Iqbal Wahhab: How Restaurants Really Price Their Food – A Tale Of Two Lamb Chops (And Some Venison Ones Too)

For decades a group of my university friends have met for dinner to treat whosever birthday has just come to bear. For our fiftieths, this meant super-treats like weekends at Le Manoir or in The Cotswolds. More regularly, we’re in the West End and the most recent birthday boy chose Gymkhana for his turn (the poor lad tends not to stray from Chelsea or Mayfair and is one of those who doesn’t look at menu prices). 

On the chosen night, I met up with one of the gang beforehand and said I always enjoy my visits to Gymkhana and always get drawn to the lamb chops there but at £48 for three pieces, I always feel slightly guilty when I do so. My friend when one step further and said “Yes, let’s not order those tonight.”

how restaurants price their food
Credit: Tayyabs

In we go, birthday boy turns up and says: “I love the lamb chops here!” The manager taking our order points out there are four of us and would we like to make the order larger so that nobody gets FOMC (Fear of Missing Chop) so now it’s a £64 dish. Of course, they are outstanding. They always are.

We like to make the order larger so that nobody gets FOMC (Fear of Missing Chop)…

Many years ago, a group of food writer friends told me to stop being so snobbish in my reluctance to go to the east London legend that is Tayyabs which is known for the long queues to get a table and for their lamb chops which back then they charged £6 a portion for. They had some sway with the owner and managed to book a table so I couldn’t slip out of joining them because I loathed queuing – a phobia I later overcame.

My ever so slightly pompous edict over Tayyabs’ chops was that whilst they were well spiced and executed well, I suspected that people revelled over them because of their price as the quality of their lamb could have been a whole lot better. I met the owner and suggested to him if he bought better (ie more expensive) meat, he could charge more and make the dish known for its quality rather than its price. He might lose a few people in the queue, but he’d see more money in the till. After all, queues don’t make you money.

From the look he gave me from my suggestion, I imagine he’s happy I have never gone back there.

And here’s my own personal chop story – and trust me, this is all going somewhere. In 2002 at The Cinnamon Club one of the many daring things we did was to have the audacity to put on a main course at £31, a price no Indian restaurant had even got close to back then.

I have a completely unscientific theory that people will not order a wine that is cheaper than their main course…

It was a venison chop grilled with pickling spices and was quite spectacular. Even more spectacular was that overnight it became our most popular dish. People ordered it first to see what could possibly merit such a price and then continued having it because it was so special.

Our annual sales went up by £1m that year largely because of that dish and the decision of diners to choose better wines to bring out the best in it.

As an aside, I have a completely unscientific theory that people will not order a wine that is cheaper than their main course.

So by now you’re the grumpy judge in a courtroom drama who’s getting tired of a verbose lawyer and asks: “Is there a point to all this?” to which my answer is I think so and it’s this question which people don’t consider enough: How do restaurants decide what to charge for each dish? Sure, there’s a bit of science which chefs will adopt like the multiple between the cost of the dish and its sell price to make sure we hit our profit targets but it’s not as simple as that.

how restaurants price their food
Credit: Cinnamon Club
how restaurants price their food

Like many high-volume restaurants, at Roast we began analysing sales dish by dish every week using a scorecard, looking at the margins they produced, which were “must-haves” but didn’t generate much of a multiple like steak, through to “hero dishes” that we were known for like our Scotch eggs which we could charge £8 or £9 even though they cost about £1 to make. My role in these meetings was to judge our diners’ stretch – how much could we push the price up before a push back occurred?

And so here’s the point: for dishes they know you love because you’ve perfected them, upscale restaurants will charge as much as they can get away with. For me, Tayyabs haven’t perfected theirs and by scraping at low margins, they’re devaluing themselves by their perception as a cheap place to eat where others rake it in on the quality of what they create.

Upscale restaurants will charge as much as they can get away with…

There are significant pockets in London that are unaffected by the rising cost of living and I hope many choose to donate the rebate. Hopefully this isn’t insensitive to say, but I’d happily go back to Tayyabs – if they charged me more for an upgraded product. Obviously, the dining demographic profile of Whitechapel is miles away from Mayfair’s but in neighbouring Shoreditch there are restaurants charging big sums to big crowds, so London is no longer a simple tale of two cities.

Iqbal Wahhab OBE is the founder of London restaurants The Cinnamon Club and Roast. He is currently planning a new venture.

If you enjoyed reading about how restaurants price their food, find more from Iqbal here. Or if you can’t wait until his next Sauce column check out his blog!

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!