There’s a very specific sense of smugness that attaches to reviewing a restaurant when it opens, being wowed, telling everyone you know the place will get a star, and then it does. It just feels like a job well done. And, back in 2024, when I first walked through the doors at Lita in Marylebone, that’s exactly what happened. By 2025, 10 months after it opened, Michelin followed my lead and gave Lita the full thumbs up, and it’s retained its star ever since.
So, I thought it was worth a trip back, to see whether the official recognition had affected the place. You see, quite often, I view these awards as a mixed blessing. Once they get on the list, restaurants can sometimes be straitjacketed into sticking with the plan. The fear of losing the bauble surpasses the desire to evolve. Well, lucky for me, Lita’s avoided this pitfall.
We left it to newish head chef, Kostas Papasanasiou, to pick the dishes, and sat back to enjoy the fun. What came out was a procession of light, summery, vegetable forward dishes that perfectly reflected the season. And all matched with some seriously fine wines picked by yet another superlative female som.
I thought it was worth a trip back, to see whether the official recognition had affected the place…
Let’s start with the wine. We went from a high minerality white from the foothills of Mount Etna, through an entirely novel (for me) and genuinely game-changing still wine from Aÿ in Champagne, to a plush, soft 2019 Brunello from Casisano. These were a thinking person’s wines. Properly interesting, perfectly suited to the courses they accompanied, and of the highest quality. They ranged between £25-37 a glass, which is a lot, but you’re getting some superlative plonk for your pounds, and I think they were all totally worth the splurge.
So, to the food. First up, kaluga caviar and avocado toast (£15, a bargain given the mound of caviar they sent out). I’ve had caviar with vanilla ice cream. With olive oil. In a martini. But I’ve never had caviar with avocado. It absolutely works. The avocado provided a neutral jumping-off point for the fancy eggs, pointing up the savour of the caviar and lengthening the finish. Next up, a second snack of Cornish mussel and tomato rosti (£9). The shellfish was plump and sweet, cut with the acidity of the fruit and counterpointed with the salty, crispy potato base, a genuinely fantastic bite.
From the starters we kicked off with a Cornish crab salad (£35). Picked white meat with just a little basil and tomato to go with, a simple treatment which let the delicate main ingredient sing. Then a hamachi crudo (£34), perfectly fresh, twinned with tomato and some hazelnuts for a little welcome crunch and earthiness. Following this, more tomatoes (£13), this time a variety of different types, from Italy, in a featherlight dressing. You’ve probably noticed by now the main issue with the first few courses. Tomato had too much of a role in our food play. I don’t mind half my dishes sharing the same ingredient, but this was nigh on 80% and I thought it was wolf apple overkill.
I’ve never had caviar with avocado. It absolutely work…
The next two courses were outstanding. Grilled scallop with lobster sauce and pumpkin (£29) was as perfect a seafood dish as you’ll find. The scallop was huge, cooked firm rather than being left wobbly in the middle, and all the better for it. I prefer my scallops either raw or cooked, not somewhere in the middle. The sauce provided a salty, umami backdrop, with some sweetness from the pumpkin to even things out. Beef short rib with peaches (£37) was, if anything, even better. Slow cooked until melting, unctuous beef, cut with fresh peaches which exploded with their juices in my mouth, refreshing the palette and making me immediately want another bite. It was an autumnal dish given a summer lick of paint. Very clever, very Lita.
We finished with monkfish (£66) from the kitchen’s custom grill, simply served with a clam beurre blanc and a little pile of sliced fennel. Monkfish really wants to tighten up as it cooks, even more so when grilled. At Lita, they cook it over indirect heat, rather than giving it the full flame. Which means a less smoky flavour, but far kinder on the flesh.
The next two courses were outstanding…
I finished up with a chocolate and coffee tart. Well, I was about to finish with the tart. But my plus-one inexplicably ordered the peach crumble and then gave me the sad eye until I yielded half the tart to her. Girls. It was a full ten out of ten, thanks to a sublime blackcurrant sorbet and the bitter backnote of the coffee, making the whole thing taste grown up and restrained, rare qualities in a pudding. One fantastic espresso later, we were back out in the blazing sun, off towards Marylebone Station and the Home Counties (me, Bucks, her Oxfordshire), a lunch well met.
Lita’s not got starry eyed following Michelin coming a calling. They continue to send out the highest quality ingredients, allowed to speak for themselves, in a space that’s as gorgeous as ever. Well worth the trip back.
Find it: 7-9 Paddington Street, Marylebone, W1U 5QH
Click it: www.litamarylebone.com
‘Gram it: @litamarylebone
Want to read Ari’s first Lita review, the one that beat the Michelin Men to it? It’s here…. Enjoy! And for more reviews, click here…
