I love this gig. I can dream of no better wheeze than being sent out to eat and drink in great places all over London and getting to tell you all about it. My current title at The Sauce, ‘Lunch Correspondent’ is the greatest job title I have ever held. I still pinch myself at how lucky I am to have landed it. But, there’s one niggle that’s been irritating me since this all started and I’ve decided to lance the boil this week by reviewing Bentley’s Oyster Bar & Grill on the aptly named Swallow Street, in the West End.
Inevitably, the way this restaurant reviewing shtick goes is that I’m asked to visit the newest place on the block, the hottest opening, the restaurant that claims it will shake up the industry with its novel approach to… well anything. And I totally adore going to these places, getting ahead of the zeitgeist and letting you all know what’s what.
What rarely happens, however, is the opportunity to visit a place that has been going strong for years. Places dishing out delicious food without fault, putting in shift after shift, never dropping the ball. And that’s why, this week’s review is all about a glorious old-timer. Bentley’s has been serving up fresh seafood and in season-game, just off Piccadilly, for over 100 years. Now I can’t vouch for it for that whole period. But I’ve been a regular, on and off, for ten years. Which is about the same time as Richard Corrigan’s owned it. And I’ll let you all in on the secret: nowhere in London does seafood better than Bentley’s. At least it was a secret until my editor made it the headline, rather bursting the bubble…
This week’s review is all about a glorious old-timer…
We arrived on a sunny weekday lunchtime, and headed straight for the covered, beautifully dressed terrace, full to the rafters (er, canopy) with lunchers who were clearly in for the long haul. Nobody I saw at any table spent fewer than three hours here. I whiled away the entire afternoon of course, but I’m pro-level at lunching. There were magnums of Burgundy and Champagne as well as beautiful cigars being passed round by staff between the tables like it was the 1920s. I don’t know anywhere as hedonistically fun as this, and it was 1pm on a Wednesday…
I kicked off with their spin on a Negroni, called a, ‘Chinato’, after the Barolo-based aromatized wine which replaces the standard red Vermouth. Spiced with the scent of cardamom and other mystery flavours of the Orient; it tasted rounded, strong and fabulous. It was like being slapped in the face, then kissed hard by a really pretty girl. Or boy. Or both. Your choice.
It was like being slapped in the face, then kissed hard by a really pretty girl…
The pal tried a Ketel One based Citrus Drop. It looked very finely made, but light lemony drinks ain’t my thing, so there’s really no more to say about that.
We chose tempura octopus from the specials board to start, together with a recommendation from our waiter, a white jacketed Jeeves-like genius, of the house smoked salmon. I have never, ever ordered smoked salmon in a restaurant except at breakfast. I consider it something I could sort at home so why choose it when out?
Well, thank f**k I ignored myself. They smoke the salmon, it turns out, on the roof of Bentley’s. It came served in not-too-thin slices, with grated horseradish and tiny, fluffy, warm blinis. My only gripe was they gave us three blinis between two of us; a recipe for a fist fight.
The horseradish gave the dish a Japanese feel. As did the absolute perfection of the fish, which, miraculously, tasted fresher than non-smoked salmon. This dish was more akin to eating sashimi in one of those thunderously expensive omakase joints in Mayfair than what you would expect from a, ‘grill’, without the £500 bill.
I ordered the octopus because it read like a dish that wouldn’t work. And those, quite frankly, are fun to write about. Octopus tends to get rubbery if cooked on a high heat, and you can’t tempura anything without hot oil so I was expecting a slightly chewy, disappointing mouthful. Wrong again. Somehow they managed to create perfectly crunchy tempura batter, encasing super tender pieces of mollusc, which we dunked into the subtle with a slight punch, Thai-style chilli and soy dipping sauce that came with.
For mains, super-Jeeves told us we had to try the turbot. Again the man was bang on. A huge, thick slab of fish arrived at table, bone-in to show, then taken off to partly debone so we could simply enjoy the beast rather than having to work for it.
And a beast it was- at least 1.5kg of perfectly cooked turbot, doused in a brown shrimp butter, served with ludicrously buttery mashed potato, with a shot glass of Kerrygold on the side (I may have made that last one up). God it was good. The best fish I’ve eaten anywhere in years. All served in a totally unpretentious, seriously fun, wonderful restaurant, by staff who have being doing all the right things for years.
So we come to the nub of all this. There’s nothing wrong with having our heads turned by the new kid on the block… But don’t forget those long-standing, outstanding restaurants which have been getting everything right, day in day out, for decades. And of these magnificent old-timers, Bentley’s is my number one.
Find it: 11-15 Swallow Street, Mayfair, W1B 4DG
Click it: www.bentleys.org
‘Gram it: @bentleysoysterbar
Assuming you enjoyed this Bentley’s Oyster Bar & Grill review (or even if you didn’t), fear not. We’ve got plenty more where it came from. Here are all our other reviews…
