One of the very best bits of this job is that, almost every day, an invitation (or three) pops into The Sauce inbox, to review a newly opened restaurant, bar or hotel. Given that eating out is our very favourite pastime, this stream of temptatious emails provides a daily sugar rush of gastropportunities. But, there are only so many lunchtimes available a week. And there are, consequently, places that have been around a while, which we just fail to get to. There’s been an insistent insider hum about Fallow, since it opened. It was initially a pop-up, in Carousel and 10 Heddon Street, before taking permanent residence in St James in 2021. People. That’s almost five years’ ago. And we hadn’t managed to make it through the door to review Fallow. Until yesterday.
To be fair, it felt like the place had only just opened. It was heaving with punters, there was a massive queue outside and the bar was packed. The staff wove through the crowd, slinking through the micro gaps between diners, all of whom were having a blast. Even if the food had been meh, we’d have hard recommended this place on the basis of the atmosphere alone. But what followed was a three hour lunch during which we got through two animal faces, six napkins, too many drinks and used almost no cutlery.
Set just off St James’s, Fallow has quickly become one of the most talked-about restaurants in London. This is largely thanks to its obsession with sustainability and nose-to-tail cooking. But strip away the buzzwords and what you have is something far simpler and far more important: it’s delicious. Properly, memorably, embarrassingly delicious.
There was a massive queue outside and the bar was packed…
We celebrated our arrival at Fallow with their signature cocktail, an oyster shell martini. This drink tacks hard to the restaurant’s ‘waste not want not’ mantra. In this case they use leftover oyster shells, ground up, with which to infuse the Belvedere vodka for 24 hours, before pimping it up with a little tingle of jalapeño. The ice cold drink in its frosted glass arrived with a pale green oyster leaf garnish. This plant, which grows in the beds from which Fallow sources its bivalves, tastes exactly like an oyster. It was a genius addition to an already sophisticated cocktail and, frankly a hell of a way to kick off.
We started, sensibly, with the mussels. Listed simply as ‘flamed mussels’, which is either admirably restrained or a mild act of deception, depending on how you feel about underselling. They arrive glossed in a bacon butter sauce, sharpened with lemon and finished with parsley. The first thing that hits you is the smoke. Not theatrical, not overpowering, but woven through the dish so that every mouthful tastes faintly, insistently, of fire. The bacon lends a salty depth that seeps into the mussels themselves, while the lemon cuts through just enough to stop the whole thing collapsing in on itself. Rich, yes, but controlled. The kind of plate that demands bread, or at the very least a spoon. Because leaving that sauce behind would be nothing short of irresponsible. We sat there after the first bite, looked at each other, and silently agreed: we would come back just for this.
The potted shrimp crumpet follows, elevated a notch or two by a kitchen that seemingly can’t help itself. Brown shrimp bound in spiced butter, warm and glossy, piled onto a crumpet toasted just enough to hold its structure without surrendering the sponge. There’s apple running through it, lifting the richness with a brightness that has no right to work as well as it does, and a faint whisper of fennel giving the whole thing a slightly herbal edge. Comforting, unctuous, unapologetically indulgent, the crumpet soaking everything up until each bite feels almost too much, and then somehow, cruelly, not enough.
And then there is the cod’s head.
Fallow’s most iconic dish, and a strong contender for one of the most interesting things you can eat in London right now. Smoked cod’s head, served with a sriracha butter sauce that glows vivid orange against dark, lacquered skin. The heat is gentle – more of a hum than a kick – with garlic sitting just behind it, rounding everything out like a well-placed full stop. You are invited, quite literally, to pick it apart. Not just the cheeks (which everyone knows are the good seats) but the hidden corners. The jawline. The eye socket. The collar.
The collar, in particular, is a revelation. It’s sweet, delicate and unexpectedly meaty. There’s a softness to it that contrasts with the slight chew of the skin, all of it held together by that sriracha butter, which clings rather than coats.
The eye, for the record, I did eat. It pops. There is no more precise way of putting it. A strange, slightly surreal moment somewhere between curiosity and mild existential reckoning. Would I do it again? Probably not. But that’s not the point. The point is that Fallow makes you engage with your food in a way that most restaurants don’t bother to. It asks something of you.
The eye, for the record, I did eat. It pops…
With the cod we switched to an ethereal, delicate, strawberry scented Gamay/Pinot mash up from Burgundy. This was chosen by the young and, as it turned out exceptionally talented, sommelier as a great foil to the cod, and it was bang on the money. The high acidity and absence of grippy tannins meant it could handle the buttery sriracha sauce, as well as the nicely blackened parts of the fish face. It’s the kind of wine that drinks so easily, but as well as being approachable and moreish, was also complex, as it evolved in the glass from fruity to smoky and autumnal.
We doubled down on the theme with the whole pig’s head, because if you’re going to commit to a lunch of faces, you might as well go all in. This is not a polite dish. It is not one you order on a tentative first date, or with someone whose opinion of you still feels fragile. It demands intimacy – if only because you are eating it with your hands, cracking through blistered crackling, pulling apart fat and meat, navigating the anatomy of the thing together.
There is something undeniably, surprisingly sensual about it. The act of tearing, of sharing, of getting slightly, cheerfully messy. The meat itself is deeply flavoured. It’s rich without being cloying, the fat rendered down and melty. Textures shift as you go: crisp shards of crackling giving way to softer, almost sticky pieces beneath, all of it designed to be eaten communally.
There is something undeniably, surprisingly sensual about it…
On the side, corn ribs. Crisped until the kernels curl in on themselves, becoming almost toffee-like at the edges, and dusted with a salty-sour seasoning leaning hard on umami. Good, objectively. Just slightly outgunned by everything else on the table.
What Fallow does so well is balance purpose with pleasure without letting either bully the other. The sustainability angle isn’t an afterthought. Instead, it’s baked into the menu, the choices and the identity of the place. Dishes like the cod’s head and pig’s head aren’t gimmicks; they’re the logical extension of a kitchen that refuses to waste. But crucially, you never feel that you’re being lectured. You’re being fed. And fed very well.
You leave remembering the mussels: the smoke, the bacon, the lemon at precisely the right moment. The crumpet, soaking up butter like it was built for nothing else. The cod’s head, the surprise of the collar, the slight absurdity of the eye. The pig’s head, the mess of it, the intimacy of it.
It’s memorable, which is increasingly rare. And in a city as crowded as London, more than enough reason to book.
Find it: 52 Haymarket, St James’s, SW1Y 4RP
Click it: www.allowrestaurant.com
‘Gram it: @fallowrestaurant
If that double-header interview (unintentional pun there – two authors and they ate two animal heads…), then we’ve more reviews here! Meanwhile you’ll find more Ari stuff here. And more from Phoebe here! Enjoy!
