The Mayfair Chippy sounds, at first, like a joke. Why on earth would you stick a chip shop in the part of the Capital known best for Michelin stars, multimillion pound property and razor thin supermodels? It’s like putting a foie gras bar in PETA’s head office, or a steakhouse in Mumbai. What the f**k were they thinking? I mused, as I headed down to review the Mayfair Chippy at lunchtime on a Spring weekday, chuckling to myself, at what I anticipated to be a restaurant which the Mayfairatti would have comprehensively shunned. Fully 75 metres from the door I found myself at the back of a queue… Dozens of people, waiting patiently in the sun, for a fish supper. On a Tuesday at 2pm. Show’s what I know. Turns out posh people love a bit of rough…
Getting back to the food; I have to admit that, in general, I do like Hi/Lo culinary combinations. Be it opulent food served in rustic surroundings, ridiculously good wine accompanied by a simple charcuterie board. Or, as is the case with The Mayfair Chippy, seemingly plebian food in the most luxe location London canoffer. This recently opened fish restaurant (trust me, it’s so much more than a chip shop), sits opposite the most extravagant florist in town, McQueen’s, right in Mayfair proper. You could sit at one of the outside tables, frisbee your cod down South Audley Street and pretty much hit Grosvenor Square. Although, of course, I don’t suggest you do so.
First impressions mostly consisted of my middle-aged concern at both the queue and the fact that the diners lucky enough to have a table were spending more time photographing their food than actually eating it. In the most extreme example I witnessed a couple, neither of whom seemed to have even a passing acquaintance with body fat, who had each ordered an enormous shepherd’s pie which sat steaming in the sunshine whilst they updated Instagram. Presumably with the news, ‘about to not eat a pie’. I’ll be honest, I got the feeling this place might not be for me. I’m a man of words not pictures, preferring to taste rather than, ‘experience’ my food. And I’m too old to line up for lunch.
An enormous shepherd’s pie which sat steaming in the sunshine whilst they updated Instagram…
It turns out I needn’t have been concerned about the queue. If you’ve booked you can sweep past like a celeb, so I did. I was rapidly settled at a cute, tiled table for two, reminiscent of one of East London’s old Pie and Mash shops. Albeit one that had been gussied up to the nines and given an appropriate nip and tuck.
I deliberately arrived 20 minutes early, ostensibly to give me time to check the place out before my companion arrived. Happily, this extra 20 minutes also afforded me the opportunity to put away three oysters, au naturel. The oysters, not me. And chosen from the single-page, almost entirely piscine menu (the only exception being the shepherd’s pie).
What arrived were good-sized (by which I mean not too big) Colchester rocks, shucked with real skill, brimming with their liquor and spankingly firm and fresh. I eat a lot of oysters and these were up near the top of the bivalve leaderboard. The one I keep constantly updated in my head, because I’m slightly off-normal.
I eat a lot of oysters and these were up near the top of the bivalve leaderboard…
By the time I’d finished oyster number three, my plus one turned up and we immediately ordered more oysters. Together with a crab salad and some salt and pepper squid. This trio worked together like a dream… The clean saline hit of the oysters, followed by some punchy, chilli and lime spiked crispy squid, with a cooling and civilised crab and apple salad to calm it all down at the end. Grown up food, very well executed, although nothing like what I’ve previously eaten at a chippy.
Mains weren’t quite as impeccable as the first courses, although not far off. First the downside; grilled fish of the day, which was bream, had spent too long on the heat. Which rendered what should have been translucent petals of white flesh into a texture a little like like cotton wool. Bream is delicate and needs to be handled with care. And as a general rule, undercooking it slightly is preferable to overdoing it. Given how good everything else was though, I’m guessing this was an aberration rather than a sign of anything more serious wrong in the kitchen.
This was the best fish and chips I’ve ever tried…
Our other main, recommended to us with some vigour by the friendly front-of-house, was the signature, ‘Mayfair Classic’. Which consists of cod, in a little basket, with chips, mushy peas and gravy sauce. This was the best fish and chips I’ve ever tried. A totally different animal to the soggy, heavily battered rubbish I’ve often been faced with at seaside cafés. Now in some ways, given that it will set you back just north of £20, so it bloody well should have been. However, as we all know, high prices don’t always equal high quality. And (here’s the controversial bit) I would go so far as to claim this dish is worth every penny.
Before you email to berate me for being out of touch with reality, let me explain. Cod is expensive and this was a serious slab, cooked, unlike the bream, absolutely flawlessly. Everything which accompanied it was home-made, including the curry sauce, which my (northern) co-luncher declared was, ‘good’ and I thought was, absolutely epic’, so was likely somewhere in between (a classic example of northern understatement vs southern hyperbole perhaps). Sweet, sour, rich, fruity (I’m channeling Greg Wallace here I know but stay with me, I’ll stop in a minute), it coated the chips like God’s own lacquer. I usually get bored four bites into fish and chips but on this occasion found myself mopping up shards of the fish batter with the curry sauce in a very un-Mayfair like fashion.
Cod is expensive and this was a serious slab…
We drank a bottle of excellent Sardinian Vermintino, which tasted slightly herbaceous and had plenty of the acidity required to go toe to toe with the batter and left, past the permanent queue, happily into the sunshine, sated and, I have to admit, surprisingly impressed by this clever little venture.
Find it: 14 North Audley Street, Mayfair, W1K 6WE
Click it: www.mayfairchippy.com
‘Gram it: @mayfairchippy
Liked Ari’s Mayfair Chippy review? Read more of our reviews here…
