Fine Dining Done Properly: Why Corrigan’s Mayfair Nails It…

It all started with the bread. You see, I consider myself pretty much, ‘pro level’ when it comes to eating out. I’ve put in the requisite 10,000 hours of munching my way through menus. I’ve dedicated much of my free time to hunting down the best spots in town. I often bore those closest to me with breathless tales of, finally, having found, for example, the perfect oyster/xiaolongbao/beef tartare (those were last month’s discoveries). All this experience has, over the years, led me to develop some useful tricks of the trade. One of which is, ‘never, ever eat the bread’. This isn’t because I’m gluten free, or dislike dough, it comes from pure, simple, greed. I’ve come to realise that I simply cannot eat enough of a menu if I start by stuffing my face with sourdough, pane carasau (Sardinian flatbread, much more filling than it looks), grissini or focaccia. Bread, in short, is a total appetite killer. Eating it leads to enjoying fewer courses… Which in turn means there would be less to write about in my Corrigan’s Mayfair review. So really, I’m doing all this for you…

I arrived at Dickie’s Bar, connected to Corrigan’s, but with its own, orange canopied entrance, on a dank Friday afternoon. When you book a table at the restaurant, you receive a charming invitation to kick things off with a cocktail or two at the bar. Needing no excuse after a frankly horrendous week of mostly failing to get things done at work, I turned up at half five to get wrapped around a Negroni. And I was very glad I did.

Corrigan's Mayfair Review - Orangey Awning Thing

Don’t go to Corrigan’s and miss Dickie’s. The bar is an inviting, leather clad, amber hued space. It’s full of fun art. My favourite being the pewter-coloured elongated antlers which sit between the vast range of single malts. And it looks like the bar a Scottish hunting lodge wished it created. But without the unnecessary swathes of tartan and Presbyterian gloom.

Like the bar a Scottish hunting lodge wished it created, without the unnecessary swathes of tartan and Presbyterian gloom…

I’ll be honest, I’m pretty sure I got there before they were really open. But the staff were way too professional and charming to let on. So I settled in, alone, at the bar for a quiet tipple (this experience being the total opposite of life at home at the moment, with the kids already off for summer, wandering around the place loudly eating crisps and overdosing on Fortnite). 

The bread arrived moments after we switched scenes, from Dickie’s to the restaurant proper. It is an equally beautifully lit space, giving off luxe-cool vibes. Helped by some more art which really doesn’t tend to the usual corporate blandness you usually find. There’s an entire wall of cartoons seemingly dedicated to why Boris Johnson is a bit of a d*ck, for example, which I could happily have spent much more time enjoying.

There’s an entire wall of cartoons seemingly dedicated to why Boris Johnson is a bit of a d*ck…

I watched the basket of carbs arrive. I observed, with professional disinterest, the pillowy white rolls sitting perkily next to a couple slices of what looked like soda bread. Not going to tempt me, I thought smugly, as I considered what additional starter I could fit in thanks to this forbearance of the ballast course.

And then it hit me. This yeasty, treacly aroma cloud of joy wafted over from the basket. The soda bread was talking to me. Like a floury siren, drawing me in, destroying my willpower, ruining my best laid plans. Before I knew it, I was wiping crumbs guiltily off my face, having hoovered up the lot. Along with a fat slap of the equally ludicrous butter, which I later discovered had been pimped with a load of Lincolnshire Poacher. The fabulous, caramelly, cheddar-like cheese which was a totally wondrous, entirely unnecessary, addition to what was already a heavy bite.

Corrigan's Mayfair Review - The Bar At Dickie's

Now I haven’t used up half this column writing about the bread just to demonstrate how weak-willed I am. The temptatiousness of this most basic element of the meal demonstrates the degree of attention to detail and level of dedication Corrigan’s bring to the table.

The temptatiousness of this most basic element of the meal demonstrates the degree of attention to detail and level of dedication…

Similar perfection was to be found in the Negroni. It came served with a perfectly clear, embossed ice block the size of a Rubik’s cube, so the booze didn’t get watered down by meltwater. This is really important. It’s not likely something which will garner you awards and praise, but it’s the small stuff like this that can really make a meal.

We ordered a combo of dishes from both the set and full menus. The former will set you back around £50 for three courses, the latter around double.

From the cheaper option we kicked off with mackerel and gooseberries. The fruit provides a nicely sharp counterpoint to the inherent oiliness of the fish. Now, for me, mackerel usually starts to taste just a little too much of itself about an hour after it’s been landed. Not this little beastie. Which they had cured by some magical means which, whilst retaining every ounce of flavour, removed the rather strident fishiness which generally makes itself felt. The only places I’ve been which had such a way with mackerel before Corrigan’s were very high end Japanese joints. And you aren’t getting out of those for anywhere near £50 a head.

I really dig glands and will nearly always choose them if I find them on a menu…

Our other starter was Limousin veal sweetbreads. I really dig glands and will nearly always choose them if I find them on a menu. Typically they come all gussied up coated with something crunchy and glazed in an astringent sauce, in an effort to counter their soft richness. At Corrigan’s, no such counterpoint is provided. The sweetbread is the absolute star of the show, allowed to shine without a rival flavour or texture to distract.

The only accompaniments are a ludicrously buttery mash, which they gleefully informed me has a 60-40 butter to potato ratio, and a delicate rather than dominating veal jus. This is confident cooking. No baubles, no gimmicks, just something you absolutely want to eat, plated with simplicity and enjoyment in mind, rather than the ego of the chef. 

Corrigan's Mayfair Review - Dining
Corrigan's Mayfair Review - Baa Lamb

Next, perfectly pink best end of lamb, with a breadcrumbed puck of shredded shoulder meat which was the highlight of the plate; a crispy nugget of joy, tasting more like grown up hogget than actual baby sheep. It came with a small silver pot of what looked like typical pub Jenga chips.

These were to chips what beef tartare is to a McDonalds cheeseburger…

I ignored the ‘chips’ until a chip shop smell of vinegar turned my head. Turns out these were to chips what beef tartare is to a McDonalds cheeseburger. Layers of potato had been sliced, packed into a cake, frozen (to remove moisture) then fried many, many times, sliced and topped with a vinegar powder. In essence a crispy, frangible, mille-feuille of spuds. This was serious, technical cooking served with a playful wink, which rather sums Corrigan’s up.

To finish, I know I had a super thin version of a tarte tatin, the apple rendered to a toffee-like consistency, the pastry crisp. But, I have to be honest, I was too full to appreciate it. Because I ate all the bread.

The reason Corrigan’s is so unique is they’ve managed to carve out the best parts of fine-dining, like the absolute attention to detail. Except without the stuffiness of a typical high-end restaurant, especially one in deepest Mayfair. Now, some people like to go to places to worship at an (always hushed) temple of gastronomy. They sit in reverence as a waiter spends half an hour explaining the provenance of a prawn. I really don’t. I like to go out, eat great food, drink interesting wine and, most importantly have fun. Corrigan’s nails it.

Find it: 28 Upper Grosvenor Street, Mayfair, W1K 7EH
Click it: www.corrigansmayfair.co.uk
‘Gram it: @corrigans_mayfair

Want to read more from Ari? And we’re sure you do. So click here for more of his brilliant reviews…

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!