Now I’m not expecting a hatful of condolence letters, but I want you to know that sometimes, eating lunch for a living feels like hard work. I do appreciate it’s not, ‘hard work’ in the traditional sense. But, on occasion, I find myself ploughing through a duff menu, feeling like life is a bit of a grind, and having no idea how on earth I’ll find something to write about that won’t send you all to sleep. Not so at Notto, a newish pasta bar down the quiet end of Piccadilly which provided me with one of this year’s best meals.
Notto is the brainchild of some serious culinary heavyweights. In the red corner, multi-Michelinned Phil Howard, previously of The Square and currently running the much more laid back Elystan Street in Chelsea. He’s a poster boy for London foodies and all round big kahuna burger. In the blue corner, we have exec chef Louis Korovilas who used to work at Locanda and Bancone, so, you might say, knows his way around Italian food.
The concept is clever; a 70 cover, Scandi-chic-looking, relaxed spot where they are deadly serious about pasta. Even better, when I arrived at the bright, corner spot, just opposite the 200-year old gentlemen’s outfitters Cordings (where you can load up on shooting stockings and tweed covered hip flasks), I realised this used to be a knackered old Costa Coffee. A genuine phoenix rising from the ashes of yet another chain caffeine joint. And I hope the start of a trend which will see every town in the UK swap at least one of their coffee shops with a newly minted Notto.
This used to be a knackered old Costa Coffee…
Just before we get to lunch, I want to give you a brief ride round the loop-the-loop of my brain. You need to know and I need to tell…
I almost always experience high levels of anxiety when I first enter a restaurant. Far more anxiety than I experience in genuinely stressful-slash-serious situations. As I walk into a place I start to worry. Will I be banished to a table by the loo? Will they take my dry martini order immediately upon my bum hitting the chair (a good thing)? Or decide they would rather spend the time, ‘explaining the chef’s concept’ (a very bad thing)? I have occasionally called ahead to pre-order the martini, but rare is the restaurant that understands this is not a sign of madness. I also fret over the potential for the wine list, will it provide interesting, good value options, or gouge me till I can take no more?
So I arrived at Notto with all these usual mind tremors humming in the background. But they were dissipated approximately 60 seconds after I opened the door. Boom, I was led straight through the loud, packed restaurant to an oasis of calm towards the back. Bang, I was offered a drink before the menu was handed to me. I went for a grapefruit Negroni, which arrived, Bazinga, fewer than five minutes after I placed the order. It was boozy yet balanced, with a bitter edge, exactly how it should be (and nothing like the one I had at Murano the week before, which tasted like those horrible boiled sweets old ladies carry in their handbags).
I went for a grapefruit Negroni, which arrived, Bazinga, fewer than five minutes after I placed the order…
This series of competences, together with the hit of hard liquor, acted as a balm to my brain. And it provided the perfect start to what turned out to be a proper, three hour, two (three?) bottle lunch.
I ordered some grissini from the small snacks section to accompany the cocktail. Now I wouldn’t usually waste my word count on a breadstick… However what arrived was more than worthy of mention… Three absurdly long sticks, pointing several feet out of a vessel, into which some rough salt had been poured to keep them steady. Round the top was woven some parchment thin, slightly melted lardo over which had been scattered a snowstorm of grated parmesan which stuck perfectly to the yielding hog fat.
I wouldn’t usually waste my word count on a breadstick… However what arrived was more than worthy of mention…
I’ve had some fun nibbles in my time, but these sticks of joy set the bar at a new level. They looked great, standing taller than a toddler, smelt amazing, wafting their piggy/parmesan savouriness at me, and made me laugh. It’s the rare combination of a food which was both ridiculous and also extremely, seriously, excellent.
The affable, relaxed GM, Nick, told me this dish had developed from one of the owners playing around with some food during a staff meeting (apparently the trick is to blowtorch the lardo for a few seconds). Imagine having a job where you get to play around with lardo and blowtorches. Heaven.
I realise you are half way down this page and I’ve only managed to reach bar snacks. Sorry, but they were legendary. What followed, with one minor duff note, matched that opening salvo. From the starters we had some excellent focaccia. It was suggested by the staff, who insisted, correctly, it needed to be tried. Together with parchment thin slices of vitello tonnato, served with some fat caperberries and a light, delicate tuna cream. It reminded me of Howard’s starry dishes at Elystan St.
Now, the one dish I wasn’t smitten by was the arancini with wild mushrooms. This came as a large, single arancino and was claggy and altogether too much of a mouthful. But I didn’t care one jot because, as I was pushing it around my plate, on the cusp of a sulk, the pasta arrived.
Pasta is the thing here, it’s their mission and the staple foundation on which the restaurant is built. Almost literally. They’ve their own pasta making extruder in the basement and have around half a dozen seasonally changing menu options. All of which I wanted to eat.
I had brought my almost Italian pal along to check they had got the fundamentals right. She’s Puglian by marriage and a true pasta expertito. Which I believe is Italian for, ‘knows her onions’). We ummed and aaaghed over the menu and eventually narrowed it down to a chosen four… Rigatoni caccio e pepe; spaghettini with crab; ravioli osso bucco and strozzapreti (a twisted pasta, the name of which translates to, ‘priest strangler’) with rabbit. Getting the niggle out the way first… I found the ravioli too rich and sweet for my taste, as did the Italian companion.
The other plates though. F**k me, they were fantastic. Caccio e pepe leaves nowhere to hide for the chef, relying as it does on just pepper and cheese, together with the pasta cooking water, for all its flavour. It was starchy, comforting, the pasta perfectly al dente. And the combination, when done so well, becomes much more than the sum of its parts. Both the rabbit and the crab dishes were similarly faultless. Though, I have to say, the habit of the kitchen to send all the pastas out together made for some weird flavour combinations. When you go, order the caccio e pepe and crab first then have the meatier options to follow.
The other plates though. F**k me, they were fantastic…
In addition to the fantastic food, Notto is properly fun. This is partly because everybody who works there is on top of their game. They can run the service while still having time to stop for a chat, make genuine recommendations and have a laugh. They know they have a hit on their hands, and this has bred the right kind of confidence, unlike in some hyped establishments where the swagger becomes insufferable.
In short, I was already 100% in on this place before discovering they have an Italian soft serve ice cream machine with which they make the best affogato in town.
Go. There. Now.
Find it: 198 Piccadilly, St James’, W1J 9EZ
Click it: www.nottopastabar.com
‘Gram it: @nottopastabar
If you enjoyed Ari’s Notto Pasta Bar review then check out more reviews here…
