The Final Boss Of Restauranting, We Review 3 Michelin Star (4 On A Technicality) L’Enclume

It’s the ultimate in restaurant reviewing, Simon Rogan’s L’Enclume, so we had to send Ari to review it…

Last week I was leafing idly through my back catalogue of reviews for The Sauce (slow day at the office) and realised I was fast approaching my 150th piece. That number represents a lot of lunches, far too much wine, and a hell of a lot of fun. It’s become obvious over the last couple years I’ve spent eating my way round London and beyond, that the overall standard of restaurants has never been higher. In essence, you’re seriously unlucky these days to get a totally dud meal. The competition for punters is so fierce, expectations so high and the feedback from a bad experience so immediate, thanks to social media, that nearly all restaurants get most things right. And we ought to celebrate that. As well as my hitting the 150 mark.

And what better way to eat two birds with one fork than for me to head to one of the undisputed heavyweights of British cuisine? Simon Rogan’s four Michelin starred L’Enclume in Cumbria. How four? Well, they’ve got the maximum three red stars for gastronomy, plus a green star for sustainability. It’s as good as it gets in the world of the rotund tyre man, and the perfect place for a (self) celebratory pilgrimage. 

L’Enclume sits in the almost uberbucolic village of Cartmel up in the Lakes. You’d be forgiven for thinking that Rogan has taken the whole place over,. There’s his shop, another restaurant, Rogan & Co (with its own star) and accommodation for diners dotted around the cobbled lanes. But this is a real working village, not a Disneyfied simulacrum. There are two schools and plenty of other non-Rogan businesses operating. Hell they even have their very own ultra-aggressive traffic warden, who, it’s rumoured, will stop at nothing to slap a ticket on your car, should you break the rules.

L’Enclume sits in the almost uberbucolic village of Cartmel…

We were staying at L’Enclume House, which is only a minute or two from the main restaurant, and almost next door to Rogan & Co. It’s the restaurant’s main accommodation building, where you’ll find half a dozen or so of the 16 bedrooms on offer. All the buildings are old, timbered cottages, so expect low beams and the occasional unexpected step… Be warned, there’s one as you enter L’Enclume House reception that I reckon has taken many a diner down) My double, on the first floor, was painted in muted shades of sage, with taupe carpets, a modern bathroom and a seriously comfortable bed. Think cosy and tasteful rather than flash and fancy (a vibe which carries through to both the restaurants). The pal had a grander bedroom on the ground floor with a sleigh bed and a dressing alcove. But the decor and feel was similarly low key and welcoming.

Ditching our bags, we headed off for an explore of the village. Which essentially involved a three minute amble, followed by a beeline for a local pub, The Cavendish Arms. It turns out The Cav can make a mean vodka martini, as well as serving a decent range of beers and wines to a clientele which seemed equally split between locals with their dogs and those visiting L’Enclume.

A three minute amble, followed by a beeline for a local pub…

So, a couple cocktails down, we headed over to L’Enclume for supper. As you’d expect at three star heights, this involved a tasting menu (of fifteen courses) which comes in at £275 a head. Greeted by the young team, we headed through the first dining room and into a sort of conservatory which was connected to the kitchen.

Now, I’ve got nothing against conservatories in principle (well, I do, a little). But, because they generally have mostly glass walls, you need to be very careful with your lighting, to avoid reflective glare making the room seem more like a double glazed operating theatre than a convivial dining space. And my main gripe with our meal was that the lighting in this room was way too bright. One of the corner spots was pointing almost directly into my eyes. It slightly took the shine off the warmth and friendliness of the welcome. 

Anyway, enough about the bulbs, let’s talk food. We began with three snacks, each of which was genuinely memorable. A tiny crisp pastry shell, studded with sunflower seeds, held a tangle of salty mackerel, topped with beetroot, which gave the bite both freshness and an earthy undertone. As well as being delicious, the tartlet was the prettiest dish of the day, topped with a layer of edible petals which made it look like the head of a particularly beautiful flower.

Enough about the bulbs, let’s talk food…

Next, crisped pork and eel fritter with fermented corn was little short of genius; an amalgam of flavours and textures that had no right to work together. And the snacks rounded off with Cora Linn (a nutty Scottish sheep’s cheese) pudding with birch sap and stout vinegar, both of which acted to lighten up what would otherwise have been a substantial mouthful. Just so you know, in my original notes made after the meal, I wrote ‘cuts well through the cheese’ which gives off an olfactory impression probably best avoided in a food write up.

For me, these snacks perfectly represented the ethos of L’Enclume. Unpretentious ingredients, many of which were local, some foraged, treated by the kitchen with infinite skill and a delicate touch. And this approach carried through many of the starters, including autumn brassicas cooked over fire with chicken fat and Welsh black truffle and a Japanese style seaweed custard with indecently sweet little Mylor prawns.

I won’t however pretend I loved every one of the procession of savouries. The monkfish with sugarsnax carrots was a perfectly cooked piece of impeccable fish, but the carrots were simply too sweet for me and there wasn’t enough of the accompanying salted roe to dial them down. I also wasn’t a fan of the frozen Tunworth Cheese that heralded the start of the sweets, finding it overpowering, the cheese too insistent in my mouth as it melted. But you shouldn’t expect to love every dish on a multi course taster like this. Part of the fun is challenging your tastebuds, trying things that make you think rather than provide immediate gratification.

I won’t however pretend I loved every one of the procession of savouries…

And to be fair, once the puddings began, they didn’t miss a step. A chocolate ‘anvil’ containing a miso infused caramel mousse that tasted like God’s own Rolo. Smooth to the touch, edible, mint flavoured pebbles (scattered into a bowl of actual pebbles, which looked nigh on identical). Meadowsweet with currants and rosehip syrup.  A woodruff infused tart with peach leaf. These were just the highlights of a truly superb and entirely original sweet section. The unifying theme for the puddings was balance. The sweetness of the caramel offset by miso. The syrupy currants counterpointed with the herbal meadowsweet. This ying-yang is what’s entirely missing from dessert staples like sticky toffee pudding. And it’s why I usually swerve the sweets but here they represented a genuine highlight of the meal. 

With this panoply of dishes, we opted for the £125 (each) wine ‘taster’, the least spendy of the available pairings. There were some gorgeous pours, including a late harvest Gewurtz from Rolly Gassman that just never ended on the palate. There was also a minerally, peachy fiano from Puglia. And an Aussie Nebbiolo from the 2010 vintage that tasted exactly like a great Barolo. But, in my opinion, there were far too many whites for an Autumn menu. In fact, I can recall only one red through the entire meal. According to the pairing list there was also a Rioja, however I don’t recall them pouring it. Every other glass seemed to be either sparkling or white and for me that simply didn’t work in in October. 

There were some gorgeous pours…

I appreciate this review won’t read like a one note homage to L’Enclume. This place though, deserves more than me taking the easy route and singing hackneyed and superficial praises. The experience was complex. It’s sophisticated yet laid back and serious without taking itself too seriously. It’s a place where you’ll find food to wow, make you think, and on occasion, raise an eyebrow. And it’s the thinking man’s three star; a genuine ambassador for inventive British cooking. And the perfect place for me to have marked my 150th.

Find it: Cavendish Street, Cartmel, Grange-over-Sands, LA11 6QA
Click it: www.lenclume.co.uk
‘Gram it: @lenclume

For more of Ari’s 150 reviews, like this one from L’Enclume, you can click here. And if you’re after food and drink in general, you’ll find more here. Enjoy!

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!