Phoebe headed down to review London’s hottest new opening, MATERIA…
We expect so much of chefs. Not just technically (though goodness knows the bar is high enough) but emotionally. We want them to make us feel something. We want them to send us back out into the grey London drizzle feeling slightly more alive. Most manage a competent meal and a reasonable bill; a very rare few actually do the thing.
This MATERIA review has been a long time coming, and not for lack of wanting. Victor Garvey had been living in my subconscious long before I ever sat down properly at one of his restaurants. My first encounter with his cooking didn’t happen in a 16-seat dining room in Notting Hill with low lighting and an expert sommelier. It happened in my kitchen, mid-lockdown, in a state of mild panic, attempting to plate a scallop with 24-month Parmesan Reggiano fondue from one of his SOLA at-home boxes. I remember the guilt vividly. Not because it wasn’t delicious (it was) but because I knew, with the quiet certainty of my father assembling flat-pack furniture without the instructions, that I was absolutely not doing it justice. Victor, if you’re reading this: I owe you.
So when MATERIA came along – his new, deeply personal project on Westbourne Grove – I was overexcited in a way I haven’t been since I was eight and we went to pick up the family kitten. There’s sixteen seats and low lighting. It’s a space that feels more like downtown New York than Notting Hill – intimate, considered and frankly very sexy. This is a tasting menu only restaurant. Said menu arrives in a wax-sealed envelope with a handful of ingredients beneath each dish. There are no theatrical explanations and no breathless prose about provenance, passion and/or the chef’s grandmother. You are not told what to think. You are simply invited to experience it. Which, it turns out, is either exhilarating or slightly confronting depending on who you’ve brought with you.
Victor, if you’re reading this: I owe you…
I brought my sister Honor. This was, in retrospect, optimistic of me.
It’s not that Honor doesn’t appreciate food (she does). It’s not that she isn’t excellent company (she is). What she is not, it quickly became apparent, is the right dining companion for a restaurant that opens proceedings by presenting a tray of the evening’s raw ingredients – including a live lobster, making direct and sustained eye contact with her, claws gently opening and closing with what I can only describe as a last chance bid for freedom.
She took a brief intermission in the bathroom.
She rallied, gamely. Until the exceptional course “March in five bites” – a sequence of extraordinary, ingredient-led snacks to open the tasting menu, representing some of the most exciting and technically brilliant cooking I’ve encountered in years. Rùben Santos, the restaurant manager (ex-Alex Dilling at Hotel Cafe Royal), was walking us through one of them: a smoked sardine tart. Except the tart isn’t pastry. It’s made from the sardines themselves, dried and compressed. He suggested, very gently, that we hold it up to the light. “You’ll see the black dots?” he said. “Those are the eyes.”
Honor, once again, was gone.
I want to be clear here: this is not a criticism of MATERIA. It is, emphatically, the opposite. This is a restaurant operating at a level where nothing is softened, nothing is hidden and nothing is diluted for comfort. The ingredient in its truest form, pushed to its most extraordinary expression. Rùben, for his part, is exceptional – warm, intuitive, perfectly calibrated, the kind of front-of-house presence that makes everything feel effortless and inevitable. He is very much a part of what makes this place extraordinary.
And extraordinary it is. A tomato dish transformed into vinegar jelly with Tokoroten noodles in a fermented tomato and miso broth is bright, sharp and deeply savoury – as an opening course, phenomenal. The cured King Ora salmon with fresh wasabi is precise and clean, almost to the point of showing off. A croustade of otoro with caviar is, quite simply, absurd.
He is very much a part of what makes this place extraordinary…
There was nothing we ate this evening that was anything less than spectacular. The smoked and grilled bonito with elderflower and tosazu jelly is one of those dishes that stops you mid-sentence, because your brain is trying to catch up with what’s just happened. The madai, done in the style of matsukasa-age with crisped scales (pinecone cooking, for those who care about these things) is textural perfection. And then the A5 Kagoshima wagyu. The sort of dish that makes you understand, very quickly, why people go to great lengths (and considerable expense) to both cook and eat at this level.
Halfway through, I messaged our critic Ari: “This is hands down the best meal I’ve had in 12 months.” I eat out four to five times a week. That is not a throwaway statement.
Pudding (Amaou strawberries with yuzu, sake and sansho pepper) arrives with the same level of intent as everything that came before it. And throughout, head sommelier Christian Vega moves things along with total assurance, each pairing doing exactly what it should, and doing it very, very well.
This is hands down the best meal I’ve had in 12 months…
MATERIA is exceptional. Genuinely, unequivocally exceptional. It is also purposeful and completely uncompromising, which are rare qualities in London right now. It makes no concessions, and that’s precisely the point.
Just, for everyone’s sake, don’t bring someone who’s squeamish about lobsters.
Find it: 115 Westbourne Grove, Notting Hill, W2 4UP
Click it: www.mater1a.uk
‘Gram it: @mater1a.london
If you want to read more reviews like this one of MATERIA, click here. And for foodie bits and bobs, here you go! You’re welcome!
