Long Live The Queen: Why Lilibet’s Just Gave Me My Favourite Meal Of The Year So Far

Standing majestic on Bruton Street in Mayfair, Lilibet’s is a maximalist fever dream in the very best sense. Edwardian flourishes, tall candles, floral upholstery, antique fireplaces, gilded frames and a bar that makes you want to cancel your plans and settle in for the night (I did). As someone who is, by nature, excessive, slightly ridiculous and deeply drawn to theatricality, I felt immediately at home. And yet, for all its flash and glitz, Lilibet’s doesn’t feel gimmicky, and as I was lucky enough to review it this week, I’ll take you with me.

The restaurant takes its name from the childhood nickname of Queen Elizabeth II, who was born on this very site when it was still a Mayfair townhouse. It certainly wasn’t inspired by Harry and Meghan’s later appropriation of it for their daughter (one imagines Her Majesty had notes). That sense of aristocratic theatre is very much the point of Lilibet’s. This is not a stripped-back seafood bar with exposed brick and a playlist from 2012. It is instead awash with antique fireplaces, floral wallpaper, gilt-framed paintings, smart candles and monogrammed napkins. Interior specialists Russell Sage Studio has leaned fully into turbo-chintz territory, but with the discipline to make it feel intentional rather than chaotic. It’s Versailles after two martinis. Less control, I am sure, was shown by the budget. 

Founder and former chef Ross Shonhan was there when we arrived. He is a brilliant person to meet, should you ever get the chance. Shonhan is not an obvious candidate for mock-Edwardian seafood grandeur. His CV runs through Nobu and the ramen revolution of Bone Daddies, followed by ventures in Dubai and Abu Dhabi. None of that screams 1920s British aristocracy. And yet here we are.

He is a brilliant person to meet, should you ever get the chance…

We took a wander around the space. Shonhan explained that the build was meant to take nine months, but it stretched to eighteen after contractor collapses and the inevitable domino effect of delays and the rising costs that follow. Unfortunate but not uncommon. What you see now is the result of perseverance. He designed the space “so that each section feels slightly different”. My reading of that is that Lilibet’s feels like wandering through the drawing room, dining room and bar of an extremely wealthy friend’s private residence, if that friend happened to have a thing for shellfish towers and theatrical pepper mills. And, of course, utterly fantastic taste. Hats off to Shonhan.

We began at the bar, which is reason enough to visit even if you never make it to a table. I ordered a vodka martini, a drink that is routinely mangled in lesser establishments. Too warm, too diluted, lacking bite. But this one was immaculate. Properly cold, bracing and handled with the assurance of a team that makes a lot of them and gets them right. The staff throughout were warm and relaxed, which in this part of town is not always a given.

Now, onto the food, because Lilibet’s is not merely a pretty face. I have long maintained that snacks are often the strongest part of a high-end meal. They are the chef’s handshake. The opening argument. If you can’t get the small bites right, I’m not hanging around for the turbot. On this front, Lilibet’s goes toe to toe with its Michelin-starred neighbours.

Lilibet’s is not merely a pretty face…

The tuna loin gilda was punchy and saline, pickles cutting neatly through the richness of the fish. The crab tart, brightened with grapefruit and coriander, managed that rare trick of feeling both delicate and assertive. And the anchovy éclair was outrageous in the best way, its silky parfait filling walking the tightrope between sweet and salty, all housed in choux that held its nerve. Three snacks in and I was already mentally composing my return order. 

From there we moved into the small plates and grill. Fried baby squid arrived crisp and light, properly seasoned and sharpened with lemon. Ricotta agnolotti with lemon and sage delivered comfort without heaviness, the citrus keeping things buoyant. These dishes don’t shy away from a bit of flair. There is generosity and a sense of occasion to them, but the execution is tight, and that’s what really matters.

The dish that lodged itself most firmly in my memory was the hand-dived scallops with seaweed butter. The scallops were sweet and expertly cooked, but the butter was the revelation. Rich, umami-drenched, salty in that deeply satisfying way that makes you pause mid-conversation. It coated each mouthful in glossy, marine intensity. This is the sort of thing that reminds you why seafood, when handled properly, can be as indulgent as any slab of aged beef.

These dishes don’t shy away from a bit of flair…

A sea bream fillet with grilled tomatoes, capers and basil reinforced the point that Lilibet’s understands fish. Clean flavours and confident seasoning with no unnecessary meddling. The focus remains on quality produce and careful cooking rather than pyrotechnics. The same might not be said for a number of its illustrious neighbours.

We drank a 2023 Chablis 1er Cru Vaillon from Roger Roblot, all crisp minerality and citrus snap, which cut neatly through the richness of the scallops and the butter-laced plates that preceded it. In a seafood restaurant in Mayfair, this is precisely what you want in your glass. It’s key to note that relative to its neighbours in this neck of the woods, Lilibet’s prides itself on accessible pricing across both the wine list and cocktail menu. When I spoke to Shonhan about this, he explained that the philosophy was simple. The team wants people to have a good time. They enable that by ensuring pricing isn’t too steep to allow a decent drinks pairing with dinner. In Mayfair terms, practically philanthropic.

Theatrical touches are aplenty, from towering candles flickering over the tables to monogrammed napkins and a comically oversized pepper grinder wielded with flourish. Yet it never tips into parody. The drama is anchored by serious cooking and genuine hospitality.

Theatrical touches are aplenty…

For anyone searching for the best seafood restaurant in Mayfair, or wondering whether Lilibet’s lives up to the hype of its lavish interiors, the answer is yes. It is maximalist, certainly. It is fun. It’s faintly ridiculous in places. But it is also thoughtful, personal and underpinned by genuinely excellent food.

I will be back, not just for the seaweed butter, though that alone would justify it, but for the sheer pleasure of spending an evening somewhere that dares to be both glamorous and good. Long live the Queen.

Find it: 17 Bruton Street, Mayfair, W1J 6QB
Click it: www.lilibetsrestaurant.com
‘Gram it: @lilibetsmayfair

Once you’ve ticked off Lilibet’s, following Phoebe’s review, we’ve more Mayfair dining ideas, check out our listicle here! Enjoy!

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!