I didn’t want to like it. I appreciate that in the unwritten code for restaurant critics, we’re expected to maintain a scrupulous sense of fairness and impartiality. The oath we might swear, if it was writ, would be to treat each place we visit with a clean slate, unsullied by personal opinion or bias. But I’m a human, not AI and I have my preconceptions. And any restaurant group that decides to open in Riyadh before London, as Carbone did, is going to claw at my craw. So, I was all ready to put the boot in to this celebrity seasoned, all swagger opening.
I’m not even sure whether reviewing Carbone has any genuine public purpose. Unless you’re famous, or ‘fuck you’ rich you’re not getting a table this decade. But put that all aside. Because this place is awesome fun.
Tuesday night, half seven, and I find myself in a queue of ridiculously beautiful people. They’re all waiting to check in downstairs at Carbone. The guests are marginally less good looking than the staff, each of whom seems to have come straight from Hollywood casting for perfect hosts/esses. These people aren’t just easy on the eye. They’re absolutely awesome at their job. Managing and massaging the big egos from door to table isn’t easy. I feel like giving the whole shebang a bit of a David Attenborough voiceover as I watch them wield the beasts around the floor.
Unless you’re famous, or ‘fuck you’ rich you’re not getting a table this decade…
Before we even got a menu at Carbone they start with the Italian American hospitality that’s made this brand famous. The table is scattered with fennel scented salami, focaccia topped with tomato and chunks of Parmesan. It’s fun, generous and generally a bit OTT. That’s the vibe throughout what turned out to be one of the funliest (I know it’s not quite a word) evenings I’ve had in 2025.
They call their waiters captains. In any other place this would come off stupid. But when the people serving you look like they’ve literally walked straight off the Sopranos set, it all just kind of makes sense.
What turned out to be one of the funliest (I know it’s not quite a word) evenings I’ve had in 2025…
We knew in advance portions are US generous, so decided to share scallops, linguine vongole then veal Marsala, rather than try to tackle a course each. Please do the same, else you’ll have a table covered in unfinished food, like Victoria Beckham (who ‘ate’ here last week, I’m told).
The food is far better than it needs to be. People would come here if they served far more laissez faire fare. The vibe is super strong. Everyone coming in feels special, either from knowing how damn hard it is to get a table at all, or the fact you’re walked to your spot by a phalanx of supermodels, whose only role is to escort you betwixt check in and the restaurant, whilst whispering into their FBI grade headsets.
I was still fuggy from the previous day’s lunch, so opted for a quick martini fix. It was cold, huge and unnaturally strong. Job done. The scallops arrived as I was downing my first, and wishing for my second cocktail. Fat, lardo cloaked molluscs, in the shell, pimped up with more porcine joy in the form of diced pancetta. Ok it was £40 odd for three mouthfuls, but if you’re going to quibble the bill, this place ain’t for you.
Cold, huge and unnaturally strong. Job done…
Personally, I thought the linguine vongole that followed was too garlic laden, but my utterly hungover partner in crime disagreed and she knows her clams so I’ll give the place a pass on this one.
And then the veal arrived. I’m not exaggerating when I say it would easily have fed four. For just shy of £70 this is bargain territory. Thick slices of babycow, sticky (slightly over) reduced Marsala sauce and a family sized dish of superior roast potatoes. It was the epitome of the Italian American cookery that this place is all about. Think generosity rather than finesse, fun rather than fuss and you’re there.
For just shy of £70 this is bargain territory…
And I’m going back, whenever they’ll have me. Carbone will put a spring in your step, two inches on your waist and make you feel gangster. Just go.
Find it: 30 Grosvenor Square, Mayfair, W1K 6AN
Click it: www.carbonelondon.com
‘Gram it: @carbonerestaurants
If you loved Ari’s Carbone review then you’ll be glad to hear there’s more of them. Loads more. Just click here for all our reviews…
