At some point we’ve all worked in toxic work environments. I’ve certainly weathered my fair share of mad megalomanic bosses who rule by combinations of fear and ineptitude. My worst was someone a colleague once joked was ‘a cross between David Brent and Kim Jong Un’… She was unbearable. And it’s a universal experience. But thank your lucky stars you don’t work at The Westbury. The hotel’s ex-chef, Alyn Williams, has just received the backing of a tribunal after a court found he was wrongfully sacked from what sounds to us like a truly unpleasant place to work.
The Westbury Hotel has always felt to me a little down-at-heel by comparison to its local competition. Among the likes of Claridge’s, The Connaught or Brown’s, all within five minutes walk from the Conduit Street frontage of The Westbury, the hotel has struggled to break into London’s very top tier.
Which is a perennial puzzle. It’s got a super prime position on the corner of Bond Street, an incredibly wealthy owner and, until recently, its own Michelin starred restaurant.
But the ongoing fallout from the abrupt and acrimonious departure of chef Alyn Williams, which has this week burst back onto the front pages, perhaps helps explain it.
Alyn Williams was recruited by the hotel’s powerful owner, Azad Cola, after he enjoyed one of Williams’ meals at Marcus Wareing at The Berkeley. Within a couple of years The Westbury had itself a Michelin Star restaurant.
A tribunal has now heard that after a decade’s graft, Williams was then unfairly dismissed in September 2019. He received zero notice or any payment for his notice period. All after the chef hosted a private lunch for friends and family at a time when the restaurant wasn’t open.
They are then accused of keeping schtum until after the upcoming Michelin awards
Hotel bosses, said to be working to the orders of Cola himself, unceremoniously let go of their prize Michelin Star chef despite having previously allowing him to host 61 parties, all of which he paid for out of his own pocket and meticulously cleaned up after.
They are then accused of keeping schtum until after the upcoming Michelin awards in order to keep hold of their star for a further year, despite booting their chef.
The party in question included children playing football and, basically, being children. They yuckily drank directly from a Tabascco bottle while scoffing sugar cubes, for instance.
According to evidence heard by the tribunal, “Before starting at the kitchen, (Williams) set up in the main area of the restaurant an improvised football goals, using two restaurant’s armchairs and a small net he had brought with him”.
“Two young boys started to play with a small soft ball kicking it into the improvised goals”.
This is what saw Williams lose his job.
After hearing the arguments (and watching hours of CCTV footage) the Tribunal Judge, Pavel Klimov, decided that although Williams was “30%” to blame, he was not guilty of misconduct and had it was an unfair dismissal, emphasising he was “strongly disapproving the Hotel’s management decisions and actions with respect to the claimant in this case”.
While the judge found Williams’ behaviour was “disrespectful”, and called the childrens’ antics “nothing out of the ordinary” he concluded… “The true reason for the claimant’s dismissal was because the management… was either directly instructed by Mr Cola to dismiss (Williams) or they had understood that Mr Cola wished the claimant to be dismissed and felt obliged to do that to meet Mr Cola’s expectations and regain his trust and fearing repercussions for themselves if they failed to carry out his wishes”
Which sounds more like a gangster film than hotel management. The tribunal has found that this was wrongful dismissal, and will now consider what level of compensation losing a Michelin Star equates to.
But there is something about the culture at The Westbury that doesn’t quite sit right with me. As a journalist it’s impossible to not notice that the hotel seems to cycle through PR firms like most people do undergarments. I think it’s roughly one a year for the past three years, which maybe says more about my underwear drawer.
The picture painted by the tribunal seems to be one of disarray. Most of the hotel’s senior personnel recently left (by choice or otherwise). Meanwhile Alyn Williams had to assume more responsibilities at the hotel aside from his work at the restaurant. He was spreading himself more thinly for the same pay (a classic bad boss move).
The tribunal heard that the hotel’s owner appears to have micromanaged his staff. An example of this saw him personally involved in a bizarre argument about a sound system cable! He seemingly overreacted and suspended his hotel manager.
Read the papers through, don’t take our word for it. But I find it very difficult to take it all in and conclude that The Westbury was a nice workplace.
Which is the broader point here. Hospitality is hard enough as it is, without dealing with idiot bosses. Nobody wants that or needs it. We feel for Alyn Williams, but with such skill we know he’ll be alright.
But for every sous chef, every chamber maid or receptionist working for terrible bosses, we feel for you too. As London’s venues start to reopen we ask that post-lockdown this becomes a kinder industry, without bullying or fear. Because, well, it’s just not worth it.
But that kind of behaviour also almost certainly holding back your restaurant, bar or hotel. If there’s a reason why The Westbury isn’t at the same level as its peers, the answer almost certainly lies within.
Looking for something lighter now? How about London’s Best Afternoon Teas?
