A Rare Treat: We Review Elephant’s Rarebit

As far back as I can remember, we’ve been promised by shiny suited, slick-haired estate agents (and who wouldn’t trust them?) that Elephant and Castle is on the way up. “It’s in Zone 2” they bray, before claiming the area is super convenient, a forgotten corner of south central London and the NEXT BIG THING.

The problem is, it isn’t very pretty and it’s currently mostly a building site. The ugly-as-Hell shopping centre, previously topped with a faded elephant and located directly outside the tube station, is in the process of a protracted, albeit very necessary, demolition. It’s not where you expect to find a knock-out restaurant.

Rarebit review: Lionel

Nevertheless, off I tripped down the Walworth Road, in search of Rarebit. Rarebit is a new all day restaurant and wine shop in The ‘Phant (and nobody apart from me right this minute calls this area “The ‘Phant” yet, but this might be just the kind of funky moniker the place needs to complete its conversion).

Rarebit sits on a corner, one side facing a cute tropical flower garden installed by developers to prettify the building site next door. There’s a small terrace and inside a mix of booths and round tables. They’re picked out in muted olive, terracotta and blond tones which, I assume coincidentally, almost exactly match the colour scheme of the old shopping centre elephant.

Nobody apart from me right this minute calls this area “The ‘Phant” yet…

Inside is cosy, exuding a relaxed, low-key, casual vibe that feels very much neighbourhood joint rather than flash gaffe. It’s the kind of place I would love to have on my doorstep.

I entered through the wine shop, plonking myself at a table half inside and half out, better to enjoy the permanent sun we now seem to enjoy (if you’re reading this during the inevitable upcoming Beast From The East, apologies).

The menu is a single side of recycled brown paper. And the focus, as you might expect from its name, is very much towards cheese. In addition to the eponymous rarebit, dairy-led options include burrata with grilled peach, mac’n’cheese, goat’s cheese salad and a Neal’s Yard Cheese Board.

It’s at this point that the pal who’s joined me for a long lunch announces she no longer partakes of lactose. After an awkward silence (I genuinely believed I didn’t know anyone with ‘allergies’) I returned my gaze to the menu with renewed impetus. So we mostly tried the sans fromage options, and I’m glad we did.

First up, some nicely crisped soft shell crab. It was given a kick with some jalapeno and extra freshness thanks to a lurid green coriander and parsley sauce. Deep fried crab can be a bit heavy, but this version was a sparky little treat. It also went well with the autumnal wild mushroom salad, dressed with a sherry vinegar.

This dish sounded totally crazy and at risk of ingredient overkill, but was actually delicious…

We couldn’t entirely ignore the cheese options so, taking my friend’s life in my hands, I ordered the mac’n’cheese. It comes with scallop and ‘nduja’ (that spicy Italian crumbly sausage you find everywhere right now). This dish sounded totally crazy and at risk of ingredient overkill, but was actually delicious. And that’s despite the (perfectly cooked and fantastic) lone scallop looking like it wandered in from another dish, lost and confused. I’m hoping when I next visit there will be a new starter, simply of the scallops on their own. They deserve it.

For the mains we went for lamb chop with peas and pearl barley. Along with the mackerel and some perfectly good roasted hispi cabbage with tomato and hazelnut.

Rarebit review: Mac & Cheese

The lamb chop was the standout, spiced, seared. And it fully deserved for you to rip it apart by hands and teeth, not knives and forks; it was the dish of the day.

The mackerel, which arrived with pickled fennel and ‘salty fingers’ (more on those in a minute), was slightly let down by the lack of punch in the fennel pickling brine. Mackerel is an oily, meaty fish and needs an acidic counterpunch, which the fennel didn’t quite deliver. The salty fingers were, however, a total treat. Plumper cousins of samphire, the little green pods burst on the tongue with a taste of the sea. It was totally addictive and added a genuinely playful element to the dish.

Now you’ve probably worked out by now that I like this place. It’s small-scale, run with passion by an independent team. And it’s located somewhere which desperately needs decent places to eat. Plus it’s a real blast. And all that is true. But the reason you all need to get yourselves down to The ‘Phant (see what I did there, it’s now a thing, you’re welcome people of Walworth), is the frankly fantastic policy they have with wine markups.

Rarebit review: fish!

Your average restaurant slaps a fairly hefty price tag on wine. It usually works like this… You take cost of the bottle, times it by 3 or 4 and that’s what you buy it for. This means that bottles which cost a lot find themselves marked up by ridiculous amounts.

So a wine costing £40 will end up listed at £130-£150. In effect a £100 tariff for the privilege of drinking it in the restaurant. This is unaffordable for everyone except the oligarchs. Who have mostly fled London now, so what happens is nobody really orders the good stuff.

A desire to give you a great time for a reasonable price…

And yes, I do understand that for restaurants with sky-high rents and overheads, charging for wine like this can be a commercial necessity. Rarebit however has decided to depart from this. Their policy is a standard £15 on top of the retail cost of a wine. Presumably hoping that you will reciprocate by ordering lots of it. Which you will.

So you can drink, for example, a wonderful, sappy, rich St Veran, £30 in the shop, for £45. This approach allows you to travel to the nether regions of the wine list, try bottles you wouldn’t usually touch. And it underlines the philosophy of this place… A desire to give you a great time for a reasonable price. 

Taking my advice to heart, me and my cheese-fearing friend polish off three bottles of variously delicious wines, of which the Chianti and St Veran were the standouts. After bottle two, feeling a little jolly, we then ordered the dish for which this place is named.

The rarebit arrived on some punchy sourdough, three different cheeses, which, according to one of the guys who runs the place, Will, were for, ‘stringiness, flavour and.. something else’, scattered with spring onions and tasting (a little too much for me) of wholegrain mustard. Other than the turbo mustardy hit, it was a lovely way to sober up for the next glass. And the one after that. You won’t ever want to leave The ‘Phant.

You could eat and drink seriously well here and pay under £30 a head. Which is a ridiculous bargain for food and wine of this quality. Come between half four and half six and you’ll also get cocktails for £4.50 each as well as any wine to drink in at retail prices. Need I say more?

Find it: 11 Sayer Street, The ‘Phant, SE17 1FY
Click it: www.rarebitfood.co.uk
‘Gram it: @rarebitfood

Liked our Rarebit review? Find more reviews here…

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!