One of the few drawbacks of this job (perhaps the only downside) is that I very rarely get to return to a place I’ve reviewed. Each week brings a new list of places to check out, which I scurry off to without so much as a backwards glance at the restaurants in my rear view mirror. But, chef Scott Paton, who heads up Michelin starred Àclèaf at Boringdon Hall in Devon, decided to add a significant string (a brand new tasting menu) to the restaurant’s bow and so I had a good excuse to head back down south west to give it the twice over and re-review.
Àclèaf still serve their original signature menu, which brings four courses (each of which has four choices) plus some titbits at the start and finish, for £130. And for those who want to be able to exercise some control over what they’re eating, this menu makes total sense. But I quite like leaving it to chef to decide what I’m having (especially when the chef has Paton’s chops), and the new £180 no choice seven course taster perfectly fit my (greedy) bill.
Instead of a standard menu with descriptions for each course, diners on the taster get a little drawing of the root of a baby oak tree (Àclèaf is an old English word for oak leaf), with tendrils pointing to each of the seven key ingredients that make up the menu but no further elaboration. So you don’t actually know what you’re getting until it arrives at table. The key ingredients read like a gastrogeek’s dream. Crab, turbot, Dover sole, squab, wagyu, honey, chocolate. Who wouldn’t want a procession of these absolute bangers? And the concept upon which this menu is based is a return to a more classical style of plating, back to the roots of the ingredients if you’ll forgive my shameless word play.
I had a good excuse to head back down south west to give it the twice over…
So, we began with crab. And this wasn’t your average crustacean. Brixham crab, only the delicate white meat of which was used, taken from a 2kg plus crab. In crab world, bigger means tastier with a fuller depth of flavour and it showed in this heavyweight beauty. They serve it simply with a little diced mango to point up the sweetness of the flesh and a delicate curry emulsion to bring a little warmth and savour. Outstanding. It was an immediate entry in my top ten restaurant kick offs, hands down.
The next course brought a disc of just cooked turbot, wrapped in nori, with a little bitter liquorice note to balance out the rich beurre blanc. This dish perfectly epitomised the kitchen’s ethos with the new tasting menu… Classic ingredient but treated with some adventurous technique and flavour combinations. Personally, I would’ve added a spoon of caviar to the beurre blanc, to take the dish into f**k me territory. But this is less of a criticism than me being a bit OTT.
This dish perfectly epitomised the kitchen’s ethos…
The final fish course, Dover sole was, we were told, a swap from scallop. It’s a switch I was more than happy with, as Dover sole would be one of my last supper choices. One advantage of this fish is its meatiness, allowing it to play nicely against robust flavours. Here it came with a trio of accompanying sauces and gels, of which it really only needed the warmth and depth of a russet coloured, rustic caponata, which gave the dish a provencale feel, a welcome dash of late summer on the plate.
Fish finished, we turned to game, with a squab pigeon breast in a truffle jus. This was accompanied by what was described as ‘ethical’ foie gras. I had some fun discussing this concept with our very French maitre d’, who I suspect shared my scepticism about the wokeification of this ultimate luxury ingredient.
Apparently, friendly foie is made without forcing the birds to swallow pound after pound of corn through a tube, and instead, they’re allowed to choose to consume as much as they fancy. This clearly sounds like a much better deal for the ducks. However, the absence of compelled gluttony did have an impact on the richness of the liver. It basically tasted like diet foie. Whether you choose to ignore welfare in favour of fuller flavoured offal is entirely up to you. I reckoned it worked fine with the pigeon, bringing a little added richness, without overpowering the bird.
Accompanied by what was described as ‘ethical’ foie gras…
The final savoury course brought wagyu rump with a celeriac puree. Rump is a lean cut, mostly made up of well worked muscle. Which meant this didn’t have the explosion of melted fat that you typically get with wagyu. It was, however, undoubtedly high grade and had a butch Marmite-y savour that went perfectly with the entry level red Burgundy we drank with it (£66). Overall, I reckoned the starters beat the mains, but none of the dishes missed a beat. And they were balanced well enough for me to actually look forward to puddings, rather than feeling like I needed a lie down.
Before we get to puddings, the wine list is worth a shout out, since Àclèaf, unlike every other Michelin starred gaffe I’ve been to recently, seems to have stuck to a 2.5-to-3-times markup (rather than the 4-5-times new normal) throughout the list. This means you can drink serious wine at the £60 mark, rather than having to enter three figures territory. This makes having a couple bottles, without getting a second mortgage, a distinct possibility. Our second bottle, since you asked, was an outstanding Aussie Chardonnay from Margaret River, called Xanadu (£67). Australia is now making whites that taste like burgundy, rather than making you feel like you’ve licked an oak tree. Subtle, balanced, fresh and half the price of its French brethren. Look out for them on a wine list if you want a high quality but reasonably priced white.
There were three puddings to finish (well, one was a pre dessert, so two and a half). But I’m only going to talk about the white chocolate and lemon assiette. Because this was one of the best sweet dishes I’ve eaten in a good while. The chocolate was balanced beautifully by the slight sharpness of a subtle lemon cream, the dish pretty as a picture, each component part playing a distinct role whilst also working in concert. This course managed the alchemic miracle of feeling light and delicate whilst being indulgent and a bit silly. That’s what a pudding should be about.
One of the best sweet dishes I’ve eaten in a good while…
So. Was I glad to return to Àclèaf? No brainer. This meal was a triumph and the taster is a superb addition to Àclèaf’s offering. The decision by Scott Paton to introduce this menu gives the kitchen the ability to be more playful and adventurous. All whilst tacking hard to the basics that high end cuisine ought to be about. Complexity only where necessary. Classic ingredients. A light touch. Àclèaf has more than a Michelin star. It has a chef with a genuine Midas touch.
Find it: Boringdon Hall Hotel, Boringdon Hill, Colebrook, Plymouth, Devon, PL7 4DP
Click it: www.acleaf.co.uk
‘Gram it: @acleafrestaurant
Ari’s review of Àclèaf came immediately before his visit to Holm. So do check that out too, they’re both brilliant.. And for more reviews, click here!
