I arrived to review The Farmhouse Inn, an ‘upscale’ boutique hotel in Sonoma County, at around 11am on a Friday morning. Which is far too early for the standard check-in time at this, or any other, hotel. Now we’ve all been in this situation, feeling slightly awkward as the receptionist informs us our room isn’t ready, then the brush off with a tepid offer to look after your bags whilst you wander around homeless for the next few hours. And that’s exactly what didn’t happen at Farmhouse.
The uber efficient front of house did explain my room wasn’t ready but then suggested I busy myself creating my own bar of soap from a selection of beautiful smelling ingredients they have at a little table inside the reception. Meanwhile she made me a reservation at a nearby vineyard. Her quick thinking turned my stupidly early arrival into an opportunity, to squeeze one, or more, glasses of vino from an already rather saturated trip.
15 minutes of Ubering through picture perfect countryside later, and I arrived at MacRostie vineyards. Greeting me, next to the super-smart, immaculate and design forward flagstone terrace, was a smiling hostess. She was wearing blue stonewashed jeans, and offered me a pale pink glass of rosé. This juxtaposition, between fancy, elegant and totally down to earth, pretty much sums MacRostie up.
It’s a place where the tasting room looks like it was designed by Frank Gehry and the terrace overlooking the vineyards looks like an idealised Hollywood image of the perfect wine vista. Yet the (hugely knowledgeable and passionate) person giving you the booze tutorial is called ‘Leaf’ (or something very similar, I kid you not), and has a buzz cut and multiple piercings. If you approach wine like it’s a puzzle to mull over, with furrowed brows knitted in concentration over whether your amphora aged Cortes de Cima came from an eastern or northern facing slope, then MacRostie probably isn’t for you. If, however, you just like drinking generous pours of consistent, mellow and varied wines, served with verve and enthusiasm… Then sign yourself right up.
So, back I went to Farmhouse, slightly oiled and very ready to check out my room. The hotel is low rise, with a number of little casas and cottages dotted around the pretty outdoor pool. The main house at the back. I was in a Barn Junior Suite, between the pool and the hotel’s two restaurants (about more of which, later).
First up, there was nothing junior about the room. It was, at 650 feet square, bigger than my old London flat. Unlike the disreputable flats I’ve rented, it came with its own mini steam room. That and a two person sunken bath, an outdoor terrace with an open fire looking onto a forest. And, of course, a wonderful minibar with full bottles of some of the best wines Sonoma has to offer. Barn Suites are at the upper end of what’s available at Farmhouse. They cost around $850 a night, with smaller cottage and farmhouse rooms available for around the $450-500 mark.
There was nothing junior about the room. It was, at 650 feet square, bigger than my old London flat…
The décor was very much New England/ The Hamptons with little nods to Sonoma’s wine heritage. There were acres of white linen, natural wood finishes and an airy, open feel thanks to floor-length-windows and double-height ceilings. It was also blissfully quiet. Probably down to the fact there aren’t really that many rooms, and they spread them out through the grounds.
One of the key reasons to visit The Farmhouse Inn is its eponymous Michelin Star restaurant, run by Head Chef Craig Wilmer. I booked in for an early supper, opting for the three course prix fixe $145 ‘Taste of Farmhouse’ menu rather than the more complex ‘Portrait of Farmhouse’ multi-course offering that costs around double. Now, clearly, having a star by the big fat tyre man, I know there’s no way three courses is going to be all the kitchen send out, and so it proved.
One of the key reasons to visit The Farmhouse Inn is its eponymous Michelin Star restaurant…
The ‘snack’ to start things off, was a decent-sized portion of snow-white local halibut. It came on a corn tostada, with a jalapeno emulsion, compressed green tomatoes and a lick of mezcal. This was fun, playful, with more than a nod to Baja California and wink in Mexico’s direction. They kill the halibut using the Japanese ‘ike jime’ method, acting to paralyse the fish and drain it of blood. This technique is said to enhance the umami qualities of fish, giving more depth and nuance to the flavour and while I’m not certain the fish appreciate it, all I know is it tasted bloody (excuse the pun) fantastic.
Next followed some more white fish. This time it was albacore tuna with tomato, dill and serpent cucumber. It’s a particularly sweet version of cucumber which grows in a curved shape, hence the name. The tuna suffered a little in coming straight after the halibut amuse, since it’s far less punchy in flavour. It’s also a little too similar a dish. Both were, in essence, cold pale fresh fish with tomatoes and other stuff. But you can’t judge them too harshly for creating an intro snack so perfect it blew the next course away…
All I know is it tasted bloody (excuse the pun) fantastic…
For my main I went for lamb chops with long beans and garum. Now I recall garum from my schooldays studying Latin (my favourite subject, make of that what you will). I was therefore almost certain it was a fish sauce fermented in clay jars. The Romans used it as their version of ketchup. I don’t know whether the same technique was used to create Farmhouse’s garum. But what I can say is that the sauce was deep, with that bass note you get from excellent anchovies, and it worked as a fantastic foil to the sweetness of the lamb chops, which I ate like lollipops, with my hands, because I was eating on my own so I could, and the chops deserved it.
The long beans had been plaited, which freaked me out. Not only because they looked like freaks of nature, but also because, when a chef does something pernickety like this, all I can think of is how many fingers have touched my food.
It worked as a fantastic foil to the sweetness of the lamb chops, which I ate like lollipops…
Despite being absolutely full by this stage, I somehow managed to devour the pudding, an apple and cinnamon mooncake that was crispy, sweet, spiced and ludicrously addictive. I would like this cake for tea on the day I die, and every day between now and then (sadly there won’t be many, if I mooncake to this extent).
The Farmhouse Inn is chic, cool, understated and, most importantly, seriously fun. If you’re heading to Sonoma, make sure it’s on your must do list. I was sad to leave (and will definitely return under my own steam). But my cab awaited to whisk me to my next destination, The Stavrand…
Find it: 7871 River Road, Forestville, California, 95436, USA
Click it: www.farmhouseinn.com
‘Gram it: @farmhouse_inn
If you enjoyed Ari’s review of Sonoma’s Farmhouse Inn then why not follow him to his next stop. Ari’s review of The Stavrand hotel is here…

