Michelin Star Dining, Spa Treatments & Stunning Scenery, This Devon Hotel Has It All

In the midst of the debate as to the precise extent to which humanity has lost its autonomy/sense of purpose/hopes for the future thanks to smartphones and social media, there’s one technological development which has had zero downside. In car sat nav. What’s not to love about the charmin Garmin? By my entirely scientific reckoning, this invention has single handedly denigrated divorce rates across the developed world. And as someone who breaks out in a panic sweat at the mere marriage of the words ‘ordnance’ and ‘survey’ I’ve more than most to be thankful for. So, as usual, I entirely relied on the sat nav to find my way from London down to my review at Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa in Devon.

The hotel sits between the south-west coast and Dartmoor National Park. And after a blissful four hour traffic and child free drive with my missus, L, happily asleep most of the way, ‘satty navs’ (he deserves a monicker) told me I was 0.6 miles away. The problem was my eyes were telling me we seemed to be in the middle of the slightly unsexy Newnham Industrial Estate just outside the town of Plympton. Large car parks and warehouses aren’t the usual backdrop for a country retreat, so I started, for the first time in recent memory, to doubt the miracle guidance system. More fool me. That 0.6 miles made all the difference.

Boringdon Hall Hotel & Spa Review: Hall

We headed up a steep track out of town, down a lane bordered with ancient slate walls, and suddenly found ourselves in a Devonian paradise. Gnarled rainforesty trees whose roots had entwined themselves into the dry stone walls, bordered the hotel’s grounds. And the place itself is pretty as a picture; ancient, castle-like and, over the Christmas period, the entire building comes wrapped in a giant red ribbon. 

And suddenly found ourselves in a Devonian paradise…

We popped through the front door, which looked about a thousand years old (possible, bearing in mind the place has been around for so long it’s mentioned in the Domesday Book) into a reception area positioned next to a grand baronial triple height hall. I half expected to be accosted by a knight in armour, but instead was handed a glass of superior mulled wine by a member of the hotel’s staff. On the topic of staff, and to save repetition, each and every member of the team went out of their way to make our stay special, but particular mention ought to go to Wayne, the consigliere who managed to be everywhere he was needed, all the time, and to Alex, whose unfussy mastery of the hotel’s tech made me feel old and feeble.

Our suite, called Hypnos, was at the far end of the modern spa wing which has been added to the original building, down a corridor decorated in the usual mellow beigey tones of 5 star gaffes, with one very unusual addition. The walls were lined not with the usual boring corporate art but with panels of living moss. Not only was this a beautiful, natural touch, but it turns out thick carpet plus moss walls equals perfect noise dampening. As a result, we didn’t hear another guest from our room during our long weekend stay, despite the fact the place was fully booked. 

The walls were lined not with the usual boring corporate art but with panels of living moss…

Hypnos is a proper suite- it has a huge, separate sitting room with a fantastic modern fire and a contemporary, luxe bedroom with four poster bed looking out onto a private terrace with a brushed steel hot tub. The last time I saw a room as beautifully appointed as this I was in the Maldives. But that holiday, unlike our stay at Boringdon, required a gentle remortgage of our house to afford.  

Boringdon Hall Hotel & Spa Review: Suite
Boringdon Hall Hotel & Spa Review: Acleaf

We spent two nights at Boringdon so were able to try both the fancy pants flagship restaurant ‘Àclèaf’ as well as the more casual Mayflower Brasserie. Both are just off the Great Hall so history buffs (of which I am not one) can get their fill of bas-reliefs, oils and minstrels’ galleries as they scoff.

Àclèaf was impressive, the staff superbly drilled, the details you’d expect from a Michelin starred restaurant all present and correct.

The last time I saw a room as beautifully appointed as this I was in the Maldives…

The standout dish was the simplest. Freshly picked Brixham crab with a mild curry seasoning and crisp slivers of apple. The venison loin that featured in my main was also of the highest quality. And handled with the care it deserves by head chef Scott Paton and his team. Another high point was the bread, a truly superb, chewy baguette (far superior to anything you’d find in France). It comes with two outstanding butters. The first, a traditional beurre du sel, bright yellow and topped with excellent sea salt. The other made with goat’s milk and sweetened up with a little truffle honey.

Even better, the breads came with razor thin rectangles of top quality Pata Negra jamon. Resisting the temptation to make an uber-posh ham sandwich, I ate the jamon all on its own. Pro-tip, try pushing it up onto the roof of your mouth and leaving it there for a minute. It maximises the earthy, acorny flavours you get from this king of the pigs. You need to understand I’m a total jamonophile. My WhatsApp profile picture is a photo of my best ever leg of Iberico’s finest. I know my pork, and this was top grade and is highly recommended.

I also totally recommend you pay the £80 for the wine pairing. Mainly because, for the quality and quantity of wine poured, it was a total steal. On the night we went they were free pouring 2018 Chateau Musar from magnum, with the venison. Which is slightly insane, given a glass of this would set you back around £50 on its own. Four courses plus the little snacky bells-and-whistles expected by Michelin sets you back £120. So £200 a head all-in for good food, plus the superb wines. Which isn’t bad at all for this level of experience.

If you only have one night at the hotel, I’d possibly incline towards dining at the Mayflower. The Mayflower Brasserie, where we dined on our second night was a more straightforward offering on paper. There’s a standard a la carte rather than a tasting menu. The night we went, a Saturday early in January, the place was chokka. Several tables were turned for a second service during the course of the evening. Given that mains come in around the £30-£40 mark, so not cheap, filling every seat on a cold January night says everything you need to know about what punters make of Mayflower.

I went for a haddock chowder to start. It was prettier than soup has any right to be, the liquid poured tableside over the gently poached haddock and supersweet charred corn, into rough textured, hand turned bowls. Homely, soothing whilst also a sophisticated take on this classic, it was a winner from first to last spoon.

Filling every seat on a cold January night says everything you need to know…

For the main I had a rare fillet of beef, with a Wagyu bonbon and dauphinoise potatoes. The latter could’ve been a little more rustic, but this is probably personal preference. I like my spuds seething in cream, heavily seasoned and bubbling all over the plate, not neatly sliced like yesterday’s quiche.

L had the risotto which I gamely tried to turn her away from on the basis mushroom risotto is too boring to write up. She however, equally gamely, elected to completely ignore my advice. She seemed incredibly happy with the dish but that might have just been her making a point. So let’s put the risotto down as ‘possibly great’.

After all the eatings (not a word, but why not?) we headed to the spa. It’s a major feature of Boringdon Hall. It’s very smart, adults-only, high tech and vaguely modelled on a Roman spa. There are all the saunas, steam rooms and chill out zones you could possibly want. As well as a proper indoor pool and indoor/outdoor hot tub.

We headed to the spa. It’s a major feature of Boringdon Hall…

The place was, perhaps unsurprisingly for the Friday following NYE, well attended. Presumably everyone had turned up to sweat off the effects of Christmas. Which didn’t bother us since we were able to retire to our own private hot tub back at the suite. We spent so long in it that we completely failed to catch the Quadrantis meteor shower everyone’s raving about. 

We rounded off the weekend with a three hour walk amongst the wild ponies on Dartmoor. Passing waterfalls, moss-covered oak trees and ferns with more in common with Brazil or Congo, than Plymouth, it was beautiful. We left this wonderful place incredibly reluctantly. Boringdon Hall Hotel & Spa is magical, historic and set in the middle of fairy tale countryside. It gave us the perfect start to 2025.

Find it: Boringdon Hall Hotel, Plymouth, Devon, PL7 4DP.
Click it: www.boringdonhall.co.uk
Splash it: Prices range from £175 for a stable room for two
‘Gram it: @boringdonhall

We hope you enjoy hearing Ari’s review of Boringdon Hall Hotel & Spa. There’s more of his jottings, mainly lunch-based, here. And for all our reviews, click here…

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!