Passion, Generous Portions & The Royal Ballet Of Wait Staff, Three Darlings Is A Real Discovery

Restaurant service is an art form I personally appreciate far more than the opera or ballet. When I eat out, a significant proportion of my pleasure derives from watching the dance of a great front-of-house team. When you’re enveloped by the skills of wait staff who genuinely know how to handle a room, you hardly notice them, unless you’re looking out for it. It’s the opposite of the performative bluster you often find in sub-par eateries. Those places where the staff seem to want you to know exactly how much effort they’re putting in.

For me, there are two great schools of waiting tables. French and Italian. And I’m a sucker for Italian. French service is generally high-class, but you get the feeling they hold you in contempt, that there’s a sneer lurking just beneath the surface. Italians actually like both the act of running restaurants and the people they’re serving. I know. These are sweeping generalisations. But I’m allowed to make them. This isn’t a scientific dissertation. It’s 800 words of me being a little irreverent. And I understand these ‘rules’ will always have exceptions. But, over the course of the hundreds of meals I’ve eaten out as your faithful critic, these are the impressions I’ve formed. 

Three Darlings, set slightly back from pretty-as-a-peach Pavilion Road, off Sloane Square, is a passion project from Irha Atherton and her superchef husband Jason. Why do I describe it as a passion project? Well, they’ve named it in honour of their three daughters, for a start. It’s also quite clearly a restaurant that’s there to give punters pleasure. Casual but high-end dining rather than Michelin star faff. They even describe it as a ‘British bistro’. This is a place to let your hair down, relax and enjoy yourself. 

A passion project from Irha Atherton and her superchef husband Jason…

We arrived around half past one on a weekday to find the beautiful terrace already two thirds full. Luckily we still managed to grab a lovely table amidst the foliage, basking in dappled sunlight. Quiet, peaceful, entirely traffic free. It’s the sort of place you dream about finding on holiday and wouldn’t stop banging on about when you got back. Except it’s in the middle of Chelsea, four minutes’ walk from the tube.

In tune with the summery, outdoor vibe, we kicked off with half a dozen oysters (£18 and a bargain these days) and a piquant roasted pineapple margarita (£15). The oysters were a little on the large side for my tastes, but good and firm. And, importantly, they came with a properly well put together mignonette. I’ve had a few oysters recently in restaurants which reckoned they could reinvent mignonette. At Three Darlings they’ve realised it’s much better directing their efforts at simply getting it perfect.

In tune with the summery, outdoor vibe, we kicked off with half a dozen oysters…

Next up, some seafood starters, with a bottle of crisp and buttery Macon Bussieres (£68) recommended by Tom, the relaxed, affable but also perfectly on-point restaurant manager, who was our spirit guide for the meal. He, together with our waiter Luca, are why I start this piece by banging on about service. Tom was always on hand, without being in any way overbearing. He gave advice but also listened to what we wanted, rather than trying to impose himself. This is subtle, difficult to pull off service.

Meanwhile Luca, an Italian gent of a certain age, demonstrated the art of waiting tables. He was simply magnificent. He never missed a beat, our glasses kept topped up with no more than an inch and a half of white throughout the meal (pour any more and it would have become warm), whisking away plates when we were finished, tidying up our table when I made a mess of it. I realised halfway through the meal that me and my plus-one were actually looking forward to his visits to our table. Between us we’ve probably had 200 lunches over the past twelve months, and we agreed Luca had won our inaugural Best Waiter Award, hands down. 

He was simply magnificent. He never missed a beat,…

Back to the food. I found the first of the starters slightly underwhelming. St Austell shellfish, cooked over embers (£16) read beautifully on the menu. But it was a little let down by some aggressively gritty clams. I appreciate these are a right bugger to clean, and some sandy bits will always remain, but there was too much crunch in each bite to really enjoy them. The mussels though, were fab, as was the smoked garlic emulsion in which the shellfish swam.

Then the Dorset queenie scallops (£7 each) arrived. Licked with fire from the grill, drenched in a spiced butter, served hot in their shells, they were totally magnificent. This time of year is peak British scallop season and these were the queen of the crop. And we wouldn’t have had these beautiful bivalves were it not for Tom, who decided to bring them out, despite us not actually ordering them, on the basis they were seriously worth a try. It was one of the many ways Tom gently steered our lunch, each of which tweaked up our meal. 

For the mains we shared a whole Cornish John Dory (£78) with crab rice (£21). Crab rice is having a moment. This version tacked towards an Italian style risotto. Velvety and rich, flavoured with a little brown crab meat but generously studded with shreds of white meat, it was comforting, luxurious and a wonderful playmate for the crisp skinned, firm fleshed, beautifully seared fish. You could order this for four rather than two and still feel you’d had plenty. There was at least £50 worth of fish, retail, on the plate, which is crazy generous when you think the restaurant has to pay its rent, staff, prepare and cook the dish and, in theory, make a profit. 

There was at least £50 worth of fish, retail, on the plate, which is crazy generous…

We decided we could eat no more, but Luca wouldn’t hear of it. Gently suggesting we ‘take a look’ at the dessert menu, he then led us to the cherry soft-serve ice cream. And a plum cheesecake. Remember. I don’t like puddings. I only agreed because by this stage I was a little in awe of Luca and was trying hard not to disappoint him. And I was delighted we listened. The soft serve cherry ice cream, in particular, was a silky, fruity, light, delight. It was made even more fun by the glasses of Chateau Suduiraut 2015 that Luca manifested, unbidden, saying he reckoned the wine would work perfectly with the cheesecake. This was serious Sauternes, nectar sweet but with a refreshing lick of acidity and whilst it was supposed to marry up with the cheesecake, I preferred it as an accompaniment to the ice cream…

A frankly show stopping end to our meal, we then enjoyed a little encore when Tom appeared, to bid us goodbye, with a couple glasses of ice cold Jacquesson 748 – an ultra-fine, bone dry, Champagne, fresh and zingy like a Granny Smith apple and which from now on is the only way I want to finish lunch. 

Find it: 241B Pavilion Road, Chelsea, SW1X 0BP
Click it: www.threedarlingslondon.com
‘Gram it: @three_darlings_chelsea

If you enjoyed Ari’s review of Three Darlings, then there’s more fabulousness awaiting. Click here for all manner of reviews (albeit generally limited to restaurants and hotels). And for more from Ari, click here…

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!