So Good They Reviewed It Twice! Why Lilibet’s Is Worth A Double Take

A few months’ back, when the nights were longer and the weather hadn’t dialled itself up to full forest fire apocalypse, I wandered past a restaurant in Mayfair, on my way to a Chinese New Year’s party, and peeped in through the swankily curtained windows. What I saw was a full house, of beautifully lit (and generally beautiful) people, having what looked like a grand night out. That restaurant turned out to be Lilibet’s, a one-of-a-kind seafood restaurant on Bruton Street.

The reason I say this place is one of a kind? Well unlike nearly every other high-end Mayfair joint, it’s not owned by an international consortium, or private equity-backed restaurant group. Nor is it part of a chain. It’s run and owned by a real chef, called Ross, who was out on the floor during our lunch making sure everyone was well looked after. 

Those of you who appreciate a minimalist, Scandi design ethos, look away now. Lilibets is a maximalist riot of sconces, fancy carpet, cushions and tassels. The loos look like Marie Antoinette’s boudoir, the bar feels like the kind of place James Bond might wind down after an afternoon of unprincipled misogyny and the dining rooms (yes there are more than one) are fully swagged. I don’t always love the ‘more is better’ approach to decor, but it seriously works at Lilibet’s, because the place feels glam rather than gaudy, grand rather than garish. And to be honest, the surroundings gave me every impression my wallet was about to take a battering.

Those of you who appreciate a minimalist, Scandi design ethos, look away now…

Then, I took a proper look at the wine list and discovered Lilibet’s has another ace up its sleeve. I eat out three or four times a week and always order at least one bottle of wine. I’m telling you this so you can appreciate that I know my way around a restaurant wine list. And I’m going to call this, right at the outset of today’s review. Lilibet’s has one of the very best lists in London, both in terms of quality and value. And that’s in a Mayfair-based seafood restaurant.

Nobody in the business seems to have cottoned onto this, yet, or at least it’s not something I’ve heard on the grapevine. I’m not merely saying it’s good value when compared with other fancy Mayfair fish places. I’m saying the mark ups are gentle compared to any other London restaurant. So, we were able to have, as our third bottle, a beautifully elegant, restrained and refreshingly crunchy, organic Chinon (Cabernet Franc from the Loire), for £60. And there’s plenty else to choose from in the £50-80 restaurant sweet spot. This is where you used to find interesting wines, without totally breaking the bank. Now 5 x retail markups are somehow the new normal. I never thought my opening gambit about Lilibet’s would be to tell you it was a bargain. But when it came to wine and cocktails, it was surprisingly reasonable. 

Lilibet’s has one of the very best lists in London…

Enough about the booze, let’s talk about the food. Now, typically, I’d walk you through starters and mains, then denigrate the concept of pudding as my big finish. Not today. We didn’t have starters. We didn’t even look at the pudding menu. Why? Because we were here to take down a single, sharing platter, the ‘The Fishes Royale’. It comes in at £220 for two and includes over a dozen different cold and raw treats from the sea.

The Royale arrived in a bespoke, double-tiered, rotating metal salver. Think two fin de siecle punch bowls sitting on top of one another. It consumed the whole of our table, requiring us to shift handbag (her), sunglasses (me) and half the cutlery (us) to our spare chair. Extravagant, decadent and frankly glorious to behold, it launched us into a lunch that lasted well into the evening and made me feel like I’d time travelled back to the 1920s. 

Oysters, three ways. Lean and fatty tuna sashimi. A dozen split langoustines, four crab tartlets, an entire lobster entirely de-shelled, down to the claws, lobster cocktail, raw wild red prawns, scallops and sea bream. And these were only my highlights of what seemed an entire ocean’s worth of pinpoint fresh, perfectly prepared piscine dishes.

It consumed the whole of our table…

And unlike those seafood platters you order in the South of France, there was no cheap filler in the form of whelks, cockles, mussels and other lesser bivalves. Everything they served was high-end, best in class, prepared so it was ready to eat, rather than requiring fiddly nutcrackers, skewers and the like, and absolutely delicious.

If I had to find fault, I’d say the mini anchovy eclairs with which we kicked off the meal were too punchy to precede the more delicate seafood that followed. But my pal disagreed with me about this, saying she loved the potent little savoury. So I’m not even sure this tiny criticism holds water.

Any issues there may or may not have been with the eclair were put to bed as soon as we popped a crab tart in our mouths. A crisp, chickpea flour shell encased a mound of fresh picked white crab under which sat some of the more potent brown meat to give it some oomph. I haven’t had many better bites in 2026 than this tart. Thank goodness you get four to share between two. It prevented me from having to steal one from my plus one.

There was no cheap filler in the form of whelks, cockles, mussels and other lesser bivalves…

We let Lilibet’s sommelier Marcello pick the whites to carry us through the ‘fishes’. He knocked it out of the park. First, a minerally, clean and medium-bodied Petritis, from a vineyard 1,600m up a Cypriot mountain. It cost a very reasonable £55, for a wine that retails around £20. No, I’d never heard of it either, but I totally recommend it with the oysters and langoustines.

Then, when we got into the richer seafood, like lobster and crab, he switched us to a big, blowsy 2022 Cali Chardonnay, full of buttery oak, which I didn’t price check, but am guessing cost around double the Petritis. We spent a good three hours munching our way through the Fishes Royale, and we still ended up leaving half the langoustines. I know that’s a total food crime, but we simply couldn’t manage another morsel. Despite this being the best seafood I’ve eaten in London this year. We finished up on the gorgeous outside terrace, sipping our Chinon and celebrating an afternoon so very well spent. This is my favourite restaurant of the Summer. Go platter yourself silly. 

Find it: 17 Bruton Street, Mayfair, W1J 6QB
Click it: www.lilibetsrestaurant.com
‘Gram it: @lilibetsmayfair

Unusually, Ari wasn’t the first person from The Sauce to review Lilibet’s; Phoebe beat him to it! So good they reviewed it twice, here’s our first stab at it.

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!