Colonel Saab, An Indian Restaurant That Could Only Exist In Britain…

We sent Ari to Trafalgar Square to review Colonel Saab’s Charing Cross restaurant. Here’s what he thought…

You all know the tramlines for this gig by now. I go to a restaurant and, if it’s any good, I tell you all about it. Doling out praise where it’s due and, I hope, constructive criticism when it’s deserved. But this week, I’m starting with a review of you, the dining public. If I stick my critic’s hat on (I don’t have one so feel free so send me any suitable headwear; I was thinking one of those cheese wedge caps sported by fans of the Green Bay Packers would be rather fitting), y’all would get a 10/10. Because it’s thanks to the willingness of British eaters to try any kind of food, from every corner of the world, that this country has, without doubt, the greatest breadth of culinary choice per square mile than anywhere on the planet.

One of the joyous outcomes of the adventurousness and open minded nature of British diners has been, over the past decade, an absolute explosion of authentic yet innovative ‘ethnic’ food. I appreciate the catch all term ‘ethnic’ doesn’t do justice to the cornucopia of cuisines available on our streets. But you get what I’m talking about. And here’s my theory about why, apart from our willingness to embrace variety, these places have popped up across our Isles.

First generation migrants arrived here via Windrush or expulsion by a variety of dictators from their motherlands. And/or other means and motivations. And they initially set up restaurants which served heavily anglicised Indian/Chinese/Bangladeshi food designed not to frighten the British horses. And who doesn’t love a sweet and sour pork, chicken tikka masala or lamb korma? But time moved on. Second generation migrants were born here to their pioneering parents. And this new lot felt more a part of this place than their parents ever did. They had sufficient confidence that they belonged here to explore more genuine food from their homelands, returning to their roots and willing to gamble on the Brits being able to take to it.

An absolute explosion of authentic yet innovative ‘ethnic’ food…

And unlike in France, Italy, Spain or pretty much everywhere else in Europe, we lapped it up. So take a bow, eaters of Britain! It’s because of you that we get places like Colonel Saab, the restaurant I’m going to tell you about today. 

There are two branches of Colonel Saab, sited not much more than a mile apart in central London. I arrived half an hour late and a slightly sweaty mess, having ‘enjoyed’ 45 minutes underground stuck on the District Line thanks to a fire alert. The staff at Saab couldn’t have been sweeter about my late arrival, bustling round to organise cold water and, even more crucially a cold gin sling, to chill things down.

We opted for the tasting menu at £80 a head for six courses. Mainly so we didn’t have to faff around with choosing what to eat. The menu aims to reflect a journey around India, designed by chef Sohan Bhandari to include both home and high end Indian cuisine and first up was a rasam, a southern Indian spiced tomato soup which is usually served with rice. Instead it came in a shot glass with some puffed pastry bites. Along with cute mini rice cakes on a skewer to dip into. This rasam wasn’t in any way moulded to ‘western’ tastes. It was properly hot, spicy and sour, just as you’d find on the subcontinent. It was a confident, impressive start to the meal. And it signalled that this place wasn’t afraid to serve up the real deal. Even if that meant giving my tastebuds a proper workout.

We opted for the tasting menu at £80 a head for six courses…

This was a hard dish to follow and to be honest I thought it put the Raj Khachori, which came next, slightly in the shade. The Khachori was basically a gussied-up version of the veggie Indian street food bhel puri with a crisp thinnish (but not thin enough for me) pastry shell encasing potato and chickpeas in a lime chaat masala. It was perfectly good, but I prefer the daintier version you get for about 30p on every street corner in Mumbai.

What was outstanding was a black spiced jam that came with the Khachori. Complex, earthy with a twang of acidity and some sweetness to mellow the pill. It was one of the highlights of the meal. As was the next starter, Kandhari paneer tikka. I thought I’d had my fill of paneer (a type of Indian white cheese with a consistency a little like a soft haloumi). I’ve had it grilled, poached in curry and in salads but this version was best in breed by some distance. Intensely smoky from the BBQ, firm but not bouncy and stuffed with pomegranate and some cooked down prunes for a decadent sticky filling. I could have eaten this on its own for supper and been happy as a pig in the proverbial. 

The food, though, kept on coming. Two curries arrived. The first, Nadan fish, was delicate and creamy, one for fans of the mild and unthreatening korma. The second, an evocatively named ‘Sunday curry’ was the total opposite, stridently spiced lamb in a deep and dark burgundy coloured sauce, I could taste this several minutes after finishing a bite, and it really felt like the kind of dish someone at home in India would make for their family.

The food, though, kept on coming…

These mains came with cute little tiffin-like dishes of sides, including fluffy cumin potatoes, Poryal beans (diced green beans fried with coconut), perfectly cooked rice and flaky paratha. Way, way too much food. But also too good not to eat. I was more stuffed than the paratha by the end and begged the waiting staff, all of whom were unfailingly charming, helpful and seriously well-informed about the food, to hold the puddings. The response was a very typically Indian entreaty that I should, ‘just have one bite’. That ‘one bite’ turned out to be both a lime cheesecake and a raspberry and coconut tart. They were fresh, fragrant and delicious but neither of which I had the stamina to do justice to. 

Colonel Saab does proper, regional, exciting Indian food with slick service, ambitious cocktails and a contemporary and friendly vibe. Weird though this sounds, it’s a place that could only really exist in Great Britain. 

Find it: 40 – 42 William IV Street, Charing Cross, WC2N 4DD
Click it: www.colonelsaab.co.uk
‘Gram it: @colonelsaab

We hope you enjoyed Ari’s review of Colonel Saab Trafalgar Square. For more like it, click here to see all our reviews…

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!