Chef Michael Caines Only Blows The Bloody Doors Off The Stafford!

Ari already reviewed the restaurant at The Stafford, the late/great Game Bird. But now they’ve gone and changed it! So the poor guy had to go and eat and drink his way through many more courses and bottles. So here you go, a review of the brand new Michael Caines at The Stafford in London…

There’s never been a better time to indulge any manner of food related whimsy than in London right now. Need to hit somewhere to get the lip numbing hit from Sichuan peppercorns? No problem. How about picking your way round a whole pig’s head? Easy. Have a fetish for deep fried crickets? This city has got you. And there’s a time and a place for all things weird and, sometimes, wonderful, within our ever-evolving food scene. But. I’ll be honest. More often than not, what I’m really after isn’t novelty. It’s classic dishes, perfectly executed. And that happens to be a far rarer beast than you’d imagine. 

A few weeks’ ago, Michael Caines, the mega star(red) chef who has been running his restaurant at Lympstone Manor, Devon, for nigh on a decade, finally opened in London. Given it takes about two months to get from London to the South West by train, this is great news for anyone who doesn’t hail from Exeter. And he’s chosen to make his debut in the Capital at The Stafford Hotel.

The Stafford sits on a quiet cul de sac, a stone’s throw from Green Park and The Ritz. Unlike the Ritz, you may never have heard of The Stafford. I think they probably like it that way. It’s a discreet, quietly luxe, five-star hotel whose guests very much look like they inherited their furniture. It feels like somewhere spies might meet for a dead drop. There’s actually a little statue in the hotel’s American bar celebrating an agent for the French resistance, Nancy Wake, nicknamed ‘the white mouse’ who used to frequent the place and who the Nazis feared so much they put a 5m franc bounty on her head. 

It’s a discreet, quietly luxe, five-star hotel…

The dining room for Michael Caines hasn’t changed much since its previous iteration as The Game Bird. This is very much deliberate, with the team keen to retain a link with the restaurant’s past identity. They’ve even kept some of the old dishes, including the H Forman and Son smoked salmon trolley and the infamous beef wellington. It’s a smart move, ensuring the regulars, some of whom have been eating here for over 30 years, feel a sense of continuity and giving Game Bird the respect it fully deserves.  

But I wasn’t here to reminisce, I wanted to see what Caines was bringing to the party. So, I went for the full blown ‘signature’ tasting menu, which gets you seven courses plus snacks for £165. So far, no surprises, that’s about what you’d expect to pay, in the heart of Mayfair, for food and cheffery of this quality.

I went for the full blown ‘signature’ tasting menu…

But, if you wanted to check this place out without getting deep into three figures, you could hit up the lunch menu. The day I went, this included Brixham cod, sirloin of beef and raspberry soufflé as options on a three-course menu which will set you back £45. Setting a menu at this price point demonstrates a genuine determination by the kitchen to open the restaurant up beyond the wealthy hotel guests, few of whom would worry about whether their main cost £20 or £200. It will also ensure the dining room stays as full as it was on the day I visited, which gave the place a lovely lunchtime buzz.  

I’ve said this before, and I’ll stick to my guns. I don’t think an amuses bouche should be cheese forward. It’s too heavy and punchy a way to start a long meal. And I was all ready to use the first snack at Michael Caines, a cheddar gougère, as further evidence to support my theory, until I actually ate it. So, my revised theory is- no restaurant should lead off with a cheese-based snack unless you’re Michael Caines, in which case do whatever the f**k you please. The gougère was so light it almost disappeared when eaten, whilst at the same time flooding my mouth with flavour. It was also still warm, slightly melting the fronds of cheddar which had been draped over the top. Annoyingly perfect. 

A genuine determination by the kitchen to open the restaurant up beyond the wealthy hotel guests…

Enough about the posh cheese puff. Let’s get to the menu proper. It read like a roll call of luxurious stuff you really, really want to eat. Scallops, caviar, turbot, foie gras, pigeon, beef. And with these superlative ingredients, Caines did what only the most accomplished and confident chefs have the balls to do. He let them sing.

Each dish, from the frankly incredible scallop ceviche with a hauntingly fragrant lemon oil, to the foie gras and duck terrine which demonstrated just how pretty fifty shades of brown can look on a plate, were testaments to restraint. Caines has a subtle touch, giving the key components of each dish their spotlight.

Caines did what only the most accomplished and confident chefs have the balls to do…

For example, I’ve never eaten a better pigeon leg, but it hadn’t been deboned, stuffed with mousse or otherwise gussied up. It was simply seasoned and cooked perfectly. Ditto the beef; rare fillet, deep mushroom and red wine reduction, a little braised cheek on the side and a sharp and verdant watercress sauce to point it all up.

My only issue with the beef course(in fact it was my only issue with the entire meal, full stop) was the 2018 Ozzie Shiraz served with it- a total boozy bruiser of a red which came in at a ridiculous 17% abv and almost sent me off for a nap in the lounge. 

The theme of giving people what they want continued through the entire meal. Everyone knows the best way to serve turbot is with a buttery shellfish sauce and a dollop of caviar. So that’s what they did. This isn’t revolutionary cooking. It’s doing exactly the right thing with each course, to ensure the maximum enjoyment of the diner. This takes a chef willing to downplay his ego in favour of ensuring you, the punter, come first. It’s vanishingly rare these days, in our era of open kitchens and showy masterchefs. And I have to say, I absolutely loved it.

Doing exactly the right thing with each course, to ensure the maximum enjoyment of the diner…

This is what eating out should be all about. Add to the exemplary menu, one of the best front of house teams in London and a wine pairing that included a fantastic Alsatian pinot noir and a minerally, saline white from the Symington family in the Douro valley (more famous for port) and you’ve got quite the experience. I could go on and on about how fab it all was, but I think you’ve got the point; Caines has nailed London. 

Find it: 16-18 St James’s Place, St James’s, SW1A 1NJ
Click it: www.thestaffordlondon.com
‘Gram it: @thestaffordlondon

As ever, you’ll find more just like this (and some quite different) if you go to our reviews pages. They’re jolly good. Especially Ari’s!

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!