Until this week I’ve been rather proud (some might say smug) of adhering to to my golden rule of restaurant reviewing. ‘Ari’s Law of semi-professional eating out’ states… One may not visit the next restaurant unless all previous reviews have been filed. It’s a rule I’ve never broken, ensures I don’t end up with a backlog of places clamouring for their write-ups and that I don’t start mixing dishes and experiences up. Given I never take notes or photos and tend to drink all the wine, it’s a real risk. But, people, spare a thought for me. Because this week I’ve hit four restaurants in five days. That’s a ridiculous number, even for a hedonistic epicure like me. Every morning I wake at 5am, complete my piece, briefly head to my day-job, then onto the next meal. And my review yesterday was at the rather glam Sparrow Italia, in Mayfair.
When I say glam, I really mean it. When I asked to borrow a light, they lent me what looked like a golden pistol, from the end of which a Bunsen flame shot out when I pressed the trigger. It took every ounce of my moral fibre not to pocket this fabulous object at the end of a very cocktail-forward meal.
It being lunchtime, we were in the ground floor dining room at Sparrrow. It’s dominated by a no-nonsense, extremely well appointed bar. Around this are dotted tables with properly comfortable club chairs and emerald green leather banquettes. Thanks in part to a fairly heavy night before, my partner-in-crime and I decided to start with the absinthe-forward cocktail… The famous Corpse Reviver Number 2.
When I say glam, I really mean it…
It did the job, raising us sufficiently from the dead that we then decided to tackle another couple of sharpeners, in the form of a ‘molise’ from the genuinely original list of house cocktails, which hover between £20-25 a piece. The molise was a lowball, containing chilli, mango, watermelon, tequila and agave, over which they sprayed a mist of cognac and then set it on fire. Once the smoke settled, we discovered a tiny bottle of blue liquid attached to the watermelon ball garnish. This turned out to be a house-made tequila and curacao miniature sidecar. Very over the top. And just what was needed. My only suggestion is they substitute the normal cubes of ice for one huge one, as the drink got a little melty and diluted by the halfway point.
Still feeling a little fragile, I decided to start with bluefin tuna otoro. I’m a firm believer that raw fish, rather than fry ups, are the best hangover cure. Some beautifully fresh and fatty tuna arrived, sashimi grade, diced with a little avocado and lightly seasoned with sea salt and lemon. So far so good, but what really elevated it was the little silver jug of sauce that came with. This turned out to be a potent reduction of girolles and truffle (now bang in season). That gave the dish an umami bass note that was indecently moreish.
I’m a firm believer that raw fish, rather than fry ups, are the best hangover cure…
Given the time of year, it wasn’t surprising that the scent of white truffles wafted over from several of the other tables whilst we ate. Sparrow do an entire menu dedicated to this tuber! However my lunch pal had a serious case of truffophobia, so we decided there-and-then that we would ignore that side of things, giving me an excellent excuse to return (more of which, below).
We shared a main of fillet steak from Sardinia rubbed with rosemary, sea salt and nowt else and cooked rare, as it must be. I would have had it even rarer than it came, to be totally up front. But this was forgivable as it was excellent quality and perfectly rested. This came accompanied by a pan of sautéed mushrooms, covered in lashings of some unexpected black truffles (don’t worry, I ate them all, to save my pal’s blushes) and a glass of outstanding 2014 Nebbiolo which, thanks to its bottle age, had developed secondary flavours faintly reminiscent of high-grade balsamic vinegar. I appreciate some of you may not consider me describing a wine as vinegary to be a compliment. But I’m not talking about the sourness of bog standard Sarson’s. I’m talking about the syrupy, brooding, perfumed real deal.
It wasn’t surprising that the scent of white truffles wafted over from several of the other tables…
The wines we had were all chosen by a sommelier who clearly knew his onions. Whilst the Nebbiolo was the standout, we also tried a Sicilian red that managed to stay light whilst also giving off funky volcanic, minerally vibes. Classy, unusual and impressive, each glass we had also paired beautifully with its partner dish.
Sparrow Italia (By Night)
Le Mans is the most famous of a style of motor racing that tests endurance rather than simple flat-line speed. Competitors work in teams which include three drivers, racing for 24 hours around a circuit, day and night, the winner determined by total distance driven. It’s considered by many the ultimate test of driving talent and staying power. Why am I telling you this? Well, after a week of four lunches, and given the need to check out the white truffle menu at Sparrow, I performed the restaurant equivalent of Le Mans, returning with someone more truffle friendly for dinner. Ridiculous doesn’t even start to describe this plan. But here’s what happened next…
Sparrow by night is a very different fish to its daytime incarnation. The entrance is darker, more brooding, with elegant staff all dressed in black there to greet us and guide us upstairs to the top floor dining room. Even getting the lift is a rather dramatic experience, with ruby red interior lighting and lacquer walls that makes you feel like you’re in a slightly dystopian but very cool future. The decor upstairs is how I imagine the Concorde lounge at JFK looked in the ’80s. Plush as f*ck with some live trees thrown in for added opulence. We sat at the action table, near the bar. If you fancy a quieter time of it (we didn’t) I suggest sitting at the opposite end. Take a left turn out of the lift.
Given the whole point of this return visit was to truffle it up, I asked the staff to just roll with their choice of starter, main and pudding containing that magic mushroom. So began a slightly ludicrous and totally over the top experience that I would very much like to repeat. We began with pan con tartufo, little rounds of focaccia onto which ricotta, honey and truffle had been liberally spread. This dish is the answer to the question, ‘what’s the world’s poshest sandwich?’. And it went down a total treat with a glass of well-rounded, slightly oaky white Burgundy.
How I imagine the Concorde lounge at JFK looked in the ’80s..
All the wines were chosen for us by a female som whose languid style and innovative selections really worked for me. The world is a better place for female sommeliers. They’re generally more interested in what diners actually like, than their male counterparts, many of whom see selling wine as an opportunity to browbeat customers into submission, rather than listening to what they want.
For the mains we went for the sine qua non of truffle cuisine. Linguine with Parmesan. It doesn’t sound like much. But made well, cooked properly and with the right amount of truffle, it’s a near perfect plate. The dish arrived, the fresh egg pasta silken and glistening under its coating of cheese. Following immediately after came the head chef, a genuine bear of a man, carrying a tiny silver cloched dish. He raised the cloche and handed me an entire alba whitetruffle. It was the size of the biggest conker you’ve ever seen. Literally hundreds of pounds worth. And he started shaving it all over the linguine. The whole thing. The dish was both utterly comforting and luxurious. Like being cuddled by the Queen.
He raised the cloche and handed me an entire alba whitetruffle…
Now, you’ve probably guessed that I wasn’t paying for this meal. If I had been, I might have had a heart attack as the shavings piled up on the plate. But here’s the thing- this dish has a set price (around £80). There isn’t an additional supplement for the truffle. So they’re literally giving it away. A monumentally generous gesture from a kitchen which seems to get a real kick out of punters enjoying themselves.
I’ll be straight up with you… The truffle-stuffed beignets with dark chocolate (£24) which we had to finish felt, even for me, a little de-trop. Too heavy a way to end such a rich (in every sense) meal. Luckily I still had some of the heady, autumnal 2018 Brunello di Montalcino, which came with the linguine, to wash the chocolate down. It’s a wine that was literally made for this cuisine, although hailing from Tuscany rather than Italy’s mother ship truffle region, Piedmont.
There isn’t an additional supplement for the truffle. So they’re literally giving it away…
By now I reckon you’ve probably realised, the fact is, Sparrow is spendy. You’re not getting out for less than £300 for two at lunch. More at dinner! And even that will take a little sensible planning (avoid three courses of truffle if you’re watching your wallet). But this outlay gets you an afternoon or evening in a gorgeous place, the dedicated attention of a truly superb team of staff, superlative drinks and wonderful, decadent food. Dress up, save up, and treat yourself.
Find it: 1-3 Avery Row, Mayfair, W1K 4AJ
Click it: www.sparrowitalia.com
‘Gram it: @sparrowitalia
We will absolutely have to add this to our listicle of best London Italian restaurants! PR lady, feel free to chase me on this! In the meantime, read more of Ari’s fabulous reviews here! And let’s all lobby to get the queen to cuddle him, now we know that’s his thing…
