So this summer I’ve mostly been eating stuff with fins. You might have noticed this trend, if you check this column out regularly (for which I thank you, loyal and almost certainly good-looking and highly intelligent readers). As the leaves start to fall, I can feel my tastebuds starting to hanker after the ferrous comfort of venison. Or the heft of a proper piece of beef and the fun of fiddling the flesh off various game birds. But I still had one piscine blowout left in me, before bidding farewell to the sun for another eight months. And there’s really only one place to choose for a final fish-forward menu. I had to review the aptly monikered Angler.
The restaurant sits on the seventh floor of the five-star South Place Hotel, located between Liverpool Street and Moorgate. And, conveniently, it’s a 15-minute walk from where I work. There’s more casual dining options on the ground floor but if it’s fancy stuff from the sea you’re after then you need to head up to Angler.
The C-shaped room is full of natural light with panoramic windows looking over the City. And there’s a wonderful (heated) terrace to boot. It’s a modern, contemporary and luxe look that perfectly fits the very well-heeled punters who filled almost every table on the Wednesday lunchtime I visited.
Angler has held a Michelin star for twelve years in a row, since winning one for the first time a year after it opened. And now there’s a new(ish) Head Chef, Craig Johnston, who took over from Gary Foulkes in late 2024, I thought it was high time to check the place out. Johnston won Professional Masterchef around a decade ago, when I was in my thirties and he looked about twelve. I remember watching the final and feeling seriously old as this kid, with a fluffy, not quite goatee beard, trounced the competition. He was 21 when he won it, which is frankly taking precocity a little far. And even more annoyingly, he still looks in his early twenties. And that’s despite grafting for many years behind the stoves at a phalanx of serious restaurants.
We opted to try the ‘Taste of Angler’, a shortened version of the full ‘signature’ menu. The former comes in at between £90-£124 depending on whether you add the lobster (you must, see below for why). The latter will set you back £155 for which you get seven courses plus the usual pre and post bells-and-whistles.
As a very welcome glass of Champagne was poured and out came the snacks. Namely, Tunworth cheese cornetto and duck liver mousse on cornbread. Tunworth is the British answer to Camembert, rich, creamy and decadent. Here it was piped into little crispy cones and topped with sticky candied walnuts. It was beautifully executed, presented and, equally importantly, fun to eat. My only issue was I’m not a fan of starting a long meal with cheese, I think it’s too heavy and cloying on the palate. But that’s very much a personal thing. The mousse was again, very rich. Crumbly, beautifully textured cornbread played well against the deep flavoured, smooth liver. The port reduction provides a sweet and nicely acidic counterpoint.
Angler has held a Michelin star for twelve years in a row…
Starters proper began with a tuna tartare. Now, this dish has become ubiquitous over the past few years and, because I love raw tuna, I tend to order it anywhere it’s available. This means I have the chops to declare Angler’s version to be top of the sea tree. What was clearly sushi grade tuna, every piece an identical sized cube (kudos to the sous for their dicing skills), was presented simply with a bright red smear of pepper puree and some sesame seeds for a little crunch. It had a nod to Japan but also to the Mediterranean with the red pepper flavour and was an outstanding plate.
We followed this dish with the second (optional) starter of lobster raviolo. A single, baby-fist sized pasta parcel arrived in a pink pool of Thai scented bisque. So with each bite I got the sweetness of the lobster combined with the warmth of Thai spicing and depth of a properly made bisque. Not a morsel remained, nor did I say a word whilst I ate this marvel. There aren’t many dishes I try that so transport me to pleasure in the moment, that I can genuinely recall how every element ate, days later. This was one of them. I would inhale this dish very happily, every day, until my time was up.
Not a morsel remained, nor did I say a word whilst I ate this marvel…
For the main we had Scottish cod, again cooked perfectly, so it separated itself into petals at the mere hint of a knife, with a chicken butter sauce. I found the sauce a little strident for the delicate cod. But I liked the chicken/fish combo as a concept. And I loved the little ballotine of chicken mousse that came alongside. This is a dish designed to navigate you away from the warmer months and into autumn. It worked a treat.
We finished up with a black fig pavlova with caramelised almonds. This had a warm undercurrent from a touch of cinnamon and a balance to the sweetness of the figs though a little mousse of brillat savarin cheese. Clever, balanced, subtle, like so many of the dishes we tried.
Cooked perfectly, so it separated itself into petals at the mere hint of a knife…
We stuck with white wine, given the food. The best of which was a superb Pomino Bianco from Frescobaldi, served with the cod. We also drank an eight-year-old Tokaji. It came with the pud and reminded me just how complex and rewarding this Hungarian sweet wine can be.
This was a sophisticated, well executed and innovative meal. It looks very much like Angler remains in good hands with the baby-faced prodigy Johnston at the helm of this ever-reliable ship.
Find it: South Place Hotel, 3 South Place, The City, EC2M 2AF
Click it: www.anglerrestaurant.com
‘Gram it: @angler_restaurant
We love Angler and, of course, we adore every review Ari pens (keyboards?). If you want to read more from Ari then click here. And for more reviews in general, here you go…
