhythm, generally the case wherever you go. And let me tell you, apart from the eating bit, none of it happened at Sushi Kanesaka, this week’s review. What did happen was one of the most original, awe-inspiring meals of my life.
We walked into the uber-smart 45 Park Lane hotel, part of the Dorchester Collection, early one Friday evening, for our 6pm sitting at Sushi Kanesaka. You get two options when booking, either 6pm or 8.30pm. And, because I’m a 46-year old father of three young kids, 6pm is about the latest I can eat dinner without getting anxious about my bedtime. Usually finding a restaurant within a hotel is a massive pain. There are often multiple in-house eateries and you wander round the lobby, confused and lost for 20 minutes getting hangry. Not here. As soon as I entered, a diminutive man, who turned out to be the restaurant GM, in an absolutely impeccable suit, glided up to me. He whispered my name (how did he know?), welcomed us and escorted us up some stairs.
Lucky he did, because Sushi Kanesaka is tiny, with only nine seats plus an even smaller private dining room which seats another four, set into a jewel-box like alcove hidden away on the mezzanine. At the entrance, instead of a door, was a gauzy, fluttering, white linen curtain, covered with beautiful Japanese script. The moment we pushed this aside we were transported to Tokyo’s Ginza district, where chef Shinji Kanesaka hails from.
Some of the most vibrant fish I’ve ever seen…
In place of standard issue tables there was simply one, solid cypress wood, curved counter, around which nine chairs were arranged. Arriving just after the first group of three (Japanese businessmen drinking Asahi and shochu), but before the last couple (a Japanese man with his date, a woman whose skin was exactly the colour and finish of alabaster and looked like a delicate china (if you’ll forgive the geographical misnomer) doll), we took our places right in the middle of the action. In front of us were half a dozen chefs. Each wielded an enormous knife with surgeon-like dexterity whilst handling some of the most vibrant fish I’ve ever seen.
Being the only non-Japanese diners in the room, we were initially a little worried we might break sushi etiquette in some unknown way or offend the other guests, or staff. But then an actual Geisha (Nanami-san, who hosted the evening) turned up with a bottle of sparkling sake and we very quickly relaxed. Nothing can go wrong if you’re being looked after by a genuine Geisha. Them’s the rules.
There’s no menu. You eat omakase style (Japanese for, ‘trust the chef, he knows what he’s doing much more than you do, gaijin’). The selection that evening consisted of 20-odd courses, each of which were made in front of us by the head chef and his team, before being placed onto elegant, minimalist, handmade plates which were positioned on the upper part of the counter, at eye level, and from which you helped yourself, by hand, to the sushi.
But then an actual Geisha (Nanami-san, who hosted the evening) turned up…
I would blow my word count if I attempted to describe every mouthful we experienced, so here are some highlights. Although there were many, many others. Steamed abalone (a brutally expensive sea snail, this one brought over from Australia) and delicate, simmered octopus was a textural, original, knock out dish. Both the abalone and octopus were utterly tender. The former because that’s the nature of abalone, the latter rendered so through hours of massaging the creature before cooking. Massaging a dead octopus is hard work. You would usually expect a commis or other chef lower down the culinary pecking order to undertake it. Not here; the head chef put in the hours to knead the flesh into submission. That’s the level of effort and attention to detail Kanesaka brings.
There was sushi nigiri (fish laid atop rice) of lean, then medium fatty, then full fat belly tuna. Each a triumph of subtle seasoning, each showcasing the most extraordinary rice I’ve ever eaten; sticky but with every grain standing on its own two feet, a hint of vinegar and deep, aged soy, but not enough to overwhelm the fish, the temperature of the rice at body temperature to optimise the flavour. Unbelievable perfection. But, despite the name of this place, it wasn’t all about sushi.
About halfway through the feast, one of the chefs brought out of a hidden back kitchen, a thick triangle of raw, marbled beef. He stroked it, said simply ‘Kobe’, then touched his heart. I hazarded a guess that this gesture meant both he and the steak were from Kobe, and was rewarded with a loud ‘hai’ of assent. Kobe beef is where it all began for the now ubiquitous wagyu. A million miles away from the £5 wagyu burgers you can now buy at Asda, Kobe beef comes only from Tajima cattle, raised in Hyogo prefecture, which are fed a diet including beer as well as enjoying a daily massage. The result is beef with an obscenely generous marbling of fat, tender beyond recognition, expensive as hell.
Beef with an obscenely generous marbling of fat, tender beyond recognition…
The particular cut of beef we were served was a tiny tenderloin section, representing less than 3% of the cow, and considered its best bit. Grilled over fire, seasoned with wasabi, it exploded in the mouth, the fat rendered to liquid as you touched it with your lips, it was utterly sensuous, rich and decadent. I can still recall every morsel of it, even now, a week later. It was a scary dish, the crack cocaine of the bovine kingdom, almost too good for comfort. I can think of some pretty terrible things I would do to get another little taste of it…
We had lobster, specifically a little blue lobster from Scotland, the animal paraded in front of us before its despatch. The flesh was sparkling white, dense, full of flavour whilst also delicate and utterly pure. It tasted of lobster dialled up to 11, whilst at the same time tasting simple and only of itself. This is as close to magic as you can get in cookery, when you have the skill to render the absolute essence of flavour from an ingredient without gussying it up. It was served with a mellow, slightly eggy take on tartare sauce, a little like a relaxed sauce gribiche, the perfect foil to the fish.
The only time I saw the chef frown was when inspecting, then rejecting, the first attempt the back kitchen made of cooking the lobster. A tiny, almost imperceptible shake of the head, followed by his staff rapidly removing the offending crustacean from view. Poor little blue, he failed to make the plate. The lobster did though make a second appearance later in the meal with the offcuts bobbing around in a deep, umami-bomb miso and chive soup, so perhaps lobster mark one didn’t perish in vain.
As close to magic as you can get in cookery…
Given I know next to nothing about Japanese booze, we placed ourselves in the hands of the utterly charming sommelier. She served a flight of sake which started with a gentle, sparkling, cloudy version to kick off, before travelling through increasingly complex and alcoholic versions of this ethereal drink. We ended up with a couple glasses from a 1.8ltr magnum of a sake blended by the guy who made Dom Perignon for 28 years. IWA 5 Reserves, as it was called, was a revelation. It’s rare to blend different sakes, even rarer for a European to have done it and the result was outstanding. Sake has an empathy with Japanese food which even the finest wines lack.
On the way home I went straight onto Ocado and added a small bottle of sake to our weekly shop. At £11.75 it won’t be anything like what we tried, but I needed something to take me back to Kanesaka. But my supermarket sake could only ever be a mere shadow of what I’d enjoyed.
I know. I’ve only managed to describe half a dozen of the 20 courses. But what do you expect? How could I do justice to fully describing each of the dishes that came at us? I don’t think I could ever find the words to convey to you how extraordinary this place is. And don’t ask me about the price. It’s well into four figures for two! But, when weighing up whether to give Sushi Kanesaka a try, don’t compare that outlay with going out to eat… Because this is so much more than that. Think instead about how much flights, hotel and a meal in Ginza district would cost. Because Sushi Kanesaka is as near as you can get to a night out in Japan, without leaving London.
Find it: 45 Park Lane, Mayfair, W1K 1PN
Click it: www.dorchestercollection.com
‘Gram it: @45parklane
If Ari’s Sushi Kanesaka review got your juices going, you’ll love his other reviews, which you can find here.
