Close your eyes and try to picture your perfect Italian lunch. Perhaps it would involve sitting on a terrace overlooking the pencil thin cypress trees which punctuate the rolling hills of Chianti. Add a bottle of crisp white, accompanied by course after course of the freshest ingredients, beautifully prepared and served to you by serious yet charming waiters, all for well under £100 a head. Unfortunately, these days, this tends to be the Italy of the imagination rather than reality. What you can actually expect, at least in the tourist focused parts of the home of la dolce vita, is substandard food (here’s looking at you Venice) or monumentally rude staff (take a bow, Rome) or almost worse, an average meal, with nothing to write home about, that will leave you 300 euros lighter in the pocket. Unless you go to Caldesi, my review this week.
Because this is somewhere you can go and eat the Italian meal you’ve conjured up in your mind. Simple, beautifully made and executed food in a warm and friendly space with staff dedicated to giving you a great time. And it’s a 10 minute walk from Bond Street.

Giancarlo Caldesi has operated a restaurant from Marylebone Lane for well over 30 years. And 23 of them have been at the current outpost, Caldesi in Marylebone. Given the frequency with which restaurants change hands or shut down, particularly in the current economic climate, this longevity alone should tell you something. It’s team know how to please their clientele. And, having spent a flawless three hours having lunch at Caldesi, I can confirm… From front of house to the kitchen and all things in between, you will be in very safe hands.
This longevity alone should tell you something…
It’s a rare perk of this job that, on occasion, I get to eat with the chefs and operators of the places I tell you about. So for this lunch I was joined by both Katie and Georgio Caldesi, mother and son. Katie has worked alongside her husband Giancarlo since 1996. She’s also author of 19 cookery books many focusing on health as much as enjoyment (about which more later).
Georgio’s dedication to Caldesi is obvious. Not only from his infectious enthusiasm but also because he gets stuck into every part of the business. Ranging from plumbing (he showed me images of yesterday’s pipework) to organising and hosting private dining. He even lives in a flat above the shop, like a true Italian.
I quickly decided my best bet was to defer selection of the food and drink to this dream team, who between them seem to work across the Caldesi mini empire, which spans from UK and Tuscany-based cookery schools (la Cucina Caldesi) to a ruralish restaurant (Caldesi in Campagna in Bray) in addition to the Marylebone restaurant I visited.
My best bet was to defer selection of the food and drink to this dream team…
Georgio started things off with the antipasti board (£34) groaning with Italy’s greatest hits, from nocerella olives (bright green, fruity and firm, and my favourite martini olive) to silky mortadella by way of superior pecorino, peperonata and wonderful ribbons of still warm gently grilled courgette. There was easily enough for three as a starter, but Giorgio couldn’t help himself from adding a beef carpaccio and a little dish of Parmigiana di Melanzane, the tomato sauce of which was truly outstanding (tomatoes for the restaurant arrive from Sicily at this time of year, followed by other parts of Italy later in the season and, finally, in deepest summer, the Isle of Wight).
I also learnt a trick from Georgio (although it was, he explained, pioneered by his brother). You twirl the carpaccio round a fork, like spaghetti. This enables you to inhale the entire portion in a single bite. It’s something I can’t wait to show off to my seven year old! Being not at all Italian but fundamentally greedy, I topped up the starters with a perfect vitello tonnato. The razor-thin, juicy and pink slices of slow roasted veal sit under a subtle tuna mayonnaise with fat caper berries for company.
Tomatoes for the restaurant arrive from Sicily at this time of year…
Realising after the first couple glasses of a crisp, stone fruit Falanghina that this wasn’t going to be a short or abstemious lunch, I then decided to order sea bass ravioli as a primo piatto, before deferring once again to Georgio and finishing with veal Milanese. The ravioli were outstanding. Silken parcels with a little bite, encasing delicate, just poached fish. There’s a real skill to execution here. A minute too long and you end up with cotton wool. It came coddled in an Amalfi lemon sauce. This managed to be both bold and subtle through some weird alchemic miracle. There were also enough ravioli for at least two people, despite it costing under £20. Frankly that’s a little absurd for food of this quality.
Having eaten almost the entire plate of pasta, I admit I was a little defeated when the veal arrived. It was however, seriously tempting. Beautifully crisp, the veal was beaten to a quarter inch thick, breadcrumbed and fried on the bone for added flavour. It was delicious but so generous a portion that it draped over the edges of the full size dinner plate it came on. I simply couldn’t do it justice. Not to worry! At my request they packaged it up and the following day I had the brunch of my life, frying it off with an egg and some capers.
So generous a portion that it draped over the edges of the full size dinner plate it came on…
Now if all this food seems rather decadent, luxurious and frankly, a little too much for lunch, worry not. Because in addition to producing superlative Italian food, Katie and the team have a keen (whilst not evangelical) focus on the effect of their dishes on diners’ wellbeing. More than half the dishes and the majority of the sides are marked ‘LC’. This indicates low carb but you’d struggle to spot any of them as obvious healthy options.
Examples included tagliata di manzo (Italian style sliced sirloin in a mushroom sauce), the previously mentioned vitello tonnato and from the sides a revelatory dish of friarielli (a type of thin stemmed broccoli) which had the bitterness of chard without the muddy undertones and had been cooked long enough so the woody stalks were rendered a yielding savoury, beautifully grown up, slightly bitter mouthful. So you can choose to eat here in a way that won’t hasten on a heart attack. The motivation for this approach is very much a family affair, with Giancarlo having been diagnosed with type two diabetes several years’ back, a condition kept entirely under control though the low carb diet reflected in aspects of the restaurant’s menu.
It was 4pm by now and Katie had to get away to do some actual work! Which left me and Georgio to ponder the puddings. I said no way. He nodded in agreement, but then immediately turned to the waiter and said, ‘let’s just have the Sicilian banana mousse’. Which is the nearest to not having pudding I was going to get away with.
This approach is very much a family affair…
What arrived was a large martini glass full of lemon curd, banana mousse, caramelised pine nuts and crushed amaretti biscuits. Sharpness, fruitiness and a nutty sweet finish. Wonderful, especially when twinned with a glass of conker-brown 20-year-old vin santo. It would give any Sauternes a run for its money. Now I’m not sure what aspect of this dessert arrived via Sicily but that really didn’t matter. Not least because this was such a fun way to end the meal. Plus it was light enough to manage after eating my body weight in veal.
Throughout this rather epic meal we were served by a team of mostly (all?) Italian waiters who were smooth, charming and passionate about food, as all Italians are. I’ll level with you. If you’re the kind of punter that’s after the latest hot table, prefer Instagramming your plates to eating what’s on them and need the buzz of the novel, please don’t go to Caldesi. But if you want to be transported to Italy for an afternoon and eat better food than you’ll get in the motherland, then head over to Marylebone Lane pronto.
Find it: 118 Marylebone Lane, Marylebone, W1U 2QF
Click it: www.caldesi.com
‘Gram it: @caldesiinmarylebone
If you enjoyed Ari’s review of Caldesi (course you did!) then you can read more bits here. You won’t regret it! And if you love Italian restaurants, here’s our listicle of London’s very best…
