Brand New & Already A Hit: We Review 74 Charlotte Street By Ben Murphy

I didn’t learn to drive until I was over 40 and my first child was about to be born. I realised failing to transport my offspring from hospital to our Hackney home would have been an unforgivable father fail. So off I went to driving school. It took four attempts and I still only managed to gain an automatic licence. The plus side of the struggles I suffered to get my go-kart licence, is that I really appreciate competent people behind the wheel. They fill you with confidence, enable you to relax in the passenger seat and enjoy the ride. Why am I regaling you with tales of my vehicular incompetence? Well. When I walked into 74 Charlotte Street By Ben Murphy, this week’s brand spanking new First Bite review, it reminded me of the feeling of being driven around by a seriously accomplished wheelsmith.

We arrived half an hour early for a mid-week lunch and were smoothly ushered into the upstairs cocktail bar, which, appropriately to my narrative, had that new car smell, of recently planed wood and fancy polish.

Nicola, the razor-thin and super-slick (Italian, natch) bar manager decided I had to try his vanilla infused house martini. We had a brief contretemps about the use of vanilla. I argued it would make the drink sweet and he said it wouldn’t, just more rounded and told me to trust him, which I did.

Reminded me of the feeling of being driven around by a seriously accomplished wheelsmith…

I had the sense of a steady hand behind the wheel as I watched him prepare the drink. As he worked he chatted to me about an artichoke infused martini he’d created at the previous place he’d worked. The choke apparently leant a hazelnutty finish to the drink. The guy clearly knew his onions. On which note, Nicola also does a range of wacky gibsons. They’re made with pickled carrots and other veg supplanting the more ubiquitous silverskin. The martini was top notch. Damn cold, viscous, Tanqueray 10, a twist and a little lemon oil for added citricity, with the vanilla along for the ride to smooth it out.

I could literally have geeked on all afternoon with this beverage master. But we were here for lunch so I dragged myself away from the bar and downstairs to the restaurant proper. 

The guy clearly knew his onions…

We need to get something out the way right now about the dining room at 74 Charlotte Street. It’s down on a level below the ground floor. Usually this would make it a basement space, with all the typical issues this creates, when you sit in subterranean gloom. But, a very clever architect, with a generous budget, has converted what would be a slightly moody space into a natural-light-filled, ersatz ground floor. They achieve this illusion through full height windows. These enable you to look up at people walking down the road. Meanwhile mirrors are fixed so as to give the impression the room goes on beyond the walls. It’s clever, beautiful and simple yet original. It made me smile before I’d even seen the menu. A room I immediately wanted to while away an afternoon in. 

You’ve got a choice at 74 Charlotte Street at lunchtime. Either go for the a la carte which will set you back around £70 for three courses, or a pared down set which comes in at £35 for a starter and main or £39 including a pud. We were in for a full afternoon blowout, so hit the main menu. From which I picked lobster to start followed by BBQ monkfish.

My only regret during lunch was that the outstanding dish of the day happened to be the first course. Perfectly poached Scottish blue lobster perched around a burnt umber coloured disc of a powerful bisque, that tasted like a thousand shellfish had died in its making. The claw was preternaturally sweet, needing the savour of the bisque to offset it. The tail was cooked with the precision you usually only find in top class Japanese joints. The combination of the skill from the kitchen, brought to bear on the world’s best lobster (the diametric opposite of the oversized, flabby crustaceans you find flopping around warmer seas) made for a serious plate of food. It was an epic dish. One of my best plates of the year! And I’ve been out to eat well over a hundred times in 2025. 

One of my best plates of the year!

It’s perhaps no surprise to see this level of cookery. Head chef Ben Murphy has worked at more Michelin three stars than I’ve eaten at. He was mentored by chef god Pierre Koffman! And then ran the kitchen at the superlative (now late) Launceston Place, before setting up shop on Charlotte Street.

After the ludicrous level set by the lobster, it was almost impossible for the main to keep up. And while I thought the monkfish was, again, beautifully cooked, I reckon that if you sell a dish as BBQ, you need a little more of the flavour of the grill to come across. Here the monkfish felt like it had a passing acquaintance with some hot coals but the two hadn’t really got to know one another.

Ben Murphy has worked at more Michelin three stars than I’ve eaten at…

What I did love was the hispi cabbage side, cooked gently, until tender, rather than burnt to a crisp, as is so often the case, generally in trendy Shoreditch kitchens where staff wear leather aprons. It was seasoned with a light touch of vinegar and crumbled fried chicken skin. This gave the cabbage a meaty little shake by the scruff of its neck. I reluctantly offered the last morsel of this epic side dish to my fellow luncher, realising this was the first time in my life I would have fought over a brassica. 

By now I entirely trusted the kitchen, so took the unusual step of actually bothering with pudding. I went for a meringue with olive oil, plums and yoghurt. I chose this on the basis it sounded like it was half savoury, a blessed relief from sugar bomb puds often served up because chefs know that sugar, like butter, makes anything tasty.

The meringue arrived as a delicate tower, atop which sat the finest slices of just ripe (not overripe) plums, with little petal shaped dabs of purple compote dotted around the plate like a pointillist painting. The olive oil brought little flavour to the plum party, but did add a mellow roundness to each bite. The yoghurt added a welcome, lactic, sour note that made the whole thing taste grown up, rather than a children’s party treat, which is what 90% of puddings taste like to me.

By now I entirely trusted the kitchen…

We drank a glass of English dessert wine with our final course which was light, balanced and had a refreshing acidity absent from the majority of stickies, which taste positively diabetic. 

You’ll have got the impression so far that 74 Charlotte Street knocked me for six. And you’d be right. But, and here’s the ridiculous part… This place had been open for exactly two weeks when I went. The team has had barely a fortnight to become acquainted with an entirely new restaurant, and they’re already nailing it. Just imagine what it will be like when they’ve had a little time to bed in.

Find it: 74 Charlotte Street, Fitzrovia, W1T 4QH
Click it: www.74charlottestreet.com
‘Gram it: @74charlottestreet

Ari is our resident restaurant critic and writes (at least) weekly features. They’re all brilliant! So if you fancy a review like this one for 74 Charlotte Street By Ben Murphy, click here… And, that’s not all. We’ve got more reviews here… And for general foodie bits click here… You’re welcome! Check back soon for more reviews!

Wait! Don’t Go, Let Us Help You Get The Best Out Of Life

Never miss out again! Make sure you’re up-to-date on all the latest food, drink and travel news. Sign up for our free weekly edition.

No, thanks!