Asked what my least favourite cuisine is, the answer is always the same. Fusion. Often attempted by over-ambitious kitchens, in an attempt to please everyone, the food typically turns into a nightmare mashup that’s confusing and dissonant at best and downright unpleasant at worst (sushi burger or pad Thai pizza anyone?). But. There’s another vaguely related phenomenon, relying on some of fusion’s principles, where a chef has the skill, understanding and confidence to borrow from multiple nations’ larders, and work a kind of alchemy in bringing it all together, making it more than the sum of its parts. This is genius level stuff, ridiculously rare to find and worth celebrating and seeking out. And, as you might have guessed by now, this week’s review, Bear by Carlo Scotto in Beaconsfield, was one of those finds.
So, a few months back, Scotto opened a fourteen-seat chef’s table experience in the Crazy Bear Hotel in Beaconsfield. He had to shut his previous restaurant, Amethyst in Mayfair, thanks to some alleged shenanigans on the part of his business partner. Well London’s loss is to Buckinghamshire’s benefit.
Despite the fact that this county generally, and Beaconsfield specifically, are wealthy commuter belt areas, there’s a dearth of really high-end restaurants (with the obvious exception of the much beloved Artichoke in Amersham). So, I can see the sense behind this fairly famous chef, with a loyal London following, upping sticks and, well, moving to the sticks. Hell, some of his Amethyst groupies were at Bear the night we dined! They travelled from London and Carlo told us this was a regular occurrence. But what this place needs to succeed will be a new breed of fans. Ones more local to his new place and able to come for a meal without schlepping over from the Big Smoke. And whether Scotto gets that new crowd really depends on just how good his food is.
Some of his Amethyst groupies were at Bear the night we dined…
We started in a dinky little lounge, upstairs from the dining room proper. On arrival, I was handed a flute of lemony, light Champagne from the producer Frere Jean by one of the two super slick front of house mini-team. This was quickly followed by a little procession of snacks, brought to our table by Scotto’s second in command, Nkosi. It was obvious from the first mouthful that something serious is going on at Bear. The onion shell filled with otoro tuna, caviar and pickled magnolia (yes, really) was sublime. Rich, piquant, delicate and beautifully presented. Almost as good was a scallop kanikama with diced freshest raw scallop and, thankfully none of the surimi/fake crab sticks that are usually part of this dish in Japan.
After the snacks, we headed downstairs for the rest of the meal. Dark, variegated marble counter. Open fire. Hand blown Zalto glassware and black Inox cutlery, made for quite the first impression. As did the first starter, a delicate pastry shell encasing cured chalk stream trout with a dab of foie gras and a hint of whisky. It tasted a bit English, a bit French and a bit Scottish. And altogether entirely fantastic.
After the snacks, we headed downstairs for the rest of the meal…
The next dish though, totally eclipsed the trout (in fact it eclipsed every other dish as well). Perfect pearlescent Atlantic cod arrived sitting in a little coral coloured foamy bath of a sauce that contained peanuts, soybeans, curry spice, mango and salsify. My instincts told me there were way too many elements, from way too many places, for this to work. My instincts were wrong. The cod had a purity of flavour that had room to absorb the robust flavours. Somehow, soy and Indian style spicing worked in concert, creating a warm umami hum, brought together with the sweet and soothing mango hit. It was an absolute triumph! A dish that left me stunned and really marked Scotto out as cooking at boss level.
Of course, there were a couple misses to go with all these hits. I thought the agnolotti pasta that came next was perfectly made and cooked but was let down by a sauce that was too sweet and caramel-y. Also, the brioche that arrived with a wonderful wood ear (type of mushroom) tea was too crispy, shattering everywhere when handled. Although to be fair to the chef, it was obvious that the kitchen intended the bread to shatter like shrapnel, since they encouraged us to make a mess breaking it up. But compared to the highs, the lows were almost non-existent.
We had duck smoked in Arabian spices with locally foraged hen of the woods mushrooms, cooked over fire. And the best pre-dessert I’ve ever been served; nashi pear sorbet with chestnut and a meringue which Scotto branded with a white-hot piece of charcoal at table. And a frankly incredible one bite cheese course comprising St Helena cheese with local honey and black truffle.
Compared to the highs, the lows were almost non-existent…
Much of the menu was given over to ingredients sourced from around Beaconsfield. The honey was from Penn, the duck from Aylesbury, the trout from a nearby chalk stream. This isn’t some menu gimmick. Every morning Scotto and his team start prep by going foraging. Think about how much work that means for the chefs. 12-hour days, searching for and then preparing and cooking the dishes. And you get eight courses of this, plus the snacks, for £140. It would definitely be more in London. And for me, this represents real value. Particularly when you consider the quality of ingredients and effort that went into each plate.
We decided at the outset to go full throttle and have the wine pairing. This included some super-rare and unusual wines. Like the Cali ‘Fast and Loose’ Tank Garage 2018, a perfumed complex and silky red and a beautifully clean and minerally 2015 German Riesling Spatlese from Hexamer. The wine flight focuses on quality rather than quantity, with pretty small pours of each wine. This enabled us to sample a different bottle with each dish and not feel overserved by the end. To be honest this was my fourth restaurant in five days and I rather welcomed the slightly abstemious servings. If you like your glass a little fuller, order a bottle instead.
We decided at the outset to go full throttle…
All these words I’ve written are really the long way round stating the obvious. Carlo Scotto is an exceptionally sophisticated and talented chef. He’s doing stuff, with ingredients from around the world, that defy expectations. Let’s hope the denizens of Beaconsfield appreciate just how lucky they are to be home to this truly Great Bear.
Find it: Old Town, Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, HP9 1LX.
Click it: www.crazybear.co.uk
‘Gram it: @bearbycarloscotto
So, on the basis of Ari’s review, let’s all agree to head to Beaconsfield right now! If you want to read more reviews like this one, then click here! And if you want more foodie news and views, then click here…
