Serious Cooking & The Most Welcoming Staff, Why Charlie’s At Brown’s Hotel Was A Joy 

By and large, there are two types of hotels I seem to end up in these days. The most ubiquitous breed is what I’m going to call the ‘common corporate’. Part of large, multinational chains, they sit in the dreary hinterland between 3 and 4 stars, with rooms designed by Clive from accounts and food so blandly international that nobody could ever take offence (or pleasure). Your club sandwich, ‘home-made’ burger, chicken-tikka-masala or salmon with pesto will taste pretty much the same, whichever one of these greige temples of meh you end up in. And you’ll eat the paint-by-numbers, bland, pap in a restaurant doing everything it can not to be noticed. Then there’s the other kind of hotel. One offs. Eccentric, flamboyantly decorated places with history, staffed by actual humans with personalities. Lucky for me, this week’s restaurant review, Charlie’s at Brown’s Hotel, definitely falls into the latter camp.

For a start, someone with a sense of humour named this place. If you’ve got a hotel called Brown’s then of course you need to call the restaurant Charlie’s. For anyone under 40, Charlie Brown is a lead character in the Peanuts comic book and television series. For anyone under 30, books are paper copies of stories which, in the olden days, people would sit and read. Generally melancholic and played by an actor with a downbeat voice, the TV version of Charlie Brown would spend his days chatting slightly forlornly with his dog Snoopy about little to nothing. It was an understated masterpiece and I like to believe Sir Charles Forte (the founder of Brown’s owners, Rocco Forte Hotels) or whoever named the place ‘Charlie’s’, was giving the comic antihero a sly doff of the cap, whilst also, very sensibly, naming the place after the boss. 

Charlie's at Brown's Hotel restaurant review: Exterior

Now let’s be clear, Brown’s isn’t some arriviste revolutionary gaffe, pushing the gastronomic envelope, in the El Bulli style. This is, after all, the place from which Alexander Graham Bell made the country’s first telephone call in 1876. It’s also where Kipling apparently wrote The Jungle Book. Brown’s has sat on its spot on Albermarle Street (you actually can’t say Albermarle without sounding like a member of the royal family- try it) for almost 200 years and claims to be London’s oldest hotel, having never relocated nor been renamed. So, it’s been around a long time, and you could forgive it for resting on its ancient laurels. But the attitude and approach of the staff was totally refreshing. The whole place manages to give a respectful nod to the past, while planting both feet confidently in the present. 

You actually can’t say Albermarle without sounding like a member of the Royal Family…

Charlie’s has its own entrance at the side of the hotel’s main door. The walls are hand painted with riotous, creeping vines and tropical foliage, in homage to Rudyard, which is so much more fun as a theme than business grey. The staff are also the opposite of corporate cutouts. Partly because they are almost all Italian, so presumably can’t do dull. But mostly because they’re all passionate experts in the world of their clearly beloved hotel. I’ve rarely enjoyed such professional service, delivered with a relaxed charm that put me at immediate ease. And I’m not an easygoing diner.

We walked into the restaurant, got an immediate, properly warm greeting from the desk staff, were led straight to a window facing floral upholstered booth and offered a cocktail. I’ve never had a bad meal in a place where they ask you if you want a drink before you’ve sat down. It’s the height of hospitality, settled us right in and was a sign of the greatness to come.

We walked into the restaurant, got an immediate, properly warm greeting…

I went for a Negroni, and Browns’ version was a showstopper. Well balanced, with a citrusy tingle from a very ripe orange slice. And served in a heavy crystal glass, frozen to sub-zero and kept judderingly cold with a massive lump of ice. The pal, a total cockaholic (this is my new word for a mixed drinks enthusiast but, now I’ve seen it written down, I’m less sure it’s likely to catch on) waxed lyrical about her Manhattan. With the aperitifs came a plate of big, bright pink, peppery radishes with some cod’s roe. The kitchen dispatches them gratis to every table. Nice touch. 

I started with the special. A scallop crudo in a gazpacho sauce which was the passionate recommendation of at least three of the staff. Hand dived, baby fist sized raw Dorset molluscs arrived swimming in a delicate, cool tomato soup. If you wanted a dish to represent a summer’s day, this was it. My only gripe was the lack of a spoon with which to scoop up the sauce. Making a lip-smacking sauce and then not giving the diner something to eat it with is how I picture the final circle of Hell. I’m sure there may be other, worse tortures but for me, this represented genuine agony. Not willing to give up, I fashioned a tool from a crust of the sourdough and used it to shovel the soup down.

Charlie's at Brown's Hotel restaurant review: Bar
Charlie's at Brown's Hotel restaurant review: Trolley

Just as I finished the scallops, a waitress wheeled over a massive, silver, domed chariot which showcased the main of the day, a beautiful looking joint of veal. Any grand hotel restaurant which doesn’t have at least one trolley making its way around the tables, conveying drama (and aromas) throughout the dining room, isn’t worth the candle.

If you wanted a dish to represent a summer’s day, this was it…

I can’t do large lumps of meat at lunch anymore. So we forwent the veal in favour of a big Dover sole to share, served with Grenobloise sauce. To save you having to enter that mouthful into Google, ‘Grenobloise’ is a lemon/butter/caper sauce with some extra crunch thanks to the addition of crispy croutons. The sole arrived whole and was then filleted table-side by the most distinguished looking waiter I’ve ever met. I’ve never seen fish filleted with such speed, precision and lack of fuss. It made me feel sorry for every fish I’ve butchered in the past.

With the fish came an array of beautiful, seasonal vegetables including a sharp/sweet tomato and shallot salad. Also some roasted, fudgy little yellow courgettes with none of the watery blandness usually associated with their larger green cousins. And a simple bowl of just steamed spinach. This isn’t showy cookery, designed for Instagram and conceived to feed a chef’s ego. It’s proper, serious technique applied to impeccable ingredients, served by people who really know what they’re doing. And with cheffing from Michelin-starred Adam Byatt behind the scenes here, that’s probably unsurprising.

We finished off with a strawberry tartlet. The crisp, buttery pastry case filled with lemon verbena cream and a strawberry ice cream tasted exactly like the best memory you have of the ripest strawberry you’ve ever eaten. With coffees, instead of petit fours which can be a little fussy and old fashioned (what adult eats jellied sweets?), came a slotted wooden block into which had been placed a series of ultra thin squares of the finest tempered chocolate, from white to dark. The effort and skill needed to make what’s essentially a kitchen freebie is immense. It’s also a good measure of how generous and talented the team here are. 

It’s proper, serious technique applied to impeccable ingredients, served by people who really know what they’re doing…

Now, you’ll have spotted that we stuck entirely to fish and seafood, which made the wine choice easy. While I won’t claim that you’ll find any bargains on Charlie’s wine list, the white chosen for us by the sommelier was superb. A 2019 Bourgogne Blanc which tasted more like a Meursault. It had heft, a little fatness on the palate and balanced out with crisp acidity. The Burgundy cost a little north of £100, which is steep, but it was an exceptional example of its type. And much cheaper than a Meursault would have been, so there you go.

When you next really need looking after, perhaps you’ve had a dreary day at work, or one of your kids is caught deliberately weeing into the loo brush holder at school (this example may be based on personal experience), or life in general is just getting too much, take yourself to Charlie’s, put yourself in their hands, sit back, relax and let them take care of everything. It’s a shedload cheaper than therapy, and much, much more fun.

Find it: 33 Albemarle Street, Mayfair, W1S 4BP
Click it: www.roccofortehotels.com
‘Gram it: @browns_hotel

Hopefully you’re now about to book a restaurant table based on Ari’s review of Charlie’s at Brown’s Hotel! If you want more recommendations then here are more of his brilliant reviews. And if you want to find out more about Brown’s Hotel, here’s a review of that instead, for good measure…

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!