I took neither notes nor photographs when our snacks arrived. We’d just been served an impeccable couple of flutes of Champagne from the trolley (hers a 2009 Dom Ruinart Rosé, mine a 2016 Perrier Jouët Belle Epoque) and been sat down for our review at a vast banquette in the muted, elegant dining room at Alex Dilling at Hotel Café Royal. So it was fair to say the evening had already started well.
And then the snacks came. And they were, without any doubt, the best prelude to a meal I’ve ever encountered. A crab tart, the shell so thin, so crisp, the meat (all white) impossibly sweet and fresh. A lozenge of sea bass speared on a silver stick. The first lollipop I’ve ever loved. The bite was clean, the fish allowed to speak for itself, with just a little crunch from what I guess was some kohlrabi to provide texture. This was fish treated with the respect, restraint and skill you usually only find in £1,000 a head Japanese restaurants.
Then another tart, this one with a nuttier shell, dark brown, which contrasted beautifully with its filling of ribbons of medium fatty tuna. More weight to this bite, a stronger flavour, the snacks building in a crescendo, until we reached peak luxe with a mouthful of caviar and ricotta to finish. To be clear, what I’ve described was only the prelude to our meal. There were five actual courses to follow, but Alex Dilling had already won dinner before the first starter. It was an entirely sublime opening and one I will never forget.
This was fish treated with the respect, restraint and skill you usually only find in £1,000 a head Japanese restaurants…
I know. I have to move beyond the canapés before I exceed my word count and get an editorial slap down. Next up were Faroe Islands salmon rillettes, served with mini bagels. An homage to Dilling’s time in New York. The salmon, rich and buttery, sat in the bottom of a small white porcelain bowl with layers of a horseradish infused cream and cucumber on top. The cucumber had a subtle hit of vinegar, the horseradish just piquant enough to get your attention, without overpowering the fish.
Oh yes. And it was all topped off with a pile of Kaluga caviar. The caviar wasn’t even mentioned on the menu description. Most chefs would give such an expensive ingredient top billing, but this dish was about nostalgia for the time Dilling spent in New York bagel shops, not about fancy fish eggs. So it follows that the caviar was the least important ingredient conceptually (given you’d never be offered that option with your lox at a deli in the Big Apple). I totally understood why it was given a role in the play but had no lines.
Oh yes. And it was all topped off with a pile of Kaluga caviar…
This is insanely clever stuff, as well as the fact the dish simply ate perfectly. We dug our mother of pearl spoons into the salmon cucumber layers and spread the lot, caviar and all, onto the seeded bagels. Luxurious but laid back. Witty but utterly serious in execution. It is so rare to find cooking at this level.
Look, I didn’t fall in love with every single mouthful. In my view the next course, of Scottish blue lobster with a peppery sabayon, was a mere 9.5/10, on the basis I thought the lobster slightly undercooked, too soft and wobbly, with too little bite. But then Dilling himself appeared at the table bearing his Hunter’s Chicken and I was back in full-blown swoon. Nobody gets excited about chicken. It’s your steady, reliable, slightly boring mate. A safe protein play. But this dish finally gave chicken its place on a culinary pedestal. A glossy, glazed, pepper crusted breast, cut longitudinally so you could see the thin layer of wild mushroom duxelles and chicken mousse that surrounded it.
I was back in full-blown swoon….
In my first mouthful I could taste bacon, foie gras (from the Albufeira sauce) as well as the most succulent chicken of my life. Again, it was a blend of the comforting (the dish is a pub stalwart) with simply ridiculous technical precision.
With it we drank a German Pinot which worked beautifully with both the lobster and chicken. Don’t let people tell your seafood needs white wine. I often have a light delicate red with fish, especially in the colder months. German Pinot is, in fact, my new best friend. The weather where it’s typically made is positively Burgundian. Meaning you get a wine remarkably similar to its French counterpart, for half the price. Don’t tell everyone though.
We had the ‘short dinner tasting menu’ which comes in at £165 a head for five courses plus the best canapés of your life. If you have an ample appetite you could opt for the full eight courses for £225 (which I’m going back for before Christmas). Five though, was plenty, especially given what came out first. These are fair prices for any two Michelin star restaurant. But this is the best two star you’ll ever eat at so consider £165 a total bargain.
These are fair prices for any two Michelin star restaurant…
I can’t pretend I’m the first person to recognise the fact that Alex Dilling is a straight up genius. Michelin gave him his double stars, straight off the bat, six months after this place opened in September 2022. I don’t think any other chef has ever achieved that (Clare Smyth went straight to two super quick at Core in 2018, but not within six months of opening). I appreciate we still have a couple months left of 2026, but I’m going to call it. This was my winning dinner of the year.
Find it: Hotel Café Royal, 68 Regent Street, Soho (sort of), W1B 4DY
Click it: www.alexdilling.com
‘Gram it: @alexdillingcaferoyal
Click here for moire reviews like this one from Alex Dilling At Hotel Café Royal. And ones nothing like it, I suppose…
